Your MUN levels are flushing profits away. Discover why protein percentages lie and the NFC/CP ratio is your new profit engine.
Here’s a fact that will make many feed companies uncomfortable: that expensive protein supplement you’re feeding your cows? Up to 70% of it is being pissed away – literally. And while your nutritionist keeps tweaking your crude protein percentages, they’re missing what matters.
For decades, we’ve been told that managing Milk Urea Nitrogen (MUN) is primarily about adjusting dietary protein. Simple formula, right? High MUN? Cut protein. Low MUN? Add protein.
Bullshit.
The Journal of Dairy Science recently published a groundbreaking meta-analysis examining 48 research studies spanning 20 years, proving what forward-thinking dairymen have all suspected – the protein story is only half the truth. (Assessing milk urea nitrogen as an indicator of protein nutrition and nitrogen utilization efficiency: A meta-analysis) The real game-changer isn’t just your protein level but the balance between your non-fiber carbohydrates (NFC) and crude protein (CP).
“We’ve been laser-focused on crude protein percentages when we should have been talking about the NFC/CP ratio all along,” admits one industry nutritionist who requested anonymity to speak candidly. “It’s like we’ve been giving farmers a hammer when they needed a complete toolbox.”
Are You Throwing Money at the Wrong Problem?
Let’s cut through the crap. Your MUN numbers aren’t just some technicalities on your milk test report – they’re a direct window into your wallet and environmental footprint.
Think about it: When your MUN hits 17 mg/dL instead of the optimal 12 mg/dL, your cows dump approximately 77 EXTRA grams of nitrogen into the environment PER COW, EVERY DAY. For a 500-cow dairy, that’s 38.5 kg of additional nitrogen daily – over 14 metric tons annually!
You might as well take $50,000 in cash and spread it across your manure pit.
Here’s what your feed rep won’t tell you: The research shows that cows with optimal MUN levels (8-16 mg/dL) typically consume diets with an NFC/CP ratio between 2.15 and 3.60. Fall below 2.15, and MUN skyrockets above 16 mg/dL. Push above 3.60, and MUN drops below 8 mg/dL.
But have you EVER had a nutritionist talk to you about your NFC/CP ratio? I’ll bet my last milk check, and the answer is no.
The Industry’s Dirty Little Protein Secret
For years, the feed industry has pushed a straightforward narrative: more protein equals more milk. It’s convenient, easy to understand, and – most importantly for them – keeps you buying expensive protein sources.
But the meta-analysis exposes this protein-pushing approach for what it is – a half-truth at best and a deliberate misdirection at worst.
The data reveals what the feed companies don’t want you to know: there’s NO consistent relationship between MUN levels and milk yield. The correlation between MUN and milk production was weak and statistically insignificant (r=0.10). Similarly, correlations between MUN and milk protein percentage (r=-0.08) and milk protein yield (r=-0.05) were practically non-existent.
Let that sink in for a minute. Were you told to keep protein high “for production” during those times? The science doesn’t back it up.
What does the science show? The NFC/CP ratio explains a staggering 68.1% variation in MUN levels across diverse feeding programs and production systems – significantly more than either NFC or CP alone. It also explains 71.1% of the variation in urinary nitrogen excretion, making it a potent predictor of nitrogen wastage.
Are you feeding based on dated protein recommendations instead of balanced NFC/CP ratios? If so, you’re leaving money on the table while polluting more than necessary.
Your New Magic Number: The NFC/CP Ratio
Forget complicated ration-balancing software for a moment. Here’s your new dairy management cheat code: maintain your dietary NFC/CP ratio between 2.15 and 3.60 to keep your MUN levels in the optimal 8-16 mg/dL range.
The calculation is dead simple:
- Take the percentage of non-fiber carbohydrates in your TMR (dry matter basis)
- Divide by the percentage of crude protein
- That’s your NFC/CP ratio
For example, a diet with 42% NFC and 16% CP has an NFC/CP ratio of 2.63, likely resulting in MUN levels around 11-13 mg/dL.
Why does this work better than just focusing on protein? Because it directly addresses what’s happening in the rumen and where the real action occurs. The NFC fraction (primarily starches and sugars) provides readily available energy that rumen microbes use to capture ammonia from protein degradation. When energy availability is synchronized with protein breakdown, nitrogen is efficiently incorporated into microbial biomass rather than wasted as urea.
The 8-16 Rule: Are You Inside or Outside the Money Zone?
The meta-analysis provides a practical target: keep your herd’s MUN between 8-16 mg/dL. This range represents the sweet spot where nitrogen utilization is optimized while supporting production.
When MUN exceeds 16 mg/dL:
- Your cows are excreting excessive nitrogen in urine
- Nitrogen utilization efficiency is suboptimal
- Your NFC/CP ratio is probably below 2.15
- Environmental nitrogen loading is increased
- You may be suppressing milk fat synthesis (the research found a significant negative correlation between MUN and both milk fat percentage (r=-0.30) and yield (r=-0.22))
When MUN falls below 8 mg/dL:
- Your NFC/CP ratio is likely above 3.60
- Potential insufficient ammonia in the rumen for optimal microbial growth
- Possible limitations on microbial protein synthesis
- Risk of inadequate metabolizable protein
Notably, the meta-analysis showed that when MUN ranges from 8-16 mg/dL, milk yield or protein synthesis had no consistent significant impact. This contradicts the conventional wisdom that higher MUN (and, by extension, higher CP diets) is necessary for maximizing production.
Your Banker Would Fire Your Nutritionist
Let’s talk money. The dairy business runs on razor-thin margins, yet we’re collectively wasting millions on inefficient protein utilization.
Consider this scenario: Your 500-cow dairy feeds a 17.5% CP diet with 38% NFC (NFC/CP ratio of 2.17), resulting in a bulk tank MUN of 17 mg/dL. After reading this article, you adjust to 16.5% CP and 43% NFC (NFC/CP ratio of 2.61). MUN drops to 13 mg/dL without any production loss.
The financial impact:
- $0.15/cow/day savings in feed costs = $27,375 annually
- 4 mg/dL reduction in MUN = approximately 22.8 tons less nitrogen excreted annually
- Potential improvements in reproductive efficiency due to reduced blood urea nitrogen
- Reduced risk of future environmental compliance costs
If your banker saw what’s happening to protein efficiency in most dairies, they’d have a stroke. The meta-analysis revealed an average nitrogen utilization efficiency of 29.6% across studies. Would you tolerate any other input being used at only 30% efficiency? Hell no. So why are we complacent about nitrogen efficiency?
Are You Still Stuck in the Protein Percentage Mindset?
Let’s be brutally honest – the dairy nutrition world is full of sacred cows that need slaughtering. The fixation on crude protein percentages is at the top of the list.
How many times have you heard:
- “You need at least 17% crude protein for high producers.”
- “You can’t cut below 16% CP without sacrificing milk yield.”
- “Higher protein means more milk.”
These protein-centric feeding approaches aren’t just outdated; they cost you serious money.
The meta-analysis data proves what progressive nutritionists have suspected for years: it’s not about the absolute protein percentage but the balance between energy and protein in the rumen.
The industry’s protein percentage fixation has created a massive blind spot: we’ve been focusing on the wrong ratio. Instead of protein-to-energy ratios, the NFC/CP ratio more directly addresses the rumen function – where the real action of feed conversion happens.
What Your Feed Company Doesn’t Want You to Ask
Next time your feed rep is in your office, ask them these four questions:
- What’s my current NFC/CP ratio, and is it in the optimal range of 2.15-3.60?
- How much nitrogen are my cows excreting based on our current MUN levels?
- Can we reformulate to optimize the NFC/CP ratio rather than focusing just on protein percentage?
- How much would I save annually by reducing MUN by 3-4 points?
If they can’t answer these questions, maybe it’s time to find someone who can. The industry is changing, and the old protein-pushing approach is being exposed for what it is – an oversimplified model that benefits feed companies more than farmers.
The meta-analysis clarifies that significant reductions in nitrogen excretion are possible without compromising production, provided the right balance of energy and protein is maintained. This creates the rare opportunity for an environmental win that’s also an economic win, reducing both nitrogen pollution and feed costs simultaneously.
Beyond Holstein: A Note of Caution
Let’s be clear about one limitation of this meta-analysis: it focused exclusively on Holstein cows. This was a deliberate choice by the researchers to eliminate breed as a confounding variable, given that different breeds are known to have different baseline MUN levels.
If you’re milking Jerseys, Brown Swiss, Ayrshires, or other breeds, the specific numeric targets (8-16 mg/dL, NFC/CP ratio of 2.15-3.60) should be applied cautiously. The fundamental biological relationships of the importance of energy-protein balance in the rumen and the connection between MUN and urinary nitrogen excretion likely hold across breeds, but the exact optimal ranges may differ.
The core principles uncovered in this meta-analysis are the importance of energy-protein synchrony, the strong link between MUN and nitrogen excretion, and the weak relationship between MUN and milk yield/protein-likely transcend breed differences. Apply the concepts with appropriate adjustments for your herd’s genetics.
Your Action Plan: Turning Knowledge into Money
Here’s your Monday morning game plan to start capturing the benefits of this revolutionary approach:
- Know Your Numbers
- Pull your last 6-12 months of bulk tank MUN data
- Request individual cow MUN data, if available, from your DHI provider
- Get your current TMR analyzed for CP and NFC content
- Calculate your current NFC/CP ratio
- Consult Your Team
- Challenge your nutritionist to explain your current NFC/CP ratio
- Discuss the feasibility of adjusting either NFC or CP to optimize the ratio
- Consider the economic implications of the proposed changes
- Set Clear Targets
- Establish your target MUN range within the 8-16 mg/dL spectrum
- Define the corresponding NFC/CP ratio target (between 2.15 and 3.60)
- Create a timeline for implementation and evaluation
- Implement Strategically
- Make incremental adjustments to the diet
- Monitor MUN, production, components, and feed costs during transitions
- Allow adequate adaptation time before making additional changes
- Document results for future reference
The Bullvine Bottom Line
The dairy industry has continuously evolved through scientific innovation. This comprehensive meta-analysis of MUN, dietary factors, and nitrogen utilization isn’t just an academic exercise – it’s a practical roadmap to better profitability and sustainability.
Will you keep feeding as your grandfather did, or are you ready to capitalize on cutting-edge nutritional science?
The approach is straightforward: focus on the NFC/CP ratio, target MUN between 8-16 mg/dL, and monitor nitrogen efficiency. You’ll not only prepare for the future, but you’ll also boost your bottom line today.
Your MUN readings aren’t just numbers on a report – they’re dollar signs with plus or minus in front of them. The choice is yours: continue overpaying for a protein that ends up in your lagoon or optimize your NFC/CP ratio and start keeping more of that money in your pocket.
Conventional wisdom is wrong. The science is precise. The only question is: are you bold enough to change?
Key Takeaways:
- NFC/CP Ratio > Protein Percentage: The balance of non-fiber carbs to protein (2.15–3.60) drives MUN efficiency, not crude protein levels alone.
- Stop Flushing Cash: Every 1 mg/dL MUN reduction saves ~15.4g nitrogen/cow/day-$27K+/year for 500 cows.
- Milk Yield Myth Busted: No link between MUN and production-optimize ratios without fearing yield drops.
- Environmental Win-Win: Lower MUN = less nitrogen pollution + compliance with tightening regulations.
- Action Now: Calculate your NFC/CP ratio, target 8–16 mg/dL MUN, and demand better from your nutritionist.
Executive Summary:
A groundbreaking meta-analysis of 48 studies reveals that dairy farmers are wasting thousands on inefficient protein use by focusing solely on crude protein percentages. The real key to profitability and sustainability lies in balancing non-fiber carbohydrates (NFC) and crude protein (CP) through the NFC/CP ratio. Maintaining this ratio between 2.15–3.60 optimizes Milk Urea Nitrogen (MUN) levels (8–16 mg/dL), slashing nitrogen waste by up to 14 metric tons annually for a 500-cow herd. Contrary to industry dogma, milk yield isn’t tied to high protein, and reducing MUN via NFC/CP balancing improves feed efficiency without sacrificing production. The article challenges feed companies’ protein-pushing narratives and urges farmers to adopt data-driven strategies for nitrogen efficiency.
Learn more:
- Research Shows How to Slash Nitrate Leaching by 28% While Boosting Milk Protein
Explore how breeding for low MUNBV cows reduces environmental impact and increases milk protein premiums-a genetic game-changer for profitability. - Optimizing Protein Levels in Dairy Cow Diets
Dive into the science of balancing crude protein with amino acids to cut nitrogen waste while maintaining lactation performance. - Strategies for Increasing Nitrogen Efficiency in Dairy Herds
Practical steps to improve nitrogen use through ration balancing, forage management, and precision feeding-essential reading for eco-conscious producers.
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.
