Sales of plant-based milk alternatives have been skyrocketing in recent years. Of course, no marketer in her right mind would try to sell anything with such a clunky, unappetizing name. Instead, they are sold as cashew milk, almond milk, hazelnut milk and a handful of other “milks” from unlikely sources with names that evoke creamy wonderfulness.
It drives producers of what you might call “traditional” milk — that is, the people who sell the old-fashioned, nutritious white liquid that comes from cows — a little nuts that the purveyors of nondairy drinks are calling their product “milk” and directly competing with the real thing in refrigerated cases across America.
It was one thing when there was just soy milk. But now that there are all manner of “milk” products concocted from the oddest things — cashews, hemp, even quinoa, for heaven’s sake — the dairy industry has had enough. Last month, on its behalf, a bipartisan group of 32 members of Congress from agricultural states sent a letter to the Food and Drug Administration asking for a crackdown on the proliferation of faux lait.
This is no frothy matter to milk producers who have seen decades of decline in milk consumption. “These hard-working Americans have experienced deep cuts in income as milk prices have plunged 40 percent since 2014,” the members of Congress wrote in their letter. The authors include two California congressmen from the state’s agricultural heartland, Rep. David Valadao (R-Hanford) and Rep. Devin Nunes (R-Tulare).
Federal regulations (21 CFR 131.110, to be exact) define milk as “the lacteal secretion, practically free from colostrum, obtained by the complete milking of one or more healthy cows.” And that means, according to the letter from the members of Congress, that it is illegal for milk imitators to profit from using milk’s good name.
But perhaps it is federal regulations that are out of touch with consumer trends. Though it is true that milk alternatives are generally less nutritious than the real thing, which is packed full of protein, calcium, and vitamins A and D, there’s no evidence that consumers have been tricked into buying a less nutritious plant-based alternative or that they’re unaware of the difference. Most people are smart enough to understand that quinoa milk isn’t cow’s milk flavored with quinoa (because, who would buy that?) just as as they can tell the difference between goat’s milk and Milk of Magnesia.
Indeed, Americans’ waning interest in drinking milk may be attributable, in part, to a better understanding of its provenance and production. These days, there are vegans eager to enjoy a bowl of cereal or ice cream without cow’s milk, often because they’re concerned about the treatment of the animals. There are parents concerned about the use of growth hormones in cows. There are people who, for whatever reason, don’t like the taste of cow’s milk and are pleased to have alternatives available.
So far, the FDA hasn’t responded to the letter. Even if the new leadership of the FDA were inclined to expend resources protecting the “milk” brand for the dairy lobby and were to force imitators to change their labels, it’s uncertain whether that would have any effect on consumption habits.
Nor is it clear if a crackdown would stop the word “milk” from being used in labeling. In 2011, the FDA sent a letter to CytoSport Inc. in Northern California warning it to stop mislabeling its popular Muscle Milk brand nutritional shakes because they don’t contain milk. (Happily, it doesn’t contain muscles, either.) Yet, Muscle Milk is still readily available for purchase in major retail stores.
Perhaps that’s because the word “milk” — like its close dairy relations “butter” and “cream” — is a relatively generic term that can’t be easily controlled through trademarks and copyrights.
It’s unfortunate that the dairy industry is blaming milk imitators — rather than a change in consumers’ tastes — for its woes. This is the industry, after all, that came up with one of the more memorable advertising campaigns in recent history: “Got Milk?”
In the end, consumers aren’t really dumb at all. Most of us know by now that there’s no cream in Cream of Wheat, no butter in cocoa butter and no grapes in Grapenuts. Or nuts, for that matter. And we know what milk is, too.
Source: LA Times

A recent iPolitics article by Alan Freeman made the argument
A sculpture paying tribute to the history of environmental stewardship by dairy farmers, and crafted from more than 1,000 pounds of butter, was unveiled today at the 101st Pennsylvania Farm Show in Harrisburg. The sculpture, sponsored by American Dairy Association North East (ADANE), highlights innovative practices to enrich the soil and reduce storm-water runoff, such as crop management, plants and groundcover near streams, streambank fencing, and manure storage facilities.
The announcement of the Master Breeder recipients has become an annual tradition at Holstein Canada, and this year is certainly no exception. Holstein Canada is pleased to announce the 20 Master Breeders who will be honoured at the 2017 National Holstein Convention Master Breeder Banquet in York Region, Ontario on Saturday, April 8, 2017.
Knigge Farms is no stranger to visitors.
Milk prices are expected to remain low. Feed costs are likely to remain high. Experts see little hope for increased federal or state milk subsidies. But Connecticut’s stubborn dairy farmers insist they see better times ahead.
When Joanne Wirtjes asked for stuffed cows for her 9-year-old son, Ryan, she never expected their heard of cattle would become so large.
It’s a New Year’s Day tradition for millions – watching the Rose Parade and the Rose Bowl Game. And each year a million or more from all around the world converge in Pasadena to see one or both, up close and personal.
According to a report from Agri-Pulse, U.S. Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack will become president and CEO of the U.S. Dairy Export Council (USDEC) when he leaves office this month.
Ted Sheppard always loved the land. Living in southern Missouri, where crops were hard to come by but rocks and grass were plenty, he was looking to find a farming endeavor that would fit the terrain and rural lifestyle. So, in 1977 he settled on dairy farming. But after 40 years in the business, this Texas County dairyman fears there will be no next generation in dairying if milk prices do not improve.


Ohio’s prisons agency made about $4.5 million from selling cattle and equipment after shutting down its prison-farm system, according to records from the state Department of Administrative Services.
A day after announcing plans to streamline water quality regulation, the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources emphatically denied that it will allow large dairy producers to write their own pollution permits.
Seated with hundreds of colleagues at the American Cheese Society awards ceremony in Des Moines this past July, Rebecca Williams heard her farm’s name announced not once but twice, for its acclaimed sheep’s milk cheeses.
The driver of a car involved in a collision with a milk tanker in South Taranaki has died.
If you ask Lorraine Lewandrowksi, almond milk is not milk.
A fight over what can be called milk can change the way products are labeled in the dairy aisle. Many plant-based alternatives like soy and almond are called milk, too. But the dairy industry, and some members of Congress, say the label should be reserved for milk from a cow, and they want the government to take action.
A lot of people will have already made up their mind about whether humans need dairy in their diet and will be thinking that the answer is obviously “yes” or obviously “no”. But nutrition is based on science not opinion – so, here’s the latest research on the matter.
The US Ayrshire Breeders’ Association is saddened by the death of our president, James Tentinger of Remsen, Iowa. Jim passed away peacefully on Christmas Day after a valiant fight with cancer.
Residents of the western Minnesota town of Hendricks thought they had won a feedlot war two years ago when they sued to stop a big dairy farm that was being planned just across the border in South Dakota.
An 82-year-old dairy farmer says he’s unsure whether to rebuild after a massive fire destroyed his dairy barn south of Dubuque.
On behalf of everyone here at the Bullvine we extend their most sincere sympathies and condolences to the family and friends of Maryland Holstein breeder Warren Knutsen, of Rising Sun, MD; who recently passed away.
Have you ever wondered how Santa’s reindeer can make that monumental journey on Christmas Eve? Let’s look into some key facts about reindeer that may help us understand how they get Ole St. Nick on his appointed rounds over the world.
When Congress and the Trump administration begin work on immigration reform, Wisconsin’s congressional delegation should make clear our state’s position: Wisconsin needs more legal immigration, not less.
The American Guernsey Association is excited to present this year’s All-American and Junior All-American Nominees. Find them here: 



Cyclical Fluctuations Can Cause Uncertainties For Farmers – And Consumers
Fall Creek area farmer Norm Anderson calmly tells the story of how he and his wife were trapped in a silo Sunday evening, but he knows it could have been much worse.