Archive for global dairy exports

Why African Dairy’s $74B Boom Bypasses Local Farmers – And What It Means for Global Markets

African farmers: $21/cow/year. African dairy market: $74 billion. The money’s flowing—just not to farmers.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Africa’s dairy market will reach $74 billion by 2035, yet local farmers capture just 2-3% while 80% flows to imports. The paradox: Africa owns 20% of global cattle but produces only 5% of milk, with farmers earning $21-200 per cow annually versus $1,800 breakeven in developed markets. Multinationals dominate through powder reconstitution rather than local sourcing—it’s cheaper to import at 5% tariffs than to collect from smallholders who produce 1-3 liters daily. East Africa proves transformation is possible, with Kenya and Rwanda becoming exporters through cooperatives and smart policy, while West Africa remains import-dependent. For global dairy professionals, success means abandoning Western models for adapted genetics, intermediate technologies, and hybrid strategies that match Africa’s unique reality—not replicating Wisconsin in Lagos.

African dairy market

At a recent dairy conference, I found myself in conversation with several producers interested in African opportunities. They’d all seen the same presentations—Africa’s dairy market reaching $74 billion by 2035, up from $61.7 billion today, according to IndexBox’s November 2024 analysis. “Last frontier for dairy,” one called it.

After spending the past few months examining the dynamics on the ground, I’ve come to realize we’re dealing with something far more complex than most investment presentations suggest. Africa isn’t developing a conventional dairy sector like we’ve seen elsewhere. Instead, it’s creating a unique hybrid system that challenges our traditional understanding of dairy market development.

The economic paradox of African dairy: A $74 billion market where local farmers earning $21 per cow annually capture just 2.5% of growth

The Market Growth Story: Real but Different

Understanding the Demographic Shift

The fundamentals driving growth are undeniably strong. McKinsey’s consumer research from June 2023 documented that Africa’s urban middle class is expanding from 300 million today to 500 million by 2035. That’s a demographic shift comparable to adding the entire U.S. population as potential dairy consumers.

What’s particularly noteworthy is how consumption patterns are evolving. Ethiopia’s Ministry of Agriculture reported in their 2024 sector review that urban dairy spending has accelerated dramatically, especially among middle-income households. Kenya’s Dairy Board projects 5.8% annual consumption growth through 2030—that’s faster than most Asian markets at a similar stage of development.

The Import Reality Check

Yet here’s where the story becomes more nuanced. The FAO’s November 2025 Africa Food Security Report reveals that approximately 80% of this consumption growth is met by imported dairy products and reconstituted powders, not by expanded local production.

Africa’s fundamental dairy paradox: controlling 20% of the world’s cattle but producing just 5% of global milk while importing 80% of consumption

“The continent currently produces just 5% of global milk while maintaining 20% of the world’s cattle.”

According to UN Comtrade data from 2024, Africa imports $7.5 billion in dairy products annually, with projections suggesting this could reach $15 billion by 2035. The European Milk Board’s October 2024 analysis shows traditional and fat-filled milk powder accounting for 76% of these imports—particularly dominant in West African urban centers.

KEY MARKET INDICATORS: The Scale of the Challenge

  • Current African production: 53.2 million tons (5% of global output)
  • Cattle population: 20% of the global herd
  • 2024 import value: $7.5 billion
  • Projected 2035 imports: $15+ billion
  • Powder products as a percentage of imports: 76%
  • Estimated local farmer share of market growth: 2-3%

Why Local Production Can’t Keep Pace

The Sobering Economics

I recently reviewed research from Mountaga Diop and colleagues at Senegal’s Institute of Agricultural Research, published in 2023. Their findings on smallholder economics were sobering:

“Average annual net returns of just $21.70 per cow”

Africa’s structural cost disadvantages: 70% feed costs, 40% infrastructure losses, and 53% heat-driven yield reductions make local production economically impossible against 5% tariff imports

In Kenya, often highlighted as a success story, the Kenya Institute for Public Policy Research’s 2024 analysis shows that farmers average $200 in annual profit per cow, with daily yields of 5-8 liters.

To put this in perspective, a Wisconsin producer recently told me their breakeven is around $1,800 per cow annually. The disparity illustrates fundamentally different economic realities.

Three Structural Challenges Blocking Progress

1. Feed Economics That Don’t Work

ILRI’s comprehensive study across eight African countries in 2024 found that feed accounted for 70% of production costs, compared to the 40-50% we typically see in North American operations. This difference alone changes everything about profitability calculations.

Ben Lukuyu, ILRI’s principal scientist for feed and forage development in Nairobi, shared with me that Kenya and Uganda face approximately 60% annual feed deficits. When the Russia-Ukraine conflict drove fertilizer prices up 81.9% and feed costs up 13.3%, many marginally viable operations simply couldn’t survive. And that’s in Kenya, which has better infrastructure than most.

2. Climate Stress Destroying Yields

The University of Melbourne’s research team, with support from the Gates Foundation, published compelling data in Animal Production Science this March. They documented Holstein yield reductions of 17-53% under African heat stress conditions—far exceeding what we see even in challenging U.S. environments like Arizona or Southern California.

“South Africa saw average yields decline from 21 liters to 16.1 liters per cow between 2018 and 2023—a 23% drop in the continent’s most developed dairy market”

This comes from the USDA Foreign Agricultural Service’s February 2025 report, and it’s particularly concerning because South Africa has the infrastructure we’d expect to mitigate these challenges.

3. Infrastructure That Can’t Support Growth

The World Bank’s 2024 Cold Chain Assessment estimates:

“Africa loses up to 40% of perishable food due to inadequate cold storage.”

CIRAD’s research indicates that only 1-7% of locally produced milk in West Africa enters formal trade channels. The investment required to fix this—estimated at $50-100 billion for comprehensive cold chain development—exceeds current funding commitments by roughly tenfold.

What Multinationals Are Actually Building

The Reconstitution Reality

The expansion strategies of major dairy companies offer important insights. Nestlé, Danone, and FrieslandCampina are indeed investing heavily across Africa, but their business models differ significantly from what many expect.

Okereke Ekumankama’s 2023 research at the University of Nigeria examined FrieslandCampina’s operations in detail. While the company controls 75% of Nigeria’s dairy market, they source virtually no local milk. Instead, they import powder from Europe for reconstitution in Nigerian facilities.

When “Development Programs” Don’t Develop

Their Dairy Development Programme, launched in 2010, aimed to integrate smallholder farmers. However, Ekumankama’s field research with 250 participating farmers revealed persistent challenges preventing meaningful integration.

The transaction costs of collecting from dispersed producers, averaging 1-3 liters daily, often in areas lacking roads, electricity, or cold storage, exceed the economics of importing powder at 5% tariff rates.

This pattern—building processing capacity for imported inputs rather than developing local supply chains—appears across much of the continent. It creates employment and provides affordable dairy products to urban consumers, which has value. But it doesn’t necessarily translate to local dairy sector development.

East Africa: A Different Story Emerges

The Success Stories

East Africa presents a notably different picture. The FAO’s October 2024 regional report shows the region accounting for 48% of Africa’s total milk production, with 26% growth between 2013 and 2023.

Rwanda’s Systematic Transformation

According to their Ministry of Agriculture’s presentation at September’s IDF Regional Conference:

  • Milk production tripled from 334,727 metric tons in 2010 to 1,092,430 metric tons in 2024
  • Per capita consumption doubled from 37.3 to 79.9 liters annually

The key? Mandatory quality testing at milk collection centers through Ministerial Order 001/11.30, strategic genetics programs with Heifer International, and sustained government investment spanning multiple administrations.

Kenya’s Cooperative Advantage

Kenya’s dairy success story: strategic policy and cooperative strength drove production from 4.2 to 5.7 billion kg while transforming from net importer to exporter by 2020

Kenya produces 5.7 billion kilograms annually, according to the Dairy Board’s 2025 outlook, with 80% originating from smallholder operations. The success factor isn’t individual farm productivity—yields remain at 5-8 liters per cow daily. Rather, it’s cooperative strength.

“Without the cooperative, I’d be selling to brokers at whatever price they offer. Now we negotiate as a group, and we get veterinary services I could never afford alone.”
— James Kibiru, dairy farmer in Nyeri County

Consider Meru Dairy Cooperative Union, which engages over 35,000 farmers through annual field days. They provide milk aggregation, veterinary support, quality-based payment systems rewarding butterfat performance, and collective bargaining power.

Uganda’s Export Achievement

IFPRI’s 2023 value chain analysis documents Uganda’s growth from a $2 million dairy industry in 2008 to $150 million by 2017. The country now exports $500 million worth of milk powder to Algeria, according to their Ministry of Trade’s 2024 data.

West Africa: Where Different Challenges Persist

I spoke with Kwame Asante, who manages a small dairy operation outside Accra, Ghana. “We can produce milk,” he told me, “but getting it to market before it spoils? That’s the real challenge. The processors prefer powder—it’s easier, cheaper, more reliable.”

His experience reflects broader West African dynamics. Ghana’s Fan Milk, now owned by Danone, built one of the region’s most successful distribution networks. Those yellow tricycles are everywhere in urban areas. Yet, as industry data shows, the operation relies primarily on imported powder, with local farmers supplying only about 2% of the processed volume.

The economics make sense from a processor perspective. A solar-powered cooling system for a single collection center runs about $15,000-20,000 according to equipment suppliers I’ve spoken with. When you’re collecting 50-100 liters daily from that center, the payback period stretches beyond what most investors will accept.

Policy Choices That Make or Break Markets

The fork in the road: policy choices and cooperative strength determine whether African dairy regions become self-sufficient exporters or import-dependent markets

The Tale of Two Approaches

Timothy Njagi at Kenya’s Tegemeo Institute documented how the country’s 2015 implementation of a 10% import levy plus 16% VAT on milk imports catalyzed transformation. Average daily yields from indigenous breeds increased by approximately 300% over the following decade, shifting Kenya from a net importer to an exporter.

By contrast, West African nations maintain just 5% tariffs through the ECOWAS Common External Tariff. Oxfam’s 2024 trade analysis shows the result: continued heavy import dependency, with fat-filled milk powder (a blend of skim milk and palm oil) dominating 70% of consumption in major cities.

Nigeria’s New Attempt

Nigeria’s National Dairy Policy Implementation Framework, validated in November 2025, offers:

  • Five-year tax holidays for processors
  • Low-interest credit for farmers
  • Guaranteed off-take schemes

Whether this succeeds where previous efforts struggled remains to be seen. The policy appears comprehensive on paper, but implementation has consistently been a challenge in Nigeria.

What This Means for Different Players

For Genetics Companies

Focus on adaptation, not maximum production. Raphael Mrode, who leads ILRI’s genetics program in Kenya, has been incorporating the “slick gene,” which confers heat tolerance through shorter, sleeker hair coats. These animals maintain reasonable productivity under conditions that would devastate conventional Holstein genetics.

The market opportunity exists for companies developing adaptation traits rather than pursuing maximum production designed for temperate conditions.

For Equipment Suppliers

Forget precision dairy technology designed for 1,000-cow operations. That’s not the market. Instead, think intermediate technologies: solar-powered cooling for collection centers (around $15,000-20,000 per unit), mobile apps for basic smartphones, robust milk testing equipment suitable for cooperative-level deployment.

Success requires matching technology to operational realities and economic constraints.

For Processors

Develop dual strategies: reconstitution capacity for urban markets while gradually building local collection infrastructure where economically viable. Don’t promise what you can’t deliver on local sourcing, but don’t ignore it either—governments are increasingly demanding local content.

The brutal reality: of the $74B African dairy market, local farmers capture just 2% ($1.5B) while European powder imports claim 58% ($43B)

The Bottom Line: Understanding the Real Opportunity

The $74 billion projection for the African dairy market from IndexBox appears realistic given demographic and income trends. However, understanding who captures this value—and how—requires nuanced analysis.

East African nations with strong cooperative structures and consistent policy support show genuine transformation potential. West Africa will likely remain import-dependent with selective local success stories. South Africa continues consolidating, potentially dropping below 500 commercial dairy operations by 2030.

What’s encouraging is seeing younger African dairy professionals returning from international training with fresh ideas. They understand both traditional systems and modern technology. They’re the ones who’ll ultimately bridge this gap between potential and reality.

For global dairy professionals, Africa represents opportunity—though not in ways that conform to conventional expectations. Success requires understanding the continent’s unique development trajectory, abandoning standard assumptions, and developing approaches appropriate to diverse regional contexts.

As we consider these opportunities, it’s worth noting that markets develop differently. Africa won’t follow the path of New Zealand or Wisconsin, or the Netherlands. It’s creating something new, and those who recognize and respect that difference will find the real opportunities.

This paradox—simultaneous consumption growth and production challenges—defines the current reality of African dairy. How the industry responds will shape both African food security and global dairy trade for decades to come.

What do you think? Are we looking at this opportunity the right way? I’d love to hear from producers who’ve worked in these markets or are considering investments there. The conversation continues.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • Africa’s $74B dairy market is an import story, not a production opportunity—80% flows to European powder while farmers earning $21-200/cow yearly capture just 2-3% of value
  • Geography determines destiny—East Africa transforms through cooperatives and smart policy (Kenya exports after tripling yields), while West Africa stays import-dependent at 76% reconstituted powder
  • The economics simply don’t work at the current scale—African farmers face 70% feed costs (vs. 40% globally), 40% infrastructure losses, and compete against powder imports at just 5% tariffs
  • Success requires radical adaptation—heat-tolerant genetics (Holstein yields drop 17-53% in African heat), intermediate technology ($15K solar cooling, not $100K precision systems), and hybrid import-local business models
  • Multinationals aren’t villains, they’re rational—FrieslandCampina controls 75% of Nigeria’s dairy using zero local milk because collecting from smallholders costs more than importing

Complete references and supporting documentation are available upon request by contacting the editorial team at editor@thebullvine.com.

Learn More:

Join the Revolution!

Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

CME Dairy Market Report: May 12, 2025 – Block Cheese Declines While Butter Strengthens

Butter climbs as cheese blocks tumble 3.75¢. Global dairy tensions & USDA forecasts signal volatility ahead—key insights for producers & traders.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The May 12 CME dairy markets saw divergent trends, with butter gaining 2¢ amid tight inventories while cheddar blocks plummeted 3.75¢ on buyer hesitancy. Nonfat Dry Milk increased with active trading, while Dry Whey stagnated due to export challenges. Global factors like Australia’s rising milk production and China’s whey tariffs contrast with bullish USDA forecasts for Class III milk prices. Market sentiment remains cautious as narrowing block-barrel spreads hint at shifting demand patterns. Stakeholders face a balancing between current supply tightness and anticipated production increases, with feed costs offering margin support. Strategic recommendations emphasize risk management and monitoring trade policy impacts.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • Butter-Cheese Divide: Butter (+2¢) strengthened on inventory concerns, while blocks (-3.75¢) retreated despite last week’s gains.
  • Global Pressures: Australia’s milk growth and China’s whey tariffs create export headwinds, offsetting strong GDT auction results.
  • USDA Forecast Gap: Class III futures ($18.65/cwt) outpace USDA’s 2025 forecast ($17.60), signaling market optimism.
  • Actionable Insights: Producers were educated to optimize milk components; traders were aware of volatility from the new processing capacity.
CME dairy prices, butter market trends, cheese price volatility, USDA milk forecasts, global dairy exports

The Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) dairy markets opened the week with mixed signals as butter prices gained 2 cents while Cheddar blocks fell significantly, dropping 3.75 cents. Meanwhile, barrels held steady, narrowing the block-barrel spread. Nonfat Dry Milk saw modest gains amid relatively active trading, while Dry Whey remained unchanged with minimal activity. Today’s session highlights ongoing tension between immediate supply tightness in certain products and broader concerns about future production growth and export market access.

Key Price Changes & Market Trends

ProductClosing PriceChange from Friday (May 9)
Butter$2.3500/lb+2.00¢
Cheddar Blocks$1.7800/lb-3.75¢
Cheddar Barrels$1.7700/lbUnchanged
Nonfat Dry Milk$1.2100/lb+0.25¢
Dry Whey$0.5425/lbUnchanged

Market Commentary: Butter continued its upward momentum today, gaining 2 cents as inventories remain tight despite seasonal production increases. Cheddar blocks reversed last week’s strengthening trend, falling 3.75 cents as buyers stepped back after recent price increases. The block-barrel price spread narrowed to just 1 cent, suggesting convergence in demand between retail and food service sectors. NDM edged slightly higher amid steady domestic and international demand, while Dry Whey held steady for the second consecutive session amid ongoing export challenges.

Volume and Trading Activity

Trading activity varied considerably across products today, providing insight into market participants’ conviction levels and overall liquidity.

Cheddar blocks showed moderate activity with four trades executed, alongside three bids and one offer, indicating some buyer hesitancy at current price levels despite the day’s decline. Barrels saw comparable activity with three trades and three offers, but no bids by session’s end.

Butter trading was notably light, with just one transaction completed despite the price increase, suggesting that the move was higher due to the limited volume. NDM was the day’s most actively traded product with 12 loads changing hands and robust bidding activity (6 bids), supporting its modest price gain. Dry Whey saw no trades for the third consecutive session, with only two bids recorded, highlighting persistent liquidity challenges in this market segment.

Global Context

International developments continue to influence U.S. dairy markets significantly. The recent Global Dairy Trade (GDT) auction on May 6 showed substantial gains with the index rising 4.6%, led by increases in cheddar (+5.4%), butter (+3.8%), and whole milk powder, providing underlying support to domestic markets.

Australia’s milk production is forecast to increase by 1.1% in 2025 to 8.8 million metric tons after strong growth of 2.7% in 2024, potentially adding to global supply pressure later this year. Meanwhile, New Zealand is experiencing production challenges but focusing on higher-value products, which could support global prices for products like cheese and butter.

Trade policy tensions remain a significant concern, particularly affecting the whey market. China’s retaliatory tariffs on U.S. whey products continue to disrupt traditional export channels, forcing U.S. suppliers to seek alternative markets. These trade barriers create persistent headwinds for the whey complex despite relatively firm domestic prices.

Forecasts and Analysis

Current CME spot prices continue to show divergence from USDA’s 2025 annual average forecasts, highlighting the tension between immediate market conditions and longer-term expectations:

ProductCurrent Spot Price (5/12/25)USDA 2025 Forecast Avg.Difference
Cheddar Cheese$1.7800/lb$1.790/lb-$0.010/lb
Butter$2.3500/lb$2.445/lb-$0.095/lb
NDM$1.2100/lb$1.220/lb-$0.010/lb
Dry Whey$0.5425/lb$0.510/lb+$0.0325/lb
Class III Milk$18.65/cwt (June Future)$17.60/cwt+$1.05/cwt

The USDA projects a 0.5% increase in total U.S. milk production for 2025, driven by modest gains in herd size (+0.4%) and milk yield per cow (+0.3%). This production growth and significant expansion in cheese processing capacity coming online throughout 2025 suggest increased product availability later this year.

Feed costs remain relatively favorable, with corn futures trading around $4.47/bushel for July contracts and soybean meal at $298.30/ton, supporting producer margins despite mixed milk prices. These favorable input costs incentivize continued milk production growth, potentially pressuring prices as the year progresses.

Market Sentiment

Market sentiment remains cautiously divided, with participants balancing short-term supply tightness against expectations of increasing production. As one analyst recently noted, “The market remains sensitive to incoming data and news flow, potentially leading to continued volatility,” reflecting many traders’ uncertainty.

The significant drop in block cheese prices today suggests some traders are becoming wary of sustainability at recent price levels, particularly as milk production seasonally increases. The cautious optimism seen in previous sessions appears to be tempering as market participants assess the impact of expanding processing capacity and potential export challenges.

Traders are particularly focused on the block-barrel spread, which narrowed considerably today. As noted in previous analysis, this spread “bears watching as it could signal shifts in consumer purchasing patterns or inventory positioning”. Today’s convergence could indicate rebalancing between retail and food service demand channels.

Closing Summary & Recommendations

The CME dairy markets began the week with mixed performance as butter strengthened while cheese blocks declined significantly, narrowing the block-barrel spread to just one cent. NDM edged slightly higher on active trading, while Dry Whey remained unchanged amid minimal participation. Today’s session reflected the market’s ongoing balancing act between current product availability and expectations of increasing supplies as the year progresses.

Based on today’s market activity and broader context, stakeholders should consider the following:

For Producers: Focus on optimizing milk components to maximize value in the current market environment. With future prices running above USDA forecasts for the year, risk management strategies should be evaluated to protect against potential price declines as production seasonally increases. Monitor feed markets closely to lock in favorable input costs for 2025.

For Processors and Buyers: Carefully assess inventory positions, particularly cheese, as the narrowing block-barrel spread may signal shifting demand patterns between retail and food service channels. Stay alert to international developments, especially trade policy changes that could impact export opportunities. Consider forward contracting strategies to navigate potential volatility as new processing capacity comes online throughout the year.

For Traders: Watch for technical price levels and changes in trading volume that may signal shifts in market direction. The divergence between spot prices and longer-term forecasts creates risks and opportunities that may require adaptive hedging strategies.

Learn more:

Join the Revolution!

Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

Dairy Markets Rally on Cheese Surge and Firm Butter Demand Amid Global Supply Constraints

Cheese prices surge 7.5¢ as global dairy supplies tighten; butter defies weak trading. USDA vs. CME forecasts reveal market skepticism.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Today’s CME dairy markets saw cheddar barrels rally 7.50¢—their largest single-day gain this month—driven by panic buying and record U.S. cheese exports. Butter edged higher (+1.00¢) amid global supply constraints, while nonfat dry milk dipped (-0.50¢) on weakened Chinese demand. USDA forecasts for Class III milk (.95/cwt) diverged sharply from CME futures (.18/cwt), reflecting trader skepticism amid rising feed costs. New Zealand’s production slump and EU inventory lows bolstered U.S. export opportunities, though weak Asian demand capped gains. Analysts recommend hedging milk production and targeting EU buyers to capitalize on tightening global inventories.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • Cheese barrels surged 7.50¢ due to domestic inventory shortages and unprecedented export growth (January volumes +22% YoY).
  • Butter gained 1.00¢ despite zero trades, supported by reduced EU competition and New Zealand’s drought-driven production decline (-4% YoY).
  • USDA vs. CME disconnect: Markets priced Class III milk 4.3% below USDA forecasts, signaling concerns over feed costs (corn +0.9%, soybeans +1.2%).
  • Global pivot: U.S. cheese exports hit record highs in nontraditional markets (Japan, Bahrain), while EU cheese stocks reached 5-year lows.
  • Action step: Producers advised to hedge at $17.18/cwt; exporters to target EU buyers amid supply gaps.
CME dairy market report, cheese price surge, butter demand trends, global dairy exports, Class III milk futures

Today’s CME dairy markets saw robust gains in cheese categories, with cheddar barrels leading the charge amid tightening domestic supplies and steady export interest. Butter edged higher despite muted trading activity, while nonfat dry milk faced downward pressure from weaker international demand.

Key Price Changes & Market Trends

ProductClosing PriceChange from YesterdayTradesBidsOffers
Cheese (Blocks)$1.7025/lb+3.25¢842
Cheese (Barrels)$1.7550/lb+7.50¢221
Butter$2.3100/lb+1.00¢041
Nonfat Dry Milk$1.1525/lb-0.50¢143
Dry Whey$0.4925/lbUnchanged020

Commentary:
Cheddar barrels surged 7.50¢, outpacing blocks (+3.25¢), as processors scrambled to secure supplies ahead of spring demand. The barrel-block spread widened to +5.25¢, signaling acute tightness in barrel inventories. Butter gained 1.00¢ following yesterday’s 0.50¢ increase, supported by firm bids and reduced EU export competition. Nonfat dry milk dipped 0.50¢ as Chinese buyers remained sidelined, continuing the weekly downward trend from $1.1665/lb last week to today’s $1.1525/lb.

Volume and Trading Activity

Cheese blocks dominated trading with eight transactions, reflecting strong buyer interest that has grown significantly from yesterday’s three trades. Bid/ask spreads for blocks have tightened over the past week, moving from a 2.00¢ spread to complete market clearing today as all offers were purchased. Barrels saw limited trading volume (2 trades) despite their sharp price rise, with their bid/ask spread narrowing to 1.00¢ compared to 1.50¢ in previous sessions.

Butter markets remained static with no completed trades for the second consecutive day, though increased bidding activity (4 bids today vs. 2 yesterday) signals strengthening demand. NDM recorded a single trade at $1.1525/lb with a consistent 0.50¢ bid/ask spread maintained from previous sessions, reflecting cautious market participation.

Global Context

U.S. cheese export momentum has been exceptional, with January volume jumping 22% year-over-year to 46,680 MT—establishing a January record. Every month since July 2024 has set monthly export records for U.S. cheese suppliers, demonstrating remarkable international demand growth. Market diversification has been particularly noteworthy, with exports expanding beyond traditional strong markets like Mexico (+1% YOY) to reach destinations including Japan, Bahrain, and Panama.

Meanwhile, New Zealand’s milk production declined 4% year-over-year in March due to drought conditions, tightening global butter and whole milk powder supplies. EU butter prices have surged since July as milk production declined precipitously due to intense heat and animal disease. This created competitive opportunities for U.S. suppliers despite New Zealand’s butter export forecast growth to 475,000 tons in 2025. European cheese stocks have reached five-year lows, further supporting U.S. export prospects.

Forecasts and Analysis

  • Milk production: 226.2B lbs (-0.7B vs prior forecast)
  • Class III milk: $17.95/cwt (-$1.15 vs March)
  • Class IV milk: $18.80/cwt (-$0.90 vs March)

CME futures diverged from USDA projections:

ContractCME April SettlementUSDA Q2 ForecastVariance
Class III Milk$17.18/cwt$17.95/cwt-4.3%
Class IV Milk$17.86/cwt$18.80/cwt-5.0%
Cheese (Blocks)$1.6950/lb$1.8100/lb-6.4%

Markets appear skeptical of USDA’s bullish cheese price forecasts, with futures pricing in tighter margins from rising feed costs (corn + +0.9%, soybeans + +1.2% week-over-week). The significant futures premium for cheese ($1.8430/lb April futures vs. $1.7025/lb cash) indicates trader optimism despite this uncertainty.

Market Sentiment

A Midwest dairy broker noted:
“The barrel rally caught many off guard—we’re seeing panic buying from foodservice distributors trying to lock in Q2 inventory.”

An export analyst added:
“Despite cash market weakness last week, futures premiums for cheese and butter suggest traders anticipate a rebound as we move deeper into Q2.”

Overall sentiment leans bullish for cheese and cautiously optimistic for butter, with traders citing “whipsaw action” in cheese markets that “underscores the fundamental uncertainty about domestic demand” as we enter the spring buying season.

Closing Summary & Recommendations

Today’s markets highlighted the continued strength in cheese, mainly barrels, which have substantially outpaced blocks on inventory concerns. Butter found modest support from global supply constraints, while NDM remains under pressure.

Recommendations:

  1. Producers: Consider hedging milk production via Class III futures at current levels ($17.18/cwt), given the significant gap between CME futures and USDA forecasts.
  2. Processors: Secure barrel cheese inventories before seasonal demand peaks, as evidenced by the widening barrel-block spread.
  3. Exporters: Target EU cheese buyers to capitalize on five-year lows in European cheese stocks while monitoring New Zealand’s export growth strategy for potential competitive pressure.

Given New Zealand’s production challenges, monitor the upcoming Global Dairy Trade auction to confirm international pricing trends, particularly for butter and whole milk powder.

Learn more:

Join the Revolution!

Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Daily for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

CME Dairy Market Report: March 27, 2025 – Butter Surges While Class III Futures Continue Strong Rally Above USDA Forecast

Butter prices soar 3.5¢ despite high stocks as Class III milk futures rally past USDA forecasts. Global dairy markets brace for spring volatility.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: CME dairy markets saw significant bullish momentum on March 27, 2025, with butter leading gains (+3.50¢) despite elevated inventories and cheese blocks rising 1.75¢. Class III milk futures surged to .67/cwt, exceeding USDA projections by 17¢, signaling trader confidence in tightening supplies. Global dynamics diverged sharply, with EU milk production declining (-0.2%) amid regulatory pressures while New Zealand output grew (+3.1%). The USDA revised its 2025 all-milk price forecast upward to .75/cwt, though nonfat dry milk faced headwinds from global price competition. Stakeholders are advised to monitor feed costs, export opportunities, and Federal Order changes expected June 1.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Buter Defies Logic: Prices jumped 3.5¢ despite 17% monthly inventory growth, driven by technical buying and export speculation.
  • Class III Futures Signal Strength: Settled at $18.67/cwt, 17¢ above USDA forecasts – largest premium since March 23.
  • Global Split: EU milk production declines (-0.2%) contrast with New Zealand’s 3.1% growth, reshaping export opportunities.
  • NDM at Crossroads: U.S. prices remain globally uncompetitive ($1.15/lb) despite USDA’s $1.30/lb annual projection.
  • Action Items: Producers urged to hedge Class III exposure; processors warned about tightening butter supplies.
CME butter prices, Class III milk futures, USDA dairy forecasts, global dairy exports, dairy market analysis

Butter and cheese markets showed significant strength in today’s Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) dairy trading, with butter posting the most crucial daily gain in nearly a month. Class III milk futures extended their rally, climbing to .67/cwt and widening the gap with USDA’s forecast. Meanwhile, after yesterday’s advance, nonfat dry milk retreated, reflecting the mixed signals currently driving dairy markets as seasonal spring flush approaches.

Key Price Changes & Market Trends

ProductClosing PriceChange from Yesterday
Butter$2.3650/lb+3.50¢
Cheese (Blocks)$1.6475/lb+1.75¢
Cheese (Barrels)$1.6350/lb+0.50¢
Nonfat Dry Milk$1.1500/lb-1.00¢
Dry Whey$0.4950/lb-0.50¢

Butter led today’s advances with a significant 3.50¢ gain despite recent cold storage reports showing inventories at 305 million pounds (up 17% month-over-month and 3% year-over-year). This seemingly contradictory movement suggests technical buying and potential export interest override inventory concerns. Cheese blocks followed with a substantial 1.75¢ increase, continuing their upward trajectory since Monday and widening the spread with barrels to 1.25¢. Nonfat dry milk retreated 1¢ after yesterday’s 2¢ jump, while dry whey dipped slightly to close just under the psychological 50¢ threshold.

Volume and Trading Activity

Today’s session saw notably active trading in butter, with 15 trades executed, reflecting strong buyer interest despite higher prices. Cheese blocks also showed healthy activity with six trades and balanced bidding interest (4 bids, four offers), indicating genuine price discovery rather than unidirectional pressure. In contrast, barrels, NDM, and dry whey saw minimal trading with just one trade each, suggesting more cautious positioning in these markets.

Butter’s trading activity was particularly noteworthy given yesterday’s Cold Storage report findings. Buyers seemingly discounted the high inventory levels in favor of forward-looking market dynamics. The 15 trades completed represent the highest daily volume for butter this week.

Global Context

International factors continue to influence U.S. dairy markets, with the stronger dollar noted yesterday having a minimal dampening effect on today’s butter and cheese advances. Export competitiveness remains a key consideration, particularly as U.S. butter and cheese exports are projected to grow due to competitive pricing.

Global milk production patterns are evolving significantly in 2025. The European Union’s milk production is forecast to decrease by 0.2% to 149.4 million metric tons due to declining cow numbers, tight farmer margins, environmental regulations, and disease outbreaks. This contrasts with New Zealand, where milk production showed 3.1% seasonal growth through December 2024, driven by favorable weather conditions and improved farm profitability.

These divergent production trends create both challenges and opportunities for U.S. dairy exports. While EU cheese production is expected to increase by 0.6% to 10.8 million metric tons despite overall milk production declines, this shift toward higher-value products may create openings for U.S. exports in other categories like butter and powdered milk.

Forecasts and Analysis

Class III milk futures continued their impressive rally, settling at .67/cwt today. This is a significant 13¢ increase from Wednesday and is now solidly above the USDA forecast of $18.50/cwt. This marks the fourth consecutive day of gains for Class III futures and reflects market confidence in cheese values.

Class III Milk Futures vs USDA Forecast (Mar 2025)

The widening gap between actual futures prices and USDA projections suggests traders are pricing in stronger fundamentals than official forecasts currently recognize. Today’s Class III settlement at $18.67 represents a 17¢ premium to the USDA forecast, compared to just a 4¢ premium on Monday.

USDA’s broader 2025 dairy forecast includes an all-milk price projection of $22.75/cwt, recently revised upward due to strong demand for cheese and export opportunities. The current market trajectory aligns with this more optimistic outlook, particularly in the cheese and butter segments.

USDA has also adjusted its dairy herd size projection for 2025, increasing it by 5,000 head to 9.380 million while simultaneously lowering milk production forecasts to 226.2 billion pounds (-0.7 billion) due to slower-than-expected growth in output per cow. This production dynamic bears monitoring as we approach peak spring flush.

Market Sentiment

Despite yesterday’s mixed performance, Market sentiment has become increasingly bullish, particularly in the butter and cheese markets. Traders appear to be positioning for tighter supplies as we approach Q2, with one market analyst noting, “The significant butter trading volume today, combined with higher prices, suggests genuine concern about future availability despite current inventory levels.”

The continued strength in Class III futures reflects confidence in cheese demand fundamentals. Market participants seemingly discount the “processors outpacing demand” narrative mentioned in yesterday’s reports. Instead, the focus appears to be shifting toward potential supply constraints and strengthening demand as we move into late spring.

Given recent global developments, the nonfat dry milk (NDM) market deserves particular attention. While today saw a modest 1¢ decline, U.S. NDM prices have been among the highest globally in recent months, creating challenges for export competitiveness. The USDA projects non-fat dry milk prices in the U.S. to average $1.30/lb in 2025, representing a 5.4% increase from 2024. Today’s closing price of $1.15/lb suggests a potential upside if these projections materialize.

Closing Summary & Recommendations

In summary, today’s dairy markets showed substantial strength in butter and cheese prices, with butter gaining 3.50¢ despite high inventory levels and cheese blocks rising 1.75¢. Class III milk futures extended their rally to .67/cwt, now trading 17¢ above USDA’s .50/cwt forecast. The divergence between intense price action and previously reported inventory builds suggests markets are looking beyond current supplies to anticipated tightening conditions.

For Producers:

  • Consider implementing selective hedging strategies for Class III milk as future prices have established a clear premium to USDA forecasts, potentially creating favorable pricing opportunities.
  • Monitor feed costs closely. Recent weakness in corn and soybean futures could improve milk production margins.
  • Track global production trends, particularly the declining EU milk production, and increasing New Zealand output, as these shifts will impact international market dynamics and potential export opportunities.

For Processors:

  • Today’s active butter trading suggests increasing supply competition despite reported inventory levels. Forward contracting may be prudent before potential further price increases.
  • The widening block-barrel spread (now 1.25¢) signals evolving market dynamics that may impact procurement strategies across cheese categories.
  • Consider the implications of EU processors prioritizing cheese production at the expense of butter and powder, which could create opportunities in international markets.

For All Market Participants:

  • Friday’s weekly summary report will provide crucial context for this week’s price movements and help establish whether today’s strength represents a new trend or temporary repositioning.
  • Continue preparing for potential market volatility as Federal Order changes approach (June 1), which will fundamentally alter milk pricing formulas.
  • Pay close attention to global dairy trade patterns, as China shows signs of demand recovery after years of declining dairy import volumes, potentially creating new export opportunities.

Read more:

Join the Revolution!

Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Daily for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

Global Dairy Market Report for January 10th 2025: Volatility Amid Shifting Production

Dairy markets swing wildly as trade tensions boil over. The March Class III contract lurched more than a dollar in a single day, leaving farmers scrambling. With U.S. tariffs rising and China retaliating, the global dairy landscape faces an economic battle. Who will emerge victorious in this high-stakes game of dairy dominance?

Summary:

The global dairy market is facing challenges due to trade tensions and changes in production. In February 2025, there was significant activity, with EEX futures trading 2,100 tonnes of dairy products. Butter futures decreased while SMP futures went up. The Global Dairy Trade auction index increased by 3.7%. Regionally, Ireland and Poland saw strong milk production growth, while milk prices in China increased slightly after a long decline. In the U.S., trade issues impacted milk powder exports, but cheese exports to Mexico did well. With mixed results worldwide, dairy farmers must focus on being efficient and adaptable to navigate these changing market conditions.

Key Takeaways:

  • Global milk supply forecasted to grow by 0.8% in 2025, with all significant exporting regions expecting gains for the first time since 2020.
  • Trade tensions between the U.S. and Canada may disrupt established trade flows, influencing global dairy markets.
  • EU milk production shows recovery, but an overall decline is expected due to environmental and regulatory challenges.
  • U.S. dairy exports are mixed, with cheese exports booming despite a sharp decline in milk powder production.
  • China’s dairy market stabilizes, with import growth projected and farmgate milk prices rising for the first time in over two years.
  • Fluctuating prices and shifting production patterns reshape the global dairy landscape, presenting challenges and opportunities.
  • Dairy farmers are encouraged to adopt risk management, explore value-added products, and leverage emerging markets for growth.
  • Emphasis on efficiency and adaptability is crucial for dairy farmers to thrive in a dynamic and evolving market environment.

During a volatile week in the financial markets, dairy market prices fluctuated significantly due to escalating trade tensions. The March Class III contract swung more than a dollar in a single day, causing farmers and traders to react quickly to the rapid price changes. As the U.S. ratchets tariffs and China retaliates with precision strikes, the global dairy landscape finds itself caught in an escalating economic battle. Recent data from key exchanges and industry reports reveal a sector teetering between opportunity and crisis – but who will emerge victorious in this high-stakes game of global dairy dominance? As exports increase, production changes, and consumer preferences evolve, dairy farmers worldwide deal with a highly dynamic market. Will they adapt swiftly to seize new opportunities or falter under the pressures of volatility?

Market Dynamics 

Global milk production is forecasted to rise by 0.8% in 2025, driven by technological advancements, shifting consumer preferences, and improved farming practices across major exporting regions, marking the first simultaneous growth since 2020. This increase is influenced by higher prices paid to farmers for milk, lower costs for animal feed, and better weather conditions, indicating a possible positive change for the global dairy sector. This growth is driven by increased profitability for dairy farmers. Additionally, more affordable feed costs and favorable weather patterns support higher yields. 

Although there are positive expectations, the dairy market continues to be unstable for various reasons. A substantial increase in dairy processing capacity, particularly in the United States, is expected to reshape regional milk markets. China’s projected 2% year-on-year increase in dairy imports for 2025 could significantly impact global trade flows and prices. Additionally, ongoing trade disputes, especially between the United States and Canada, threaten to disrupt established trade patterns. 

Combining these factors results in a complicated and ever-changing global market landscape for dairy farmers and processors. Consumer demand fluctuations, driven by economic pressures and changing preferences, influence the market. While feed costs are currently favorable, they remain subject to fluctuations in the global commodity market. As the industry navigates these challenges and opportunities, adaptability and strategic planning will be crucial for success in the evolving global dairy landscape 2025. 

Country/Region2024 Expected (Billion Pounds)2025 Forecast (Billion Pounds)Change
Argentina23.624.71.1
Australia19.219.40.2
European Union320.9320.3-0.6
New Zealand47.648.10.5
Major Exporter Total411.3412.51.2

Source: USDA, Economic Research Service calculations based on USDA, Foreign Agricultural Service. Dairy: World Markets and Trade Report, December 2024.

Regional Production Trends 

European Union

In 2025, the European Union’s dairy industry shows varied trends among its member countries. While some countries show promising growth, EU milk production is forecast to decline marginally. 

Ireland stands out with a remarkable 30.1% year-over-year increase in December collections, showcasing the country’s strong recovery and efficient dairy farming practices. This surge is attributed to favorable weather conditions, improved feed quality, and strategic investments in dairy infrastructure. Poland and Spain also posted gains, with solid milk production up by 3.4% and 0.7% respectively in December. Poland’s growth is driven by ongoing consolidation in the dairy sector and investments in modern farming technologies. Spain’s modest increase reflects a gradual recovery from past obstacles, including economic downturns and supply chain disruptions, showcasing the industry’s resilience and adaptive strategies. 

Despite these positive indicators, the EU as a whole faces headwinds. It is predicted that milk output will slightly decrease to 149.4 million metric tons (MMT) in 2025, a drop from 149.6 MMT in 2024. This decline is attributed to several factors: 

  • Declining cow numbers: Stricter environmental regulations and farm consolidation are reducing overall herd sizes across the EU.
  • Tight farmer margins: Rising input costs, particularly for feed and energy, are squeezing profitability for many dairy farmers.
  • Environmental regulations: The EU’s Green Deal and Farm to Fork strategy impose stricter sustainability requirements, forcing some farmers to reduce production or exit the industry.
  • Disease outbreaks: Concerns about diseases like bluetongue in some regions are impacting production and trade.

The European dairy industry is also experiencing a shift in product focus. Cheese manufacturing is set to be a primary focus due to high local and international demand. This focus on cheese may come at the expense of butter, non-fat dry milk, and whole milk powder production. 

Looking ahead, the EU dairy sector must balance environmental sustainability with economic viability. Innovations in feed efficiency, animal welfare, and sustainable farming practices will be crucial for maintaining the EU’s position in the global dairy market.

United States 

In 2025, the U.S. dairy industry grapples with diverse challenges, including labor shortages and environmental regulations, alongside promising prospects such as export market growth and technological advancements. While milk production shows signs of growth, there are significant variations across product categories and regions. 

Cheese production experienced a dip of 0.7% year-over-year in December, totaling 1.2 billion pounds. This decrease is primarily attributed to shifts in consumer demand and increased competition from plant-based alternatives. However, the export market tells a different story, with cheese shipments surging by 21% compared to December 2023. This export boom is driven by strong demand from key markets like Mexico and South Korea and favorable exchange rates. 

Regional variations in milk production are becoming more pronounced. Texas and Idaho are leading the charge, with production increases of 7.5% and 3.5%, respectively. These states benefit from: 

  • Large-scale, efficient dairy operations
  • Favorable climate conditions for year-round production
  • Strategic investments in processing capacity

Other major dairy states also see increased milk production, albeit at more modest rates. Factors contributing to this growth include: 

  • Improved cow genetics, leading to higher per-cow yields
  • Adopt advanced technologies like robotic milking systems
  • Optimized feed management practices

However, challenges remain for the U.S. dairy sector: 

  • Labor shortages continue to impact farm operations and processing facilities
  • Environmental regulations, particularly regarding methane emissions, are becoming more stringent
  • Volatility in feed costs affects profitability

The USDA forecasts overall U.S. milk production to reach 227.2 billion pounds in 2025, slightly lower than previous estimates due to decreased milk per cow yields and adjustments in dairy cow inventories, signaling potential challenges for the industry. 

Adaptability and innovation will be key as the U.S. dairy industry navigates these complex dynamics. Farmers and processors are likely to focus on: 

  • Diversifying product offerings to meet changing consumer preferences
  • Investing in sustainability initiatives to meet regulatory requirements and consumer expectations
  • Explore new export markets to capitalize on strong global demand

Oceania 

The Oceania region, particularly New Zealand, plays a crucial role in the global dairy market. The strong participation in the latest Global Dairy Trade (GDT) event, with 182 bidders competing for 23,854 tonnes of product, underscores the region’s importance in setting global dairy price trends. 

New Zealand‘s dairy sector is anticipating significant seasonal peaks in production for 2025.  

  • Favorable weather conditions: La Niña weather patterns are expected to bring adequate rainfall, supporting pasture growth.
  • Herd management improvements: Farmers focus on breeding programs and animal health to increase per-cow productivity.
  • Technological advancements: Precision farming techniques enhance overall farm efficiency.

However, the industry also faces challenges: 

  • Environmental regulations: New Zealand’s government is implementing stricter environmental policies, which may impact production practices.
  • Land use competition: Increasing pressure from alternative land uses, such as forestry and horticulture, could limit dairy expansion.
  • Labor shortages: Like many countries, New Zealand is grappling with agricultural labor shortages.

Australia, the other major player in Oceania’s dairy sector, is expected to see modest growth in milk production. The country is recovering from previous droughts and focusing on rebuilding its dairy herd. 

Both countries will likely benefit from strong global demand, particularly from Asian markets. However, they must navigate changing consumer preferences, especially the growing demand for plant-based alternatives. 

China 

China, the world’s largest dairy importer, shows signs of market stabilization, with potential significant impacts on global dairy trade. Farmgate milk prices in January increased for the first time in 27 months, signaling a possible turning point in the country’s dairy sector. 

However, at 3.12 Yuan/Kg, prices remain 14.5% below year-ago levels, indicating ongoing challenges for domestic producers. This price pressure has led to: 

  • Consolidation in the dairy farming sector, with smaller farms exiting the market
  • Increased focus on efficiency and productivity among more extensive operations
  • Government initiatives to support the domestic dairy industry

In 2025, China’s milk production will fall by 1.5% year-on-year. This decline is attributed to: 

  • Herd reductions due to sustained low prices
  • Stricter environmental regulations impacting farm operations
  • Shift towards more extensive, more efficient dairy operations

Despite the projected decrease in domestic production, China’s dairy market remains dynamic: 

  • Consumer demand for dairy products continues to grow, particularly in urban areas
  • The government is promoting increased dairy consumption for nutritional benefits
  • E-commerce and innovative dairy products are expanding market reach

China’s dairy imports are projected to grow by 2% year-on-year in 2025, ending a three-year decline. This increase could significantly impact global dairy trade flows and prices. 

Key factors to watch in China’s dairy sector include: 

  • Government policies supporting domestic production vs. import reliance
  • Changing consumer preferences, especially among younger demographics
  • Developments in China’s trade relationships with major dairy exporting countries

As China’s dairy landscape evolves, it will play a pivotal role in shaping global dairy markets, influencing everything from commodity prices to product innovation. 

Trade Tensions and Market Volatility 

The dairy industry is central to a complex web of international trade disputes, with recent developments creating significant market uncertainty. The U.S., Mexico, and Canada have agreed to a 30-day détente, temporarily easing tensions in North American trade relations. This short-term truce is aimed at addressing shared concerns over drug trafficking across borders, highlighting the interconnected nature of trade and broader geopolitical issues. 

However, escalating trade conflicts with China overshadow the respite in North American tensions. The U.S. has implemented a sweeping 10% tariff increase on Chinese imports, which has prompted swift retaliation from Beijing. China’s response, characterized by targeted sanctions, demonstrates a strategic approach to economic warfare, potentially impacting specific sectors of the U.S. economy while minimizing domestic economic disruption. 

The ripple effects of these trade tensions are already evident in the dairy market. U.S. milk powder exporters, traditionally reliant on robust international demand, are adopting a cautious stance. The USDA’s Dairy Market News reports that Mexican demand for U.S. milk powder has become “subdued,” a concerning development given Mexico’s status as a key market for U.S. dairy exports. In 2024, Mexico imported approximately 576,000 metric tons of U.S. dairy products, making it the largest export destination for American dairy. 

This hesitancy extends beyond international buyers, with domestic purchasers also showing reluctance. Market analysts note a “chilling effect” on U.S. buyers, who are wary of committing to purchases in such an unpredictable environment. This cautious approach is encapsulated in the industry phrase of avoiding “catching the proverbial falling knife,” reflecting fears of buying into a declining market. 

These trade conflicts affect more than just milk powder; they extend to other dairy products. The dairy commodity spectrum, including cheese, butter, and whey products, faces potential disruption. For instance, U.S. cheese exports to Mexico, which saw a 36% year-over-year increase in August 2024, could be at risk if current trade uncertainties persist or escalate. 

Looking ahead, the industry faces several critical junctures that could further shape market dynamics: 

  1. The conclusion of the 30-day North American détente could lead to a more stable trading environment or a return to heightened tensions.
  2. Potential expansion of Chinese tariffs to include key dairy products like whey, which have so far been spared but remain vulnerable.
  3. The upcoming 2026 review of the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) could reshape the North American dairy trade for years.

In this volatile climate, dairy producers and exporters must remain agile, ready to adapt to rapidly changing market conditions. Diversification of export markets, exploration of value-added product lines, and close monitoring of international trade policies will be crucial strategies for navigating these turbulent waters. 

Production Shifts and Export Trends 

The U.S. dairy industry is experiencing significant shifts in production patterns and export trends, with notable divergences between milk powder and cheese sectors. 

Milk Powder Production Decline 

U.S. milk powder output has substantially declined, with December production 15% lower than the prior year. This trend extends beyond a month, as 2024 milk powder production slumped 13% to reach the lowest annual total since 2013. Several factors contribute to this decline: 

  1. Shifting consumer preferences: Domestic consumers increasingly opt for alternative dairy products, reducing demand for traditional milk powder.
  2. Processing capacity reallocation: Many processors have shifted their focus to higher-value products like cheese and specialty ingredients, reducing capacity dedicated to milk powder production.
  3. Feed cost fluctuations: Rising feed costs have impacted milk production, with some farmers reducing herd sizes or shifting to alternative feed strategies.
  4. Environmental regulations: Stricter environmental policies in some states have reduced dairy herd sizes, impacting milk availability for powder production.

Booming Cheese Exports 

U.S. cheese exports are experiencing unprecedented growth compared to the milk powder sector. The U.S. exported 97 million pounds of cheese in December, marking a 21% increase compared to December 2023. This export surge has led to a record-breaking utilization of domestic production, with exports accounting for 8% of U.S. cheese production in 2024. Key drivers of this cheese export boom include: 

  1. Competitive pricing: U.S. cheese prices have become more competitive globally, attracting international buyers.
  2. Product diversification: American cheesemakers have expanded their product range, catering to diverse international tastes and preferences.
  3. Quality improvements: Investments in cheese-making technology and processes have enhanced the quality and consistency of U.S. cheese, making it more appealing to foreign markets.
  4. Trade agreements: Favorable trade agreements, particularly with Mexico and South Korea, have facilitated increased cheese exports.
  5. Marketing efforts: Aggressive marketing campaigns by U.S. dairy organizations have successfully promoted American cheese in key international markets.

Market Implications 

These contrasting trends in milk powder production and cheese exports have significant implications for the U.S. dairy industry: 

  1. Processor strategy shifts: More processors may pivot towards cheese production, given the strong export demand and higher profit margins than milk powder.
  2. Farm-level impacts: Dairy farmers may need to adjust their production strategies to meet the changing demand, potentially focusing on milk composition that favors cheese production.
  3. Global market positioning: The U.S. is strengthening as a significant cheese exporter while potentially ceding ground in the global milk powder market.
  4. Supply chain adaptations: U.S. dairy exports’ logistics and supply chain are likely to evolve, with increased focus on cheese transportation and storage.

As these trends unfold, the U.S. dairy industry must remain agile, adapting to changing global demand patterns and market opportunities. The contrasting fortunes of milk powder and cheese sectors underscore the importance of diversification and market responsiveness in the dynamic global dairy trade landscape.

Price Movements and Future Outlook 

YearAll-Milk Price Forecast (USD/cwt)
202523.05
202619.00
202719.10
202819.30
202919.50
203019.70

Source: USDA, Economic Research Service

The dairy market is experiencing significant price fluctuations across various products, reflecting the complex interplay of supply, demand, and global trade dynamics. 

CME Spot Market Trends: 

The CME spot nonfat dry milk (NDM) fell 1.5¢ to $1.33 per pound, reaching its lowest point since August. This decline suggests an oversupply in the milk powder market, potentially due to weakened export demand or increased domestic production. The drop in NDM prices could impact Class IV milk prices, as NDM is a key component. 

Similarly, CME spot Cheddar blocks also decreased, falling 1.75¢ to $1.86 per pound. This downward movement in cheese prices may indicate softening demand or increased production, which could pressure Class III milk prices. 

Global Dairy Trade (GDT) Auction Results: 

Unlike the CME spot market, the GDT auction demonstrated strength in powder markets. Whole milk powder (WMP) values jumped 4.1%, while skim milk powder (SMP) prices leapt 4.7%. These significant increases suggest robust international demand, particularly from key importing regions like Southeast Asia and China. The divergence between domestic U.S. prices and international auction results highlights the global nature of dairy trade and the potential for arbitrage opportunities. 

Future Price Outlook: 

The average milk price is forecast to rise by 5% in 2025 compared to 2024, driven by favorable trends in recent Global Dairy Trade auctions. This projection indicates a generally optimistic outlook for global dairy markets, supported by expectations of continued strong demand and potentially tightening supplies in major exporting regions. 

However, the U.S. market presents a contrasting picture, with projections of a decrease of 30 cents per hundredweight in all milk prices. This discrepancy between global trends and U.S. forecasts could be attributed to several factors: 

  • Domestic Supply and Demand Balance: The U.S. might increase milk production or face lower domestic demand than global markets.
  • Export Competitiveness: A stronger U.S. dollar or increased competition from other exporting nations could impact the U.S.’s position in global markets.
  • Policy Changes: Potential shifts in U.S. dairy policy or trade agreements could influence domestic pricing.
  • Regional Variations: The U.S. forecast may be more heavily influenced by specific regional production trends or processing capacities.

Implications for Dairy Farmers: 

These price movements and forecasts present a complex picture for dairy farmers. While global markets show signs of strength, U.S. producers may face challenges if domestic prices remain suppressed. Farmers must closely watch local and international market trends, adjust their production strategies, and explore new market opportunities to maximize their returns in this changing environment.

The Bottom Line

As the global dairy market navigates through unprecedented volatility in early 2025, dairy farmers worldwide find themselves at a critical juncture. The rising milk supply, shifting trade dynamics, and evolving consumer preferences create challenges and opportunities. While farmgate prices generally improve in many regions, trade tensions and potential tariffs loom large, particularly for U.S. producers eyeing the Mexican market. Success in this dynamic environment will hinge on adaptability and strategic foresight. Dairy farmers must focus on efficiency, embrace risk management strategies, and explore diversification opportunities. Whether investing in value-added products, adopting new technologies to address labor shortages, or implementing sustainable practices to meet evolving regulations, the path forward requires innovation and resilience. In 2025, the global dairy industry is positioned for growth but faces the risk of rapid changes due to geopolitical factors. Farmers who stay informed, remain flexible in their approaches, and capitalize on emerging market trends will be best positioned to thrive in this complex and ever-changing dairy ecosystem. 

How is your operation adapting to these market trends? Share your experiences and strategies in the comments below. 

Learn more:

Join the Revolution!

Bullvine Daily is your essential e-zine for staying ahead in the dairy industry. With over 30,000 subscribers, we bring you the week’s top news, helping you manage tasks efficiently. Stay informed about milk production, tech adoption, and more, so you can concentrate on your dairy operations. 

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

How Protectionism Could Shake Up the Global Dairy Trade

Protectionism is on the rise. Is your farm ready for the shake-up in global dairy trade? Here’s what you need to know now.

Summary: Feeling uneasy about the future of dairy trade? Rising protectionism is the latest curveball thrown into an already complex global market. Recent moves by China and Colombia to investigate subsidies in Europe and the U.S. could have far-reaching consequences on the dairy industry. Are you prepared for how these developments could impact your farm’s bottom line? “As a dairy farmer, understanding the implications of these trade investigations is crucial for navigating the upcoming challenges.” The global dairy trade is a complex industry with major players from Central Europe, North America, Oceania, and Asia. Exporters like New Zealand, the European Union, and the United States dominate the market, while importers like China, Mexico, and Southeast Asian nations rely on imports. International trade agreements like the US-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement (TPA) help reduce tariffs and set trade norms, but they are often criticized for potentially favoring one side. China’s Ministry of Commerce is investigating European agriculture subsidies, which could impact the global dairy sector. The European Union’s participation could result in excess output in Europe, potentially pushing down global prices and harming farmers worldwide. A growing trend of protectionism is affecting global trade relations, with Colombia’s dairy farmers alleging that these subsidies enable artificially cheap U.S. milk powder, undermining domestic dairy pricing and putting pressure on the sector. Dairy farmers need to diversify markets, form cooperatives, advocate for fair trade policies, stay informed, leverage technology, build strong relationships with local suppliers and customers, and consider value-added dairy products.

  • Rising protectionism poses a new challenge to the global dairy trade.
  • China and Colombia are investigating U.S. and European dairy subsidies.
  • These investigations could impact global dairy prices and affect your farm’s profitability.
  • Understanding trade agreements and their criticisms is crucial for staying informed.
  • Diversifying markets and forming cooperatives can help mitigate risks.
  • Staying updated on global trade developments is essential.
  • Leveraging technology and forming strong local relationships can offer stability.
  • Consider producing value-added dairy products to enhance your market position.
global dairy trade, complex industry, major players, Central Europe, North America, Oceania, Asia, exporters, New Zealand, European Union, United States, dominate market, importers, China, Mexico, Southeast Asian nations, rising demand, international trade agreements, US-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement (TPA), reducing tariffs, setting trade norms, criticized agreements, favoring one side, China's Ministry of Commerce, investigating European agriculture subsidies, unfair competitive advantage, impact global dairy sector, significant share, global dairy exports, excess output, Europe, pushing down global prices, harming farmers worldwide, growing trend, protectionism, Colombia's dairy farmers, subsidies, U.S. milk powder, artificially cheaply, undermining domestic dairy pricing, pressure on sector, tariffs, trade adjustments, TPA, increased U.S. dairy imports, diversifying markets, forming cooperatives, advocating for fair trade policies, staying informed, leveraging technology, building strong relationships, local suppliers, customers, value-added dairy products, proactive, aware, engaged, competent judgments, navigate tumultuous world.

Are you ready to take charge in the face of increased protectionism in the global dairy trade? As dairy producers, you have the power to navigate the changing landscape as governments scrutinize international subsidies. The recent probes by China and Colombia may alter long-standing trade agreements and market dynamics, but with the right strategies, you can steer your business through these challenges.

Take the European Union as an example. The EU, a significant player in the global dairy market, has been a major exporter of dairy products. However, the EU’s decision to impose tariffs on Chinese electric automobiles has sparked a retaliatory investigation by China’s Ministry of Commerce into Europe’s agricultural subsidies. This action, initiated at the request of Chinese dairy farmers, could have significant repercussions for European dairy exports.

On the opposite side of the world, Colombia’s government is scrutinizing U.S. funding. Colombian dairy farmers blame programs such as the Dairy Margin Coverage and the USDA’s Dairy Donation Program for the low cost of milk powder from the United States. With so much money flooding into the dairy business in the United States, Colombian farmers are concerned about their livelihoods.

The Global Dairy Showdown: How Major Players and Trade Agreements Shape the Market

The global dairy trade is a thriving business with participants from Central Europe, North America, Oceania, and Asia. Significant exporters, such as New Zealand, the European Union, and the United States, dominate the market, selling dairy products such as milk, cheese, and milk powder to nations across the globe. Fonterra Cooperative Group, based in New Zealand, is one of the world’s major dairy exporters, significantly impacting market trends.

Key importers include China, Mexico, and Southeast Asian nations, who depend on imports to fulfill rising demand. China, in particular, has experienced increased dairy imports to meet local demands due to growing consumer demand and limited domestic production capacity. Geographic indications (G.I.s) in the E.U. and cheese imports from the United States considerably impact commerce.

The US-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement (TPA) is a crucial international trade accord. This agreement, which came into force in 2012, has significantly influenced the global dairy trade. It has led to a considerable increase in U.S. milk powder shipments to Colombia, affecting the Colombian dairy market. Such agreements, while aiming to balance advantages between exporting and importing countries, are often criticized for potentially favoring one side.

These agreements affect trade flows and domestic industry. For example, the TPA has permitted the continual supply of U.S. dairy into Colombia, which some argue undercuts local farmers. This conflict demonstrates the delicate balance necessary to preserve fairness and competitiveness in the global dairy market, emphasizing the importance of continuing reviews and discussions.

China’s Investigation into European Subsidies: A Game-Changer for Global Dairy Trade? 

China’s Ministry of Commerce has begun extensively examining European agriculture subsidies. This initiative, spearheaded by Chinese dairy producers, seeks to determine if these subsidies provide European farmers an unfair competitive advantage. Experts fear that the inquiry might substantially impact the global dairy sector.

Beijing’s investigation followed the European Union’s decision to slap tariffs on most electric cars imported from China, intensifying trade tensions between the two industrial powerhouses. European dairy farmers have concerns about their market share in China and global commerce.

Stanford University economist Roger Noll states, “Trade barriers can disrupt established supply chains, leading to inefficiencies and reduced market access for many producers.” The European dairy sector, which already accounts for a sizable share of global dairy exports, may experience a fall in global competitiveness if China imposes more taxes or restrictions based on the investigation’s findings.

Data demonstrate that the European Union is a significant participant in the global dairy industry, with exports continuously increasing over the last decade [source]. Any interruptions caused by China’s discoveries might result in excess output in Europe, possibly pushing down global prices and harming farmers throughout the globe.

This inquiry into U.S. and European subsidies is part of a broader trend of growing protectionism, which has the potential to significantly alter global trade relations. The conclusions of these investigations could have long-term implications for market conditions and trade ties. They could lead to new trade obstacles or more egalitarian practices, reshaping the global dairy trade in the process.

How U.S. Subsidies Might Be Shaking Up The Global Dairy Market? Colombia Certainly Has Some Thoughts… 

How are U.S. subsidies affecting the global dairy market? Colombia undoubtedly has some ideas. They are looking at U.S. dairy subsidies, focusing on two essential programs: the Dairy Margin Coverage (DMC) program and the USDA’s Dairy Donation Program.

So, what is the crux of their complaints? Let’s dig in. The DMC program provides a significant safety net for U.S. dairy producers, with $1.65 billion issued in 2023 to cover the difference between milk prices and feed costs. Furthermore, the USDA’s Dairy Donation Program helps farmers buy excess milk products to distribute to food banks. Sounds useful.

Not if you are a Colombian dairy farmer. Colombia’s dairy farmers allege that these subsidies enable U.S. milk powder to be offered artificially cheaply, undermining domestic dairy pricing. They believe this makes it difficult for local farmers to compete, putting pressure on the sector.

Imagine being a Colombian dairy farmer trying to earn a livelihood, only to have your market inundated by cheaper U.S. milk powder. Tariffs and trade adjustments resulting from the United States-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement (TPA) are not helping since they have opened the door for increased U.S. dairy imports.

The Colombian government is delving deeply into the subsidy concerns, and the stakes are high. How will this probe impact the delicate balance of the global dairy trade? Will it result in new trade obstacles or more egalitarian practices? Only time will tell.

Impact on U.S. Dairy Exports: A Case Study with Colombia 

So, how can these investigations and possible trade restrictions affect the U.S. dairy sector, particularly shipments to Colombia? The stakes are enormous, given the importance of the US-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement (TPA) in defining this market.

Historically, the TPA allowed U.S. milk powder to flood the Colombian market. The deal, which went into effect in 2012, eliminated several trade obstacles that had previously limited U.S. dairy goods. Consequently, U.S. exports to Colombia have increased dramatically, with milk powder becoming a significant import.

Fast forward to the latest probe launched by Colombia’s government, and the situation may shift dramatically. Allegations that U.S. subsidies, such as the Dairy Margin Coverage program, artificially decrease prices have raised concerns. Colombian dairy producers believe these subsidies provide U.S. goods an unfair advantage, harming local farmers who cannot compete on price.

With greater on-farm profits and better weather conditions increasing local output, Colombia’s main dairy union is now looking for ways to restrict these U.S. imports. If successful, this might increase tariffs or outright limits on U.S. dairy goods entering Colombia.

Such actions would be troubling for U.S. dairy exporters. The TPA played a critical role in their present market domination, but government inquiries into subsidies may change this dynamic. The conclusion may restrict U.S. market access, requiring American dairy producers to seek new overseas markets or confront domestic overproduction issues.

The dairy industry in the United States is facing a difficult period. Understanding the historical backdrop and present dynamics may help stakeholders plan for future roadblocks and find methods to negotiate this complicated trading environment.

The Tug-of-War: Balancing Domestic Interests with International Trade Fairness 

Let us discuss the tug-of-war between home interests and international trade equity. Have you ever pondered how protectionism affects this delicate balance?

On the one hand, protectionism may be beneficial to local dairy producers. Assume you’re a dairy farmer facing stiff competition from low-cost imported milk powder. What could be better than government policies that shift the balance in your favor? These safeguards help keep pricing stable and your business profitable.

Consider the United States Dairy Margin Coverage scheme, for example. It awarded American dairy farmers with $1.65 billion in 2023 alone. This benefits domestic farmers, allowing them to weather economic crises and maintain consistent output.

However, let’s flip the coin. The same policies may disrupt international trade dynamics. Colombia’s complaint against U.S. dairy subsidies is a prime example. These subsidies have the potential to destabilize local markets in other countries by artificially lowering the price of U.S. milk powder. Colombian dairy farmers complain that this reduces their pricing, making it difficult to compete in their market.

Trade accords such as the US-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement seek to level the playing field. However, subsidies may distort this equilibrium, causing friction and disagreements.

So, where should we draw the line? Supporting local farmers is unquestionably essential. But so is preserving fair trading practices on a global scale. As these investigations evolve, one thing becomes clear: balancing local advantages and international justice is challenging.

Roger Noll states,  “Trade barriers can protect local industries in the short term, but they often lead to inefficiencies and conflicts down the line.”

What are your thoughts? How should governments negotiate this complex landscape?

What Dairy Farmers Need to Know: Navigating Rising Protectionism 

Do you feel trapped in the crossfire of global trade disputes? You are not alone. Rising protectionism is altering the dairy industry, and planning is critical. 

Here are some hands-on strategies to help you navigate these turbulent waters: 

  1. Diversify Your Markets 
    Depending on a single export market might be dangerous. Explore new markets to diversify your risk and reach a more extensive client base. Building a more significant market presence might protect you against unexpected trade interruptions.
  2. Form or Join Cooperatives 
    There’s power in numbers. Joining a cooperative may increase negotiating power and give access to a broader range of markets. Cooperatives may also assist in sharing resources and knowledge, making it easier to overcome trade risks.
  3. Advocate for Fair Trade Policies 
    Your voice matters. Engage with industry organizations to lobby for fair trade policies. Lobbying for clear rules may help guarantee a fair playing field worldwide, which will defend your interests.
  4. Stay Informed 
    Keep up with the most recent trade news and policy developments. Subscribe to industry publications, attend webinars, and engage in debates. Knowing what’s going on might help you predict changes and plan appropriately.
  5. Leverage Technology 
    Use technology to improve productivity and save expenses. Efficient methods may strengthen your operation’s resilience to market shifts. Consider investing in farm management software, precision agricultural instruments, and other innovative technologies.
  6. Build Strong Relationships 
    Foster partnerships with local suppliers and customers. Building a solid local network may offer a consistent market for your goods while reducing reliance on foreign commerce.
  7. Consider Value-Added Products 
    Consider creating value-added dairy products such as cheese, yogurt, and butter. These items often offer larger profit margins and may provide new market possibilities.

Using these methods, you will be better prepared to deal with increased protectionism uncertainties while protecting your dairy industry. Stay proactive, aware, and engaged; your farm’s future relies on it.

The Bottom Line

Understanding the repercussions of increasing protectionism is critical for dairy producers today. We’ve looked at how significant actors like China and Colombia are challenging the current quo in the global dairy trade, with the potential to reshape markets. As trade obstacles and government subsidies are reviewed, balancing local interests and international trade fairness becomes more critical.

Keeping up with these changes might help you make more competent judgments and navigate this tumultuous world. Diversifying markets, forming cooperatives, and harnessing technology are just a few options. The future of global dairy commerce remains uncertain—will protectionism stifle development or usher in a new age of fair competition? It’s an issue that every dairy farmer must consider as they navigate this ever-changing global economy.

Learn more: 

Send this to a friend