Dairy booms, beef tightens, feed costs shift: Master 2025-26 ag markets with key WASDE insights. Act now or risk margins!
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The 2025-2026 agricultural outlook reveals critical shifts: Dairy production grows (227B+ lbs) with strong 2025 prices ($21.60/cwt) before moderating in 2026, while beef faces supply constraints (+$214/cwt fed cattle) from halted Mexican imports. Feed markets split-corn prices drop (.20/bushel) but soybean meal surges (0/ton)-forcing ration strategy overhauls. Federal milk pricing reforms and weather risks add complexity, demanding proactive risk management, genetic adjustments, and efficiency gains to protect profits amid volatile margins.
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
- Dairy’s 12-month window: Capitalize on 2025’s $21.60/cwt milk prices before 2026’s supply-driven dip.
- Beef’s supply crunch: Fed cattle prices peak at $214/cwt (Q4 2025) amid import disruptions-optimize cull values.
- Feed cost chess: Lock in cheap corn ($4.20/bushel) but brace for pricier protein (soybean meal +$10/ton).
- Regulatory pivot: Federal milk pricing changes (June 2025) require immediate component strategy reviews.
- Risk reigns: Weather, trade, and demand volatility demand hedging, efficiency focus, and flexible feed sourcing.
The May 2025 WASDE report reveals a perfect opportunity for progressive dairy producers: higher milk component values alongside increasing production for the next 12 months, followed by potential margin compression in 2026. But here’s the uncomfortable truth – most dairies will fail to capitalize on this rare market advantage because they’re still operating with outdated feed and financial strategies that made sense a decade ago.
Let’s cut through the noise. The May 2025 WASDE report has handed us a production roadmap that every commercial dairy should scrutinize. After month-over-month upward revisions, USDA is now projecting what nutritionists call a “positive feedback loop” – growing milk production AND strengthening prices through 2025, before the Federal Order formula changes and supply fundamentals shift the balance in 2026.
If you’ve been holding back on that robotic milker investment or postponing those genomic testing plans, the data suggests a 12-month window of opportunity before supply growth begins to outpace demand.
But ask yourself this – are you actually prepared to execute when opportunity knocks, or will you be caught flat-footed like 70% of operations were during the last market upswing?
Dual Growth Drivers: Expanding Herds, Higher Components
The May WASDE report significantly revised milk production expectations upward, with total 2025 milk production now forecast at 227.3 billion pounds – a substantial 400 million pound increase from last month’s projection.
What’s driving this growth? USDA cites two key factors: expanding herd size and accelerating milk per cow. For commercial dairy producers, this dual growth story represents a significant evolution compared to recent years when gains came primarily through culling lower-performing animals rather than true expansion.
The uncomfortable reality most consultants won’t tell you: If your rolling herd average is still under 26,000 pounds with components below national averages, you’re already being left behind.
The top 20% of dairies are pushing 32,000+ pounds with superior component performance, creating a widening profitability gap that will become catastrophic when margins tighten in 2026.
As Dr. Mike Hutjens from the University of Illinois often reminds producers: “The national rolling herd average only tells half the story – component production and feed efficiency determine your milk check reality.”
Yet how many of us are still chasing outdated productivity metrics while the real leaders are focusing on income over feed cost per stall?
Price Picture: 2025’s Component Strength vs. 2026’s Reality Check
The price outlook reveals a distinct two-phase pattern that any strategic dairy producer needs to recognize: stronger-than-expected component values in 2025, followed by moderate pressure in 2026.
For 2025, all major dairy commodities have seen upward price revisions with the all-milk price raised 50 cents to $21.60 per cwt.
Here’s what most analysts won’t tell you: this opportunity will be completely squandered by operations that continue to manage their farms reactively rather than proactively.
Think about it – how many times have we seen farms wait until prices rise before implementing expansion plans? Or delay risk management until markets begin to soften?
Yet the data consistently shows that the farms who thrive long-term make their most important strategic moves counter-cyclically – expanding when others contract, locking in margins when others gamble, and building financial reserves when cash flow is abundant.
Federal Order Changes: The Mid-Year Component Recalibration
The X-factor in these projections is the implementation of Federal Milk Marketing Order updates effective June 1, 2025. These formula changes will fundamentally alter how your components are valued for the remainder of 2025 and beyond.
Are you among the minority of producers who have actually modeled how these changes will affect your specific operation, or are you still relying on generalized commentary from your cooperative?
The reality is that the impact will vary dramatically depending on your farm’s component profile, geographic location, and marketing arrangements – yet most producers are flying blind into this transition.
2026: The Coming Component Squeeze
Looking ahead to 2026, the price trajectory shifts downward with the all-milk price forecast at $21.15 per cwt (down $0.45 from 2025).
| Year | All-Milk Price | Class III | Class IV | Production |
| 2025 | $21.60/cwt | $18.70/cwt | $18.45/cwt | 227.3B lbs |
| 2026 | $21.15/cwt | $17.50/cwt | $18.10/cwt | 227.9B lbs |
| Change | -$0.45 | -$1.20 | -$0.35 | +0.6B lbs |
The relationship between Class III and Class IV prices in 2026 deserves particular attention.
Despite overall lower dairy prices, Class IV ($18.10) is forecast higher than Class III ($17.50). This suggests butterfat may hold value better than protein in 2026 – a critical factor that should be informing your breeding decisions today.
But let’s be honest: how many dairy producers are still making genetic selections as if it were 2010?
The Genetic Strategy Disconnect: Are You Breeding for Yesterday’s Markets?
Most dairy producers continue using outdated genetic selection indexes that no longer align with where component values are heading. This disconnect between breeding strategy and market reality creates a hidden but substantial economic drag.
Consider this: The Class III/IV price inversion projected for 2026 signals a fundamental shift in component valuation. While protein has historically commanded premium value, the WASDE data suggests butterfat will retain relatively stronger value as markets moderate. Yet according to a 2024 analysis by The Bullvine, over 65% of commercial dairies are still using genetic selection indexes heavily weighted toward protein production.
The economic cost of this misalignment is staggering.
Data from Progressive Dairy’s benchmarking program shows that operations aligning their genetic strategy with forecasted component values achieve $0.75-$1.25 higher income over feed cost per hundredweight compared to those using outdated selection criteria. For a 1,000-cow operation, this represents $175,000-$300,000 in annual profitability difference.
Dr. Kent Weigel, dairy cattle genetics specialist at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, explains: “Producers who adjust their genetic selection criteria to match projected component values typically see the economic benefits within 24-36 months. The challenge is that many are making breeding decisions today based on yesterday’s milk markets, not tomorrow’s component values.”
Ask yourself: When was the last time you sat down with your genetic advisor to specifically review how your breeding program aligns with forecasted component valuations for 2026-2027?
Feed Cost Chess: TMR Optimization as Corn Drops, Bypass Proteins Rise
The feed outlook presents the kind of complex puzzle that separates elite operations from the merely average. Think of it as a chess game where your ability to optimize metabolizable protein while managing energy costs will directly impact your income over feed cost (IOFC).
Corn: Record Production, Lower Energy Costs
The 2025-26 U.S. corn outlook is impressively bullish for buyers, projecting:
- Corn crop: 15.8 billion bushels (up 6% from last year)
- Season-average price: $4.20 per bushel (down 15 cents from 2024-25)
Soybeans: Tighter RUP Supplies, Higher Prices
While corn costs ease, the soybean outlook tells a different story:
- 2025-26 soybean price: $10.25 per bushel (up from $9.95 in 2024-25)
- Soybean meal: $310 per ton (up $10 from 2024-25)
“This divergence creates what nutritionists call a challenging ‘nutrient-to-cost ratio’ environment,” explains Dr. Randy Shaver of the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
At least 60% of dairy operations are still formulating rations based on crude protein percentages rather than metabolizable protein and amino acid profiles – an outdated approach that’s leaving significant money on the table.
When was the last time you challenged your nutritionist to show you the actual amino acid profile of your ration? Or asked them to demonstrate the economic impact of substituting different protein sources?
The uncomfortable truth is that many dairy nutritionists continue recommending what’s familiar rather than what’s optimal.
Your Feed Strategy Advantage
This mixed feed cost picture creates a competitive advantage for producers who:
- Lock in favorable corn prices while they last
- Explore alternative bypass protein sources beyond traditional soybean meal
- Maximize digestible fiber and protein in home-grown forages
- Implement precision feed management that most operations still view as “too complicated”
The reality most won’t acknowledge: While we obsess over milk prices, the difference between top and bottom quartile feed efficiency often exceeds $2.00/cwt in profitability – larger than most price fluctuations we worry about.
Beef’s Bull Run: Capitalizing on Genomics and Strategic Culling
While dairy production expands, the beef sector faces constraints that create opportunities for strategic dairy producers who understand crossbreeding value.
Fed cattle prices have been raised significantly, with the 2025 average now forecast at $214.51 per cwt and highest prices expected in the fourth quarter.
Yet how many dairies are still treating beef as an afterthought rather than a strategic profit center?
The hard truth is that progressive operations are generating an additional $100-150 per lactation through strategic beef programs, while traditional dairies continue viewing beef as merely a byproduct of milk production.
“The economic signal is clear,” notes Dan Schaefer, beef specialist at the University of Wisconsin. “Dairy producers who implement strategic crossbreeding programs for the bottom third of their herd based on genomic data are capturing a significant premium in the current market environment.”
Have you calculated how much money you’re leaving on the table by not implementing a strategic beef program?
For a 1,000-cow dairy, the difference between basic and optimized beef strategies often exceeds $100,000 annually – equivalent to a $1.00/cwt improvement in milk price.
Your Strategic Roadmap: Five Actions to Take Now
Given the projections for 2025 and 2026, here are five strategic moves that will separate the leaders from the laggards:
1. Re-evaluate Your Risk Management Plan
The hard truth: Most farms’ “risk management plans” are little more than reactions to market movements rather than systematic approaches to protecting margins.
With milk prices projected stronger for 2025 but moderating in 2026, now is the time to implement a strategic margin management plan. Consider:
- Securing floor prices for 2025 production that allow participation in potential upside
- Beginning to establish price floors for early 2026 production as favorable opportunities arise
- Staggering contracting decisions to avoid single-price exposure
Ask yourself: Are you managing risk systematically, or are you still making emotional decisions based on market sentiment and coffee shop talk?
2. Optimize Your Feed Positions
The uncomfortable reality: While we’ll spend hours debating a 10-cent milk price movement, many operations leave dollars per hundredweight on the table through suboptimal feed management.
The divergent outlook for feed ingredients demands a proactive approach:
- Consider longer-term contracting for corn needs, given favorable price projections
- Evaluate rumen-protected protein alternatives to traditional soybean meal
- Invest in forage quality improvements that reduce reliance on purchased proteins
- Review feed center storage capacity – the ability to purchase when prices dip could provide significant advantage
“Feed inventory management is becoming as important as the ration itself,” notes Dr. Tom Overton of Cornell University. “The days of just-in-time purchasing are becoming increasingly risky in volatile markets.”
3. Accelerate Genetic and Management Efficiency Gains
Let’s be brutally honest: Many farms are still selecting bulls as if component prices and feed efficiency don’t matter.
With milk per cow projected to increase, staying competitive means keeping pace with productivity improvements:
- Evaluate your breeding program’s focus on feed efficiency traits like Residual Feed Intake (RFI) and component production
- Consider expanded genomic testing to accelerate genetic progress through more precise culling decisions
- Review facility constraints that might be limiting your transition cow performance
- Assess technology investments that could improve days in milk (DIM) productivity curves while managing labor costs
Ask yourself: Are you still breeding for the same traits you prioritized five years ago, or have you adjusted your genetic strategy to reflect where the market is heading?
4. Strategically Manage Your Herd Size
The myth we need to abandon: That every heifer calf born should become a milking cow.
The dual projections of initially stronger prices followed by potential moderation suggest a measured approach to growth:
- Consider front-loading planned expansions to capture the stronger 2025 price environment
- Evaluate culling decisions with both milk and beef values in mind
- Assess the optimal balance between raising all heifers and strategically incorporating beef genetics
“Think of heifer inventory like your forage inventory,” suggests Dr. Victor Cabrera of the University of Wisconsin-Madison. “Having too many is costly and inefficient, while having too few creates risk during growth opportunities.”
5. Prepare for the Federal Order Changes
The uncomfortable question: Do you actually understand how the Federal Order changes will specifically affect your milk check, or are you just hoping for the best?
With Federal Milk Marketing Order formula changes taking effect June 1, 2025:
- Review how your milk component profile aligns with the new pricing formulas
- Understand how the changes will affect your specific mailbox price calculations
- Consider adjustments to feeding programs that might maximize returns under the new system
The Bottom Line
The May 2025 WASDE report presents a unique opportunity window for progressive dairy producers. The next 12 months offer a potential sweet spot of strong component values, cheaper energy feeds, robust export demand, and valuable cull animals – before supply growth pressures prices in 2026.
But here’s the essential question you need to ask: Are you managing your dairy for where the markets are heading, or for where they’ve been?
The farms that will thrive through this cycle aren’t necessarily the largest ones – they’re the operations that apply strategic thinking to every aspect of their business, from component optimization to feed procurement to risk management.
The opportunity is clear, but the window is narrow. While most operations will continue with business as usual and wonder why margins disappoint in 2026, the industry leaders are already positioning themselves to capitalize on the coming 12 months of opportunity while simultaneously preparing for the challenges that follow.
What’s your plan? Will you continue with the familiar patterns that brought you this far, or will you embrace the strategic shifts needed to thrive in an increasingly volatile market environment?
The choice is yours, but the clock is ticking. Schedule a meeting with your management team this week specifically focused on these 2025-2026 projections. Challenge every assumption about your current operational strategy. Run the numbers on multiple scenarios.
Your 2026 profitability depends on the decisions you make today.
Learn more:
- USDA’s 2025 Dairy Outlook: Market Shifts and Strategic Opportunities for Producers
Explore how evolving milk supply, pricing, and export trends in 2025 demand new strategies for dairy producers. - 11 Proven Strategies to Lower Feed Costs and Boost Efficiency on Your Dairy
Actionable tips for managing feed expenses and improving operational efficiency in the face of rising input costs. - Milk Tsunami Ahead: USDA Exposes 2025 Price Crash Triggers
Analyze the risks of overproduction, price volatility, and discover survival tactics for navigating turbulent dairy markets.
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.
