Market defies gravity: Futures climb despite USDA’s bearish outlook – is export demand trumping production forecasts in dairy’s high-stakes game?
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: CME dairy markets displayed a striking disconnect on April 22, 2025, with futures markets mounting significant gains in direct opposition to recently slashed USDA price forecasts. While cash markets showed modest improvements in butter, barrels, and NDM (each up 0.25¢), the real story unfolded in futures markets, where participants appeared to discount the USDA’s bearish outlook based on increased milk production projections. Global dynamics intensify market complexity, with New Zealand leveraging its duty-free access to China as U.S. exporters face prohibitive tariffs up to 125%, forcing American suppliers to increasingly rely on Mexico and Southeast Asia. The market’s divergent signals create a challenging landscape where producer margins remain under pressure despite seemingly optimistic futures, making risk management strategies increasingly critical heading into mid-2025.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- FUTURES-FORECAST DISCONNECT: A significant gap exists between USDA’s sharply lower price projections (All-Milk forecast down to $21.10/cwt) and strengthening futures markets (May Class III at $18.37/cwt), suggesting traders may be prioritizing current demand signals over supply forecasts.
- GLOBAL TRADE RESHAPING MARKETS: U.S. dairy exports face structural challenges in China due to prohibitive tariffs, while New Zealand benefits from duty-free access, forcing American suppliers to pivot toward Mexico and Southeast Asia, particularly for NDM and skim milk powder.
- CHEESE MARKET DYNAMICS: High trading volume (11 loads each for blocks and barrels) with unfilled bids at close indicates active price discovery and potential buyer support emerging after recent declines, though readily available milk supplies in the Midwest continue flowing into cheese vats.
- PRODUCER MARGIN PRESSURE: Despite potential easing in feed costs (May Corn at $4.75/bushel), USDA’s downward price revisions signal continued margin compression for producers through 2025, emphasizing the critical importance of proactive risk management strategies.
- PRODUCT-SPECIFIC SENTIMENT: Market sentiment varies dramatically by product – cautious in cheese, patient in well-supplied butter, and optimistic in export-driven NDM – creating a fragmented outlook requiring product-specific strategies.
Dairy markets showed modest gains in cash butter, barrels, and Nonfat Dry Milk today, while futures posted significant advances. This upward momentum contrasts recent bearish USDA price forecasts, suggesting market participants may focus on current demand signals rather than longer-term supply projections.
Key Price Changes & Market Trends
Today’s CME cash dairy markets displayed mixed results, with three products posting slight gains while cheese blocks and dry whey remained unchanged. Futures markets demonstrated more significant strength across the board.
Product | Closing Price ($/lb) | Change from Yesterday (¢/lb) | Trades | Bids | Offers |
Butter | 2.3225 | +0.25 | 5 | 0 | 2 |
Cheddar Block | 1.7750 | NC | 11 | 5 | 0 |
Cheddar Barrel | 1.8100 | +0.25 | 11 | 3 | 0 |
NDM Grade A | 1.1850 | +0.25 | 1 | 1 | 3 |
Dry Whey | 0.4775 | NC | 0 | 2 | 1 |
Commentary on Price Movements
Butter: Prices increased slightly by 0.25 cents to $2.3225/lb on moderate volume. This modest recovery follows Monday’s decline despite market commentary suggesting ample inventories and potentially softer food service demand compared to last year. While international demand provides some support, domestic supply factors remain the primary influence.
Cheddar Blocks: Prices held steady at $1.7750/lb despite high trading volume (11 loads) following Monday’s significant 6-cent drop. Notably, blocks traded as low as $1.7400 before recovering to close unchanged, indicating buyers stepped in to absorb the selling pressure. Readily available milk supplies in the Midwest continue to flow into cheese vats, while post-Easter demand has been described as steady but not particularly robust.
Cheddar Barrels: Barrel cheese gained 0.25 cents to close at $1.8100/lb, also on active volume, with 11 trades executed. Barrels maintain their premium over blocks, a relationship that has seen volatility recently. The upcoming Federal Milk Marketing Order changes, set to remove barrel prices from component pricing formulas effective June 1, 2025, add complexity to market dynamics.
Nonfat Dry Milk: Grade A NDM firmed by 0.25 cents to $1.1850/lb, building on Monday’s 1-cent gain, though on very light volume with only one trade recorded. Market strength continues to be attributed to firm international skim milk powder prices and robust export demand, particularly from Mexico and Southeast Asian markets.
Dry Whey: Prices remained unchanged at $0.4775/lb with no trades executed, following a half-cent decline on Monday. The market commentary describes the whey market as relatively balanced but potentially unstable, with buyers hesitant to build inventory and sellers reluctant to offload volumes at current values.
Volume and Trading Activity
Trading activity today was heavily concentrated in the cheese complex, with both Cheddar Blocks and Barrels trading 11 loads each. This high activity level, particularly in blocks that held firm despite early pressure, suggests considerable two-way interest and potentially active position adjustment by market participants.
Butter experienced moderate activity, with five trades completed, while the powder markets were notably quiet. NDM saw just a single trade, and Dry Whey recorded zero transactions, indicating these markets are currently less driven by spot market dynamics and more influenced by factors like export commitments.
The bid/offer analysis at market close provides additional insights:
- Cheese: Both blocks (5 bids / 0 offers) and barrels (3 bids / 0 offers) closed with unfilled bids and no offers, indicating buying interest was present at the closing prices, though sellers were unwilling to transact at those levels.
- Butter: The close saw zero bids against two offers, pointing to available selling interest above $2.3225 but a lack of corresponding buyer interest.
- NDM: One bid was posted against three offers, suggesting more selling interest than buying interest at the $1.1850 level despite the price firming earlier.
- Dry Whey: Two bids and one offer indicated relatively balanced interest, though this did not translate into completed trades.
Global Context
International dairy market dynamics continue to significantly influence U.S. prices, shaped by divergent supply trends, shifting demand patterns, and evolving trade policies.
Supply Conditions
New Zealand: Production remains robust, tracking higher year-over-year for the season-to-date. Kiwi exporters benefit significantly from their free trade agreement with China, enjoying duty-free access that solidifies their dominant position in that key market. Producers focus on efficiency and shift exports towards higher-value products beyond powders.
European Union: Milk production faces headwinds, with forecasts pointing towards declines or stagnation due to tightening environmental regulations, lower cow numbers, and lingering effects of disease outbreaks like the Bluetongue Virus. Despite lower milk availability, EU processors prioritize cheese production to meet solid domestic and export demand.
China: Domestic milk production is contracting, with forecasts predicting a 2.6% decline in 2025 after years of expansion. Farmgate milk prices have fallen below production costs for many producers, discouraging expansion. This decline supports the need for imports, although the government maintains a long-term goal of increasing self-sufficiency.
Demand & Trade Flows
China remains a critical but complex market. A recent surge in imports across whey, cheese, and whole milk powder was likely influenced by buyers attempting to secure supply ahead of escalating trade tensions and tariffs. The U.S. faces significant challenges, with retaliatory tariffs reaching as high as 125% on some dairy products, effectively limiting access for American suppliers while competitors like New Zealand benefit.
Markets like Mexico and Southeast Asia have become increasingly vital for U.S. dairy exports, particularly for NDM and skim milk powder, providing crucial outlets given the difficulties in accessing the Chinese market.
The broader trade environment remains uncertain, with potential shifts in U.S. global trade alignment potentially introducing new barriers or challenges. The ongoing US-China trade tensions are a dominant factor shaping feed markets and dairy export opportunities.
Forecasts and Analysis
Recent forecasts from the USDA present a challenging outlook for U.S. dairy prices, contrasting with the relative strength observed in futures markets today.
USDA Price & Production Forecasts
The USDA’s April 2025 World Agricultural Supply and Demand Estimates (WASDE) report significantly lowered price expectations for the year. Key 2025 average price forecasts include:
- All-Milk: $21.10/cwt (down $0.50 from the March forecast and $1.95 from January)
- Class III Milk: $17.60/cwt (down $0.35 from March)
- Class IV Milk: $18.20/cwt (down $0.60 from March)
- Cheddar Cheese: $1.790/lb (down 2.0 cents from March)
- Butter: $2.445/lb (down 7.0 cents from March)
- NDM: $1.220/lb (down 3.5 cents from March)
- Dry Whey: $0.510/lb (down 1.5 cents from March)
The primary driver for these downward revisions was an increase in the 2025 milk production forecast to 226.9 billion pounds, representing a 0.7-billion-pound increase from the March estimate. This was attributed to expectations for higher cow numbers and improved milk yield per cow, reversing earlier forecasts that projected lower production.
Feed Costs
Feed futures saw some weakness today, with May Corn settling around $4.75/bushel and May Soybean Meal near $292.10/ton. In the long term, USDA expects overall feed costs in 2025 to be lower than in recent years. However, softer international soybean demand (partly due to China tariffs potentially shifting acres to corn) and strong corn export demand complicate the feed price outlook.
Analysis & Implications
A significant disconnect exists between the sharply lower USDA price forecasts and today’s upward movement in CME futures (e.g., May Class III settled at $18.37/cwt, May Class IV at $18.62/cwt). This divergence suggests market participants may discount the USDA’s increased production forecast, perhaps placing more weight on strong export demand signals (especially for powders) or technical market factors.
Regardless of potentially easing feed costs, the USDA’s milk price forecast reductions point towards a significant margin squeeze for dairy producers through 2025. The milk-feed ratio was reported to be unfavorably low earlier in the year, and the latest forecasts reinforce concerns about profitability, underscoring the importance of risk management strategies.
Market Sentiment
Market sentiment in the dairy complex appears fragmented and generally cautious, reflecting the divergent product trends and uncertainty surrounding demand and forecasts.
Product-Specific Sentiment
Cheese: Sentiment is mixed. While buyers demonstrated support today by defending price levels after Monday’s drop, underlying caution persists. One analyst noted, “Buyers seem hesitant to build inventory at current prices, awaiting clearer demand signals.” Concerns linger about ample milk availability for cheese production and potentially sluggish post-Easter retail movement. Recent export strength offers a counterpoint.
Butter: The prevailing feeling is that the market remains well-supplied, leading buyers to be patient. Comfortable inventory levels appear to be capping upside potential, even though prices remain historically elevated.
NDM: Sentiment here is more optimistic, driven largely by export activity. A trader highlighted, “We’re seeing ongoing, consistent inquiries from Southeast Asian buyers that keep the export pipeline active and support domestic prices.” This optimistic view persists despite lower official price forecasts.
General Market Mood
Broader economic concerns weigh on overall sentiment. Factors such as ongoing trade tensions, persistently high interest rates, and inflation dampen consumer confidence and potentially impact household spending on dairy products. Market volatility remains a key theme across all dairy products.
The market mood reflects a split: optimism grounded in strong international demand for milk powders contrasts with wariness regarding the domestic supply/demand balance for cheese and butter, particularly given economic headwinds. The disconnect between strengthening futures and bearish USDA forecasts adds a layer of uncertainty to the overall outlook.
Closing Summary & Recommendations
In summary, the CME dairy markets on April 22 presented a picture of divergence. Cash markets saw modest gains in butter, barrels, and NDM, while blocks and whey remained unchanged. Trading was notably active in the cheese complex, but it was very thin in powders. Futures markets posted solid gains, moving counter to the recent significantly lowered price forecasts from the USDA, which were based on expectations of increased milk production.
Recommendations for Stakeholders
Producers: The divergence between current futures strength and the bearish USDA outlook warrants close monitoring. Given the significant downward revisions in official price forecasts, proactive risk management remains crucial, even with potentially easing feed costs. Pay close attention to export demand signals, especially for milk powders, as this appears to be a key pillar of current market support. Be prepared for continued margin pressure as forecasted in recent reports.
Traders: Acknowledge the technical strength shown in futures markets today but exercise caution given the bearish fundamental backdrop painted by USDA supply projections. Watch cheese market spreads and trading volumes for signs of follow-through or reversal. The strength of NDM appears to be heavily reliant on sustained export momentum. Butter and Dry Whey seem caught in a balance, potentially awaiting fresh catalysts for a directional move.
Analysts: The key focus should be reconciling the current futures market optimism with the USDA’s pessimistic supply/price outlook. Closely track upcoming export data releases and domestic retail and food service demand indicators to gauge whether current market strength is sustainable. Monitoring ongoing global supply developments (particularly in the EU and NZ) and the impact of trade policies (especially US-China relations) will be critical for assessing future market direction.
Learn more:
- Global Dairy Market Trends 2025: European Decline, US Expansion Reshaping Industry Landscape
- U.S. Dairy Exports Shatter Billion-Pound Barrier
- Global Dairy Market Analysis: Butter Strength, SMP Weakness Signal Strategic Opportunities
Join the Revolution!
Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Daily for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.