US-Japan trade talks stall as tariffs clash with political red lines. Dairy exports face uphill battle amid protracted negotiations.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The US-Japan trade standoff has become a “long game” due to conflicting priorities: the US demands agricultural market access (notably rice) while Japan seeks removal of auto tariffs under Trump’s “Liberation Day” framework. Japan’s dairy sector highlights US disadvantages, as competitors like the EU and CPTPP nations enjoy preferential tariffs. Domestic politics, including Japan’s July 2025 elections, freeze progress, with Tokyo opting for strategic patience over risky concessions. The impasse risks lasting damage to bilateral trade, leaving industries like dairy navigating volatile export markets and structural barriers.
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
- Tariffs as leverage: US uses auto/steel tariffs (25%) to pressure Japan, which refuses to “sacrifice agriculture for cars.”
- Dairy’s double bind: US cheese exports surge 59% in Japan (Jan 2025), but CPTPP/EU deals give rivals long-term tariff advantages.
- Political paralysis: Japan’s July elections and LDP’s farm lobby make agricultural concessions (e.g., rice) a non-starter.
- Strategic patience: Japan risks 24% reciprocal tariffs post-July rather than accept a “bad deal,” prolonging negotiations.
- Global ripple effects: US absence from CPTPP costs dairy exporters $1.3B over a decade, per USDEC projections.
US dairy exporters face a paradoxical market where cheese exports to Japan surged by 59% in January, while deeper structural disadvantages against competitors continue to grow. As US-Japan trade negotiations evolve into a protracted standoff with no end, American dairy producers need sophisticated strategies to navigate this $400 million export market, especially as competitors from Australia, New Zealand, and the EU continue advancing under more favorable trade terms.
Why is the US-Japan Trade Dispute Taking So Long to Resolve?
The current impasse between Japan and the United States stems directly from the “Liberation Day” tariffs announced this April. This unprecedented policy established a minimum 10% tariff on virtually all imports to the United States, with approximately 60 nations facing additional “reciprocal” tariffs based on their trade surpluses.
For Japan, the consequences were particularly severe. Beyond the baseline 10% tariff, Japan faces a potential 24% reciprocal tariff based on its substantial trade surplus with the US. While this higher rate is suspended until July 2025, the implementation threat looms large over negotiations. Even more concerning for Tokyo, the US imposed specific 25% tariffs on automobiles and auto parts under Section 232 (national security grounds), directly targeting a sector that accounts for approximately one-third of Japan’s exports to the United States.
This creates an inherently asymmetric negotiating environment. Japanese trade czar Ryosei Akazawa has made it clear that Japan’s position is non-negotiable: talks cannot proceed without addressing all tariffs currently in place, including the baseline 10% “Liberation Day” tariffs, the potential 24% reciprocal rate, and the sectoral levies on automotive products, steel, and aluminum.
Meanwhile, the US approach focuses on negotiating the terms under which the threatened 24% reciprocal tariff might be avoided or reduced, treating the baseline 10% tariff as a new normal rather than a temporary measure. This fundamental disconnect creates what one analyst described as a negotiating environment where “the two sides are talking around each other.”
Why Should Dairy Producers Care About Auto Tariffs?
You might wonder what Japanese cars have to do with your dairy operation. Here’s the cold, hard reality: As long as the automotive dispute remains unresolved, progress on agricultural market access, including dairy, will likely remain stalled.
For Japan, removing the 25% automotive tariff represents a non-negotiable objective in any comprehensive agreement. Prime Minister Ishiba has made this clear, stating that alternatives like the low-tariff quota system negotiated with Britain would be “unworkable” for Japan given its much higher export volume (over 1.3 million vehicles annually compared to Britain’s 100,000).
When addressing potential agricultural concessions, Ishiba didn’t mince words, stating bluntly, “We will not sacrifice agriculture for cars.” This intransigence reflects political realities in Japan, where the agricultural lobby remains powerful and Upper House elections loom in July 2025.
What this means for your operation: The automotive dispute impacts the timeline for potential dairy market access gains. Understanding this connection helps explain why progress feels frustratingly slow and why July 2025 (post-Japanese elections) represents the earliest realistic window for meaningful movement.
How Are US Dairy Exports Performing Despite These Disadvantages?
Japan remains a critical market worth nearly 0 million annually for US dairy exporters. Recent trade data reveals fascinating volatility across different product categories that smart operators can leverage for strategic advantage.
January 2025 figures showed a dramatic 59% increase in US cheese exports to Japan, an additional 2,133 metric tons, representing the strongest volume since June 2014. However, this positive trend was counterbalanced by steep declines in other categories. Exports of low-protein whey plummeted by 69% (-1,474 MT) during the same period, while skim milk powder exports dropped by 72% (-1,470 MT) compared to January 2024’s strong volume.
Conversely, demand for high-protein whey products (WPC80+) saw a remarkable uptick, with US exports more than doubling to 2,009 MT, marking the largest single-month purchase since September 2023. This mixed performance highlights the complex competitive landscape shaped by Japan’s extensive network of trade agreements.
The Competitive Reality: US vs. CPTPP/EU Access in Japan
| Dairy Product | US Access (Post-USJTA) | CPTPP/EU Access in Japan | Implications for US Producers |
| Cheese | Tariffs up to 40% phased out over 15 years; 150 MT CSQ for processed cheese | Faster and broader tariff elimination (29.8% tariff being eliminated over 16 years) | Widening price disadvantage; requires premium positioning to offset tariff gap |
| Low-Protein Whey | CSQ of 5,400-9,000 MT; over-quota tariffs eliminated in 5-20 years | Broader duty-free access for some categories | January’s 69% export drop reflects competitive pressures; focus on in-quota opportunities |
| High-Protein Whey (WPC80+) | Whey protein tariff (2.9%) eliminated immediately | Similar benefits under CPTPP/JEEPA | Strong growth area despite competition; capitalize on immediate duty-free status |
Why this competitive gap matters: The challenges facing US dairy exporters in Japan can be traced directly to a critical strategic decision made during Trump’s first term, withdrawing from the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP). While the US stepped away, other major dairy exporters moved forward with the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), securing preferential access to Japan’s market that the US now lacks.
The 2019 US-Japan Trade Agreement (USJTA) was intended to partially mitigate these disadvantages, providing preferential tariff treatment for more than 80% of US dairy exports to Japan. However, this limited agreement can’t fully compensate for the comprehensive benefits competitors enjoy under broader trade pacts. The current impasse means these structural disadvantages persist, further complicating the US dairy’s competitive position.
Is Japan’s Domestic Dairy Industry Collapsing?
Japan’s domestic dairy sector faces significant structural challenges that create genuine opportunities for international suppliers. The number of Japanese dairy farms has steadily declined, falling below 10,000 in October 2024, a milestone low since data collection began in 2005. Nearly half of these producers consider exiting the industry due to economic pressures, including rising input costs and the weak yen.
This decline stems from multiple factors:
- An aging farmer demographic with inadequate succession planning
- High initial investment costs create barriers for new entrants
- Difficulties acquiring land in a space-limited country
- Persistent labor shortages in rural areas
- The demanding 365-day-a-year nature of dairy farming
Despite these challenges, Japan maintains a robust system of protections for its domestic dairy industry, including complex import quotas and tariff structures. The paradox is striking while Japan’s domestic milk production capacity shrinks, creating apparent opportunities for exporters, the political sensitivity surrounding agricultural protection makes significant market opening difficult.
Strategic Positioning: Winning Despite the Tariff Disadvantage
The protracted nature of US-Japan trade negotiations doesn’t mean dairy exporters should adopt a wait-and-see approach. On the contrary, the current environment demands strategic positioning and targeted market development. Here’s how forward-thinking companies can succeed:
Target High-Growth Product Categories
The dramatic growth in cheese exports (+59%) and high-protein whey (+100%) demonstrates that certain product categories can thrive despite tariff disadvantages. Focus your market development efforts on segments where US products maintain competitive advantages in quality, functionality, or specialized applications. The January 2025 data clarifies that not all dairy categories face the same competitive pressures and thrive despite the structural disadvantages.
Develop Premium Positioning Strategies
With Japanese per capita cheese consumption at just 2.40 kg (2023)-compared to over 12 kg in most Western countries- there’s substantial room for growth in specialty and premium segments. Tourism has emerged as a significant driver of dairy demand, boosting consumption particularly in the foodservice and confectionery sectors. Despite relatively flat liquid milk consumption, western-style cuisine, specialty coffee culture, and bakery products have all contributed to increased dairy utilization.
Cultivate Strong Distribution Partnerships
In Japan’s complex distribution landscape, strong partnerships with importers and distributors who understand local market dynamics are essential. These relationships can help navigate non-tariff barriers and provide valuable market intelligence despite the absence of a comprehensive trade agreement. This becomes even more crucial when competing against suppliers from countries with preferential trade terms, as distributors can help position your products where the tariff disadvantage matters least.
Leverage USJTA Provisions Strategically
While the US-Japan Trade Agreement is limited compared to CPTPP and Japan-EU Economic Partnership Agreement (JEEPA), it does provide specific benefits worth exploiting. US dairy exporters should ensure they maximize utilization of country-specific tariff-rate quotas (CSQs) and other preferential provisions. For example, the 150 MT CSQ for processed cheese and the growing CSQ for whey (from 5,400 to 9,000 MT) represent valuable opportunities, especially when filled with higher-margin specialty products.
The Bottom Line: Preparing for the Long Haul
The “long game” nature of US-Japan trade negotiations creates challenges and opportunities for dairy industry stakeholders. Without a comprehensive resolution of the current trade impasse, US dairy will continue facing structural challenges compared to EU, Australia, and New Zealand competitors. However, the recent strong performance in cheese exports demonstrates that targeted success remains possible even within these constraints.
As both countries settle in for what appears to be a prolonged negotiating process with no clear end in sight, the winners in Japan’s valuable dairy import market will be those who can navigate this complex political environment while meeting evolving consumer demands with differentiated, high-quality offerings that transcend price-based competition alone.
Don’t expect any quick resolution to the broader tariff disputes, especially with Japan’s Upper House elections in July creating a political firewall against agricultural concessions. Instead, focus on what you can control: product quality, specialized offerings, and building relationships to position your dairy business for success regardless of how the trade negotiations ultimately unfold.
The industry should also maintain a unified voice advocating for more comprehensive market access in future trade talks. While individual companies must adapt to the current reality, collective action through industry associations can help ensure dairy’s interests aren’t overlooked when automotive and other disputes eventually move toward resolution. The fundamental goal should remain gaining equivalent access to what our competitors already enjoy under CPTPP and JEEPA- anything less puts US dairy at a lasting competitive disadvantage in one of Asia’s most valuable markets.
Learn more:
- U.S. Dairy Exports Surge as Global Buyers Raid American Bargain Barn – Explores record cheese sales to Japan and how price advantages are driving US dairy export growth in early 2025.
- U.S.-U.K. Trade Deal: Why Dairy Got Left in the Holding Pen While Beef and Ethanol Got Premium Classification – Provides valuable context on how dairy is faring in other recent trade negotiations during the “Liberation Day” tariff era.
- Why Japan’s Tourism Revival is a Golden Opportunity for the U.S. Dairy Industry – Examines how Japan’s post-pandemic tourism surge is specifically driving demand for cheese and butter, creating export opportunities for US dairy producers.
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.
