Heat stress hits fertility earlier than you think! New THI thresholds & genetic insights mean it’s time to rethink your cooling & breeding strategies.

Your herd’s reproductive performance is taking a nosedive long before you see them panting at the bunk line. Groundbreaking research reveals conception damage begins at surprisingly low temperature thresholds, and the genetic implications could revolutionize your AI strategy in our warming climate. If you’re waiting for signs of heat stress before activating cooling systems, you’re already months behind in protecting your herd’s reproductive efficiency.

The Hidden Fertility Crisis Lurking in Your Barn

If you’re like most dairy producers, you’ve accepted poor summer conception rates and extended days open as an unavoidable seasonal challenge. You’ve probably resigned yourself to watching your 21-day pregnancy rate plummet like milk prices in 2009, chalking it up as just another summer headache along with higher SCC and reduced components.

But what if I told you those fertility losses were starting far earlier than you realize, in conditions you wouldn’t even consider “hot”?

A landmark study published in the Journal of Dairy Science (Genetic analysis of the impact of heat stress on fertility traits in dairy cows in the Netherlands) shatters conventional wisdom about when heat stress impacts dairy cow fertility. The researchers analyzed data from a staggering 416,814 first-parity Holstein cows across the Netherlands, looking at four critical fertility parameters that drive reproductive efficiency and your dairy’s bottom line.

What they found should change how dairy producers approach sire selection strategies and environmental management. But before diving into those findings, let’s clarify exactly what we’re measuring.

Beyond Temperature: Why THI Matters More Than Your Thermometer

You’ve probably heard of the Temperature-Humidity Index (THI). It’s been the gold standard for quantifying heat stress in livestock for decades, and for good reason. THI combines the dual impacts of temperature and humidity into a single value that better reflects what your cows experience.

Because let’s face it, an 85°F day in Arizona feels dramatically different than an 85°F day in Florida. The difference? Humidity. And your cows think it even more acutely than you do.

The researchers in this study used various THI calculations to determine which measurement most accurately predicted fertility impacts. They found that the average THI from three days- the day of insemination plus one day before and after (THI3)-was most strongly associated with fertility outcomes.

Here’s where things get interesting: why this new research is so groundbreaking. The traditional THI thresholds we’ve all been taught (typically that mild heat stress begins around THI 68-72) were primarily established based on impacts on milk production, not reproductive efficiency. As you wouldn’t use the same metrics to evaluate your dry cow program and fresh cow protocols, we shouldn’t use milk production thresholds to predict reproductive declines.

And as it turns out, your cows’ reproductive systems are far more sensitive to heat than we ever realized, about as sensitive as your bottom line is to an extended calving interval.

The Shocking Truth: Fertility Damage Starts in Spring-Like Conditions

The research team identified specific THI thresholds where each fertility trait began to decline:

• THI 60 for conception rate and interval from first to last insemination
• THI 50 for the interval from calving to first insemination and calving interval

Let that sink in. THI 50. That’s not even close to what we traditionally consider “heat stress” territory.

To put this in perspective, a THI of 50 can occur at temperatures as modest as 65°F (18°C) when humidity is elevated. We’re talking spring weather in many dairy regions- conditions where your cows aren’t even breaking a sweat, and you’re still more concerned about mud season than heat abatement.

But the data doesn’t lie. At these surprisingly low THI levels, researchers observed:

• Longer delays from calving to first breeding
• Extended calving intervals
• More services per conception (when THI hits 60)
• Reduced conception rates (when THI hits 60)

These findings force us to reconsider when heat abatement strategies should begin. If you’re only activating cooling systems when cows show visible signs of heat stress-elevated respiration rates, decreased dry matter intake, crowding around waterers-you’re already weeks or months behind in protecting their fertility. That’s like waiting until your bulk tank average drops before addressing a subclinical mastitis problem.

Fresh Cows vs. Breeding Cows: Why Different Thresholds Matter

One of the most fascinating aspects of this research is the discovery of different THI thresholds for different fertility parameters. This isn’t just academic trivia- it has profound implications for managing various cohorts in your herd.

The interval from calving to first insemination begins to lengthen at THI 50, while conception rate doesn’t decline significantly until THI 60. Why the difference?

Early postpartum cows, critical first 60-90 days in milk, are especially vulnerable to mild heat stress. The physiological demands of recovering from the transition period, launching a new lactation, and restarting ovarian cyclicity create a perfect storm of sensitivity. These fresh cows are like high-performance athletes at the start of training season- even small disruptions can throw off their entire program.

For these fresh cows, even moderate environmental challenges can delay follicular development, suppress estradiol production, and push back that crucial first breeding. The hypothalamic-pituitary-ovarian axis is delicately recalibrating after calving, and heat stress throws a wrench in the works by suppressing luteinizing hormone (LH) secretion and altering progesterone levels. This disruption directly impacts the formation of the corpus luteum and compromises ovarian function.

Meanwhile, cows already cycling normally seem to have slightly more heat tolerance before conception rates suffer (THI 60 vs. 50). But make no mistake-both- both thresholds are still far lower than we’ve been taught.

What This Means For Your Operation: Your fresh pen needs superior cooling compared to the rest of your facility, and those cooling systems need to activate at much lower temperatures than you’re likely using now. Just as you wouldn’t feed your close-up dry cows the same TMR as your high producers, you shouldn’t provide them with identical environmental conditions.

The Genetic Breakthrough That Changes Everything

Now we get to what might be the most revolutionary finding in the entire study. And it’s not just about when heat stress impacts fertility, it’s about which cows are affected and why.

The researchers discovered that genetic variance and heritability for fertility traits increased as THI levels increased. In plain language? Heat stress unmasks genetic differences in fertility that remain hidden under normal conditions.

Some cows maintain relatively good fertility even when heat-stressed, while others fall off a reproductive cliff at the first hint of warm weather. It’s like the difference between your rock-solid brood cows that breed back like clockwork regardless of conditions, versus those problematic repeat breeders that give your AI technician nightmares every summer.

Even more striking, they found significant “genotype-by-environment interactions” for all fertility traits. Translation: the daughters of a bull that ranks highly for Daughter Pregnancy Rate (DPR) under cool conditions might perform terribly when heat-stressed, while another bull’s daughters might show exceptional fertility, specifically under heat-stress conditions.

This finding completely upends traditional approaches to genetic selection for fertility, which typically assumes a bull’s fertility ranking applies equally across all environmental conditions. It’s like discovering that the feed efficiency rankings of your TMR ingredients change entirely depending on whether you’re feeding a high-forage or high-grain diet.

Heat Stress Thresholds: Old vs. New Understanding

Fertility Parameter	Traditional THI Threshold	Actual THI Threshold	What This Means
Conception Rate	68-72	60	Fertility decline starts ~10°F cooler than previously thought
Calving to First Insemination	68-72	50	Fresh cows are affected at even milder temperatures
First to Last Insemination	68-72	60	More straws are needed once THI exceeds 60
Overall Calving Interval	68-72	50	Extended days open begin at a surprisingly low THI

Breeding Strategies for a Warming World

The genetic findings from this research open exciting new possibilities for dairy breeders and farmers. Here are strategies worth considering:

Rethink Your Sire Selection

The traditional fertility indexes like Daughter Pregnancy Rate (DPR), Daughter Fertility (DF), or Cow Conception Rate (CCR) may not tell the whole story about how a bull’s daughters will perform in heat-stressed conditions. Ask your genetics provider about heat tolerance data and performance under challenging environmental conditions.

Consider bulls specifically tested and proven under similar conditions for regions prone to heat stress. A bull whose daughters show consistently good fertility across diverse environmental challenges may be more valuable than one with superior performance only under optimal conditions. Your breeding program needs to be more like your nutrition program- adaptable to changing conditions rather than optimized for a single scenario.

Consider Breed Differences

While the Ojo study focused exclusively on Holsteins, other research has demonstrated significant breed differences in heat tolerance. Jersey cattle, for instance, typically show greater resilience to heat stress than Holsteins- their smaller body mass creates a more favorable surface area-to-body mass ratio for dissipating heat.

Research from South Africa found Jersey cows maintained lower rectal temperatures than Friesians under identical heat stress conditions. Jersey heat tolerance is attributed to smaller body size, lighter hair color, thinner skin, and less fat deposits. Studies have shown that fertility rates in Jerseys decline less steeply than in Holsteins as THI increases, particularly at THI levels above 75.

For operations in hot climates, crossbreeding strategies incorporating heat-tolerant breeds might offer a quicker path to improved fertility than selection within a single breed. Like many producers have successfully employed Jersey or Viking Red crossbreeding to improve components or health traits, strategic crossbreeding could be the fastest route to heat-tolerant fertility.

Watch for Emerging Genetic Tools

The increased heritability of fertility traits under heat stress suggests that genomic selection for heat tolerance could be highly effective. As our understanding of the genetic basis for heat tolerance expands, expect to see new genomic tools specifically targeting this trait.

Some breeding companies are already developing heat tolerance indexes. These will become increasingly sophisticated and valuable as more data becomes available from such studies. Heat-tolerance selection could soon become as common in your breeding program as selection for casein variants or hoof health.

Practical Heat Abatement: Starting Earlier and Getting Smarter

Now that we know fertility decline starts at much lower THI thresholds than previously thought, it’s time to rethink our approach to cooling. Here are practical steps every dairy can implement:

1. Revamp Your Cooling Activation Points

Most dairy cooling systems are programmed to activate when temperatures reach 75-80°F. Based on this research, that’s far too late to protect fertility, like waiting until clinical mastitis appears before treating an elevated SCC cow. Reprogram your cooling system controllers to start at lower thresholds- ideally when conditions could create a THI of 50-60.

In practical terms:

• Fans should begin operating at approximately 65°F when humidity is moderate to high
• Sprinkler/soaker systems should activate around 70°F, significantly earlier than typical settings

2. Create Fertility Protection Zones

Not all parts of your facility need identical cooling. Create strategic “fertility protection zones” with enhanced cooling in areas where:

• Fresh cows are housed (most sensitive to THI > 50)
• Breeding pens are located (to maintain THI < 60 around insemination)
• Heat detection occurs (to encourage normal expression of estrus)

This approach is similar to how you might group your ration requirements- your high-fertility pens, like your high-production groups, need premium conditions to perform at their best.

3. Implement 24-Hour Cooling During Critical Windows

The 72 hours surrounding insemination (day before, day of, day after) appear particularly important for conception success. Consider implementing 24-hour cooling protocols during these critical windows, even if you typically reduce cooling at night.

It could be cost-effective for larger herds to design a specific “recently bred” pen with premium cooling for cows in their first 3-7 days post-insemination. Think of it as the reproductive equivalent of your fresh pen place where extra attention pays dividends for the entire lactation.

4. Invest in Precision Monitoring

The specific THI thresholds identified (50 and 60) make a strong case for investing in environmental monitoring systems that track temperature AND humidity in real-time throughout your facilities.

Several companies now offer barn monitoring systems that calculate THI continuously and can integrate with automated cooling controls. These systems can help you activate cooling strategies at precisely the right moments to protect fertility. Just as precision dairy monitoring has revolutionized health and feed management, it can transform your approach to environmental management.

The Economic Reality: What’s at Stake

Let’s talk dollars and cents. The fertility impacts identified in this research translate directly to your bottom line.

Consider the cumulative costs of:

• Additional inseminations at $25-50 each
• Extended days open at $2-5 per day
• Reduced milk production from lengthened calving intervals
• Increased involuntary culling due to reproduction failures
• Extra labor for heat abatement and reproductive management

For a 1,000-cow dairy, these costs can easily accumulate to tens of thousands of dollars annually, enough to make or break your profit margin in today’s volatile milk market.

But here’s the real kicker: because the THI thresholds for fertility decline are so much lower than previously thought, many operations are experiencing these losses without even recognizing heat stress as the culprit.

Those mediocre summer conception rates you’ve learned to live with? That extended calving interval that seems unavoidable? According to this research, they may not be inevitable; they result from unrecognized heat stress thresholds. It’s like discovering that subclinical hypocalcemia has been quietly draining your herd’s performance for years without obvious symptoms.

What This Means for the Future of Dairy

The implications of this research extend far beyond individual farm management. As global temperatures continue to rise, heat stress is becoming a more pervasive challenge for dairy producers worldwide, even in regions previously considered moderate climates.

The dairy industry faces a choice: adapt our breeding and management practices to this new reality, or watch fertility and profitability decline as temperatures rise. This is eerily similar to the antibiotic resistance challenge; we can adapt our practices proactively or face increasingly difficult conditions reactively.

The good news is that the same research identifying these challenges also points toward solutions. The increased genetic variation in heat tolerance provides the raw material for breeding more resilient cows. And the precise identification of THI thresholds gives us actionable triggers for management interventions.

The Bottom Line

The groundbreaking research fundamentally changes our thoughts about heat stress and dairy cow fertility. The key takeaways every dairy producer should implement:

1. Recognize that fertility damage begins far earlier than visible heat stress symptoms, THI thresholds of 50-60, not the 68-72 traditionally taught.
2. Implement cooling strategies earlier in the season and activate them at lower temperature-humidity combinations than you probably use now.
3. Pay special attention to fresh cows and those approaching first insemination, as they appear most sensitive to mild heat stress (THI 50).
4. Rethink your breeding program to incorporate heat tolerance, especially if your operation faces significant seasonal heat challenges.
5. Monitor THI levels in your barn, not just temperature, as the combination of heat and humidity truly impacts your cows.

Are you still waiting for panting cows before activating your cooling systems? Are you selecting bulls based on fertility data that ignores heat tolerance? If so, this research suggests you leave significant reproductive performance and profits on the table.

The days of accepting poor summer fertility as inevitable are over with this new understanding of when and how heat stress impacts reproduction. dairy producers know how to maintain reproductive performance even as our climate keeps warming.

The question isn’t whether you can afford to implement these changes. Given the substantial economic losses associated with heat-induced fertility decline, the real question is: Can you afford not to? After all, managing heat stress is like managing transition cows; an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.

What changes will you make to your cooling and breeding strategies before this summer? Your herd’s reproductive performance and your profitability depend on the answer.

Key Takeaways:

• Fertility decline begins at lower THI: Calving to first insemination and calving interval are affected at THI 50; conception rate and first-to-last insemination interval at THI 60.
• Heat stress unmasks genetic differences: Genetic variance and heritability for fertility traits increase under heat stress, making selection for heat tolerance more feasible.
• Genotype x Environment (GxE) is real: Sire rankings for fertility can change depending on THI levels, necessitating new approaches to genetic selection for heat-prone environments.
• Actionable thresholds for management: Dairy farmers should implement cooling strategies before THI reaches 50 to protect early reproductive recovery and intensify efforts before THI 60 to safeguard conception.
• Breeding for resilience is key: The findings support incorporating heat stress considerations into breeding programs to develop inherently more heat-tolerant dairy cattle.

Executive Summary:

Recent research on Holstein cows reveals that heat stress, quantified by the Temperature-Humidity Index (THI), negatively impacts dairy cow fertility at lower thresholds than previously understood. The interval from calving to first insemination and overall calving interval begin to suffer at a THI of 50, while conception rates and the interval from first to last insemination decline above a THI of 60. Crucially, the study found that genetic variance and heritability for fertility traits increase under heat stress, indicating significant genotype-by-environment interactions. This suggests that sire rankings for fertility can change with THI levels, opening opportunities for breeding more heat-resilient animals by selecting for superior performance under thermal stress. These findings call for proactive on-farm cooling strategies at these newly identified, lower THI thresholds and a re-evaluation of genetic selection programs to prioritize heat tolerance.

Learn more:

• Heat Stress in Dairy Cattle: Understanding the Long-term Consequences
• Heat-Proof Genetics: Why Your Shade Structures Aren’t Enough Anymore
• Maximizing Dairy Cow Fertility Through Genetic Selection: Current Strategies and Future Directions

Join the Revolution!

Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.