43% of H5N1 bailouts go to repeat offenders—some farms cashed 5 checks in 6 months, while you pay the bill

So I was chatting with a producer from Iowa—been farming since the 80s—tells me his operation got hit with H5N1 twice this year. Twice! And somehow he’s still collecting government checks. Makes you wonder what’s really going on, doesn’t it?
Look, everyone’s calling Nebraska’s latest case “unfortunate timing” with fall migration. Sure, blame the ducks. But here’s what really gets me—and this might surprise you—according to Farm Forward’s July 2025 Freedom of Information Act analysis, 43% of all federal H5N1 compensation is going to farms that have experienced multiple outbreaks.
Now, before you start thinking these farmers are gaming the system, it’s more complicated than that. Some operations might be dealing with geographic challenges—maybe they’re in flyways where the virus keeps circulating, or they’re downstream from infected operations. But the pattern still raises questions about how our bailout system works.
The Numbers Tell a Story
You wanna know who’s collecting the most? Prado Dairy in Colorado pulled in over $1.5 million from Uncle Sam, according to the USDA compensation records that Farm Forward obtained through their FOIA request. Wolf Creek, Meadowvale, Sierra View—same story, different day.
These aren’t necessarily bad actors. But they are big operations with resources that smaller farms don’t have, and they’re navigating a system that covers 90% of losses through the Emergency Livestock Assistance Program with no cap on claims.
Dr. Julie Gauthier, who’s the Executive Director of Veterinary Services at USDA APHIS, keeps talking about “voluntary testing” and “producer cooperation.” Meanwhile, there’s essentially no financial penalty for getting hit repeatedly.
It’s like having fire insurance that pays out every time you leave the stove on.
What the Science Actually Shows

Felipe Peña-Mosca and his team at Cornell published research in Nature Communications—March 2025—tracking one Ohio herd through a complete H5N1 outbreak—3,900 head. Real numbers, no modeling BS.
Each infected cow lost 945 kilograms of milk over two months. That’s nearly $950 per head walking out your parlor door, based on their economic analysis. But here’s what’s really concerning—89% of that herd developed antibodies, meaning this thing spread through that barn mostly undetected. Only 20% showed obvious clinical signs.
You could have four-fifths of your herd infected and not even know it until your butterfat numbers tank.
Dr. Paul Virkler from Cornell’s been studying this stuff, and he’s found something that should scare the hell out of all of us: rumination time and milk production start dropping about five days before you see any clinical signs. Five days!
That’s your early warning window—if you’re watching for it.
The Transmission Reality Nobody Talks About
The thing about this virus is that everyone keeps blaming the waterfowl. And sure, ducks and geese bring H5N1 onto farms—the research from USDA APHIS and Cornell is crystal clear on that. Wild birds are the primary introduction route.
But then it’s our own boots, equipment, and trucks that move it around farms and between operations. The Cornell study shows this pretty clearly—once it’s in your barn, human activity becomes the major factor in how far and fast it spreads.
And once cows are infected? They don’t bounce back like everyone thinks. The Cornell team followed infected animals for 60 days after diagnosis—their production stayed depressed the entire time. This isn’t mastitis, where you lose milk for two weeks and recover. The virus replicates right in the mammary gland tissue, destroys the milk-secreting cells.
Some of these cows might never produce the same again.
The Psychology Behind Profitable Failure
What really concerns me is what Dr. Joe Armstrong from the University of Minnesota Extension told me: “I am 100% expecting this to result in many arguments with clients.”
He’s watching veterinarians get caught between USDA requirements and farmers who… well, some who still think this whole thing’s overblown. Meanwhile, operations keep getting hit, keep collecting checks, and the cycle continues.
When there’s no real financial consequences for getting hit repeatedly—when Uncle Sam covers 90% of your losses—where’s the incentive to invest heavily in prevention?
And don’t even get me started on California. Over 650 herds were infected by November 2024. Milk production down 9.2% year-over-year—the biggest drop in twenty years. Yet the biggest operations keep floating on government support while family farms get squeezed out.
The Bigger Picture We’re Missing

California’s just the canary in the coal mine. According to USDA APHIS data, we’ve had 973 confirmed cases across 17 states as of February 2025. That’s not just scattered bad luck—that’s systematic vulnerability.
We lost over 16,000 farms between 2018 and 2023. The closure rate hit 12.2% in 2023 alone. While family operations disappear, the bailout system is essentially subsidizing some survivors to maintain practices that leave them vulnerable to repeated outbreaks.

That’s not building industry resilience. That’s creating systematic dependency.
What Actually Works (When Folks Want It To)
New strains keep popping up—that D1.1 variant caught Nevada operations off guard, even though they’d dealt with H5N1 before. The virus isn’t standing still while we figure out policy.
The industry’s splitting into two groups: maybe 30% of operations that implement serious biosecurity and achieve genuine resilience, while others get stuck in cycles of infection and bailouts.
So what’s a producer supposed to do?
Lock up your feed during migration season. All of it. TMR, corn, silage, everything. This isn’t rocket science—if wild birds can’t access your feed, they can’t contaminate it.
Cut cattle access to natural water sources. I know that the stock pond’s been there since your grandfather’s time, but infected waterfowl can turn it into a disease reservoir overnight.
Get monitoring technology that flags trouble before your bank account feels it. Those rumination sensors and milk meters Dr. Virkler mentioned—they can give you that five-day warning. That’s five days you could be implementing containment instead of watching it spread.
Make your vet your biosecurity partner, not just your treatment provider. No more Mr. Nice Guy routine when it comes to prevention protocols.
The Forward-Looking Disaster
But honestly? I’m worried we’re past the point where individual farm actions matter enough. When nearly half the bailout money goes to repeat cases, when there’s little incentive to prevent rather than collect compensation… we’re not building resilience.
We’re creating dependency.
The good news for consumers is that pasteurization kills H5N1 in milk—the CDC and FDA are crystal clear on that. But that doesn’t protect your cash flow, your family’s future, or your ability to stay in this business.
The question isn’t whether more farms will get hit. It’s whether we’ll have sustainable dairy operations left when this is over, or just farms that’ve learned to navigate the bailout system better than they prevent disease.
Because while some operations perfect that navigation, independent producers are fighting for the future of American dairy farming. And right now? The dependency model is winning.
Time to decide what kind of industry we want to build.
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
- Financial Reality Check: Basic migration-season biosecurity costs $50-75 per cow annually vs. $950 losses per infected animal—yet 43% of bailouts reward farms choosing subsidized failure over prevention
- Early Detection Advantage: Cornell research proves monitoring technology detects H5N1 production drops 5 days before clinical signs, giving smart operators crucial containment time while competitors wait for obvious symptoms
- Competitive Positioning: While repeat offenders collect government checks, operations implementing enclosed feed storage, water isolation, and veterinary partnerships during September-November migration create sustainable advantages in an industry losing 12% of farms yearly
- Market Intelligence: The 30% of farms achieving genuine H5N1 resilience will dominate as bailout-dependent operations face eventual policy changes—position now while competitors remain psychologically invested in government dependency
- Strategic Implementation: Lock feed storage, eliminate shared water sources, deploy rumination monitoring, and make veterinarians biosecurity enforcers—because building prevention capability beats perfecting bailout collection every time
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The H5N1 outbreak has morphed from a disease crisis into a systematic bailout scheme that’s destroying American dairy from within. According to Farm Forward’s FOIA analysis, 43% of federal compensation goes to farms getting infected repeatedly, with operations like Prado Dairy collecting over $1.5 million while family farms disappear at 12% annually. Cornell’s latest research shows infected cows lose 945kg of milk worth $950 each, yet USDA covers 90% with no claim limits, creating perverse incentives where prevention costs less than subsidized failure. While corporate ag publications focus on duck migration, the real story is how repeat bailout recipients game taxpayer-funded programs instead of implementing $75-per-cow biosecurity that actually works. This isn’t building industry resilience—it’s creating systematic dependency that threatens the 24,000 remaining dairy operations across America. The data reveals we’re not fighting a virus anymore; we’re watching the birth of subsidized incompetence while independent producers get squeezed out by operations that’ve mastered the art of profitable failure.
Complete references and supporting documentation are available upon request by contacting the editorial team at editor@thebullvine.com.
Learn More:
- HPAI H5N1: The 2025 Science-Based Dairy Farm Survival Guide (Because Hope Isn’t a Biosecurity Plan) – This article provides a tactical playbook for immediate action. It reveals practical biosecurity hacks, such as using laser bird deterrents and HEPA filters, that offer concrete ways to reduce risk and protect your operation, demonstrating how to move from a mindset of dependency to one of prevention.
- H5N1 Is Slamming American Dairies: The $950 Cow Loss, Hidden Biosecurity Risks, and How Smart Farms Are Fighting Back – This strategic-focused piece dissects the long-term economic impact of H5N1, showing how progressive farms are turning government bailouts and grants into investment capital for technology and biosecurity upgrades. It reveals how to build a competitive edge in a volatile market by embracing data-driven resilience.
- The Vaccine Race That Will Make or Break the Dairy Industry: HPAI Solutions on the Horizon – This article provides a forward-looking perspective on the innovative solutions being developed to combat H5N1. It examines the promises and challenges of new vaccine technologies, from subunit to mRNA, offering crucial market intelligence on the future of disease control and prevention.
Join the Revolution!
Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.

Join the Revolution!







