Milk prices CRASHED in all 11 FMMO regions March 2025—butterfat hits 3-year low. Survival strategies for dairy farmers inside. Are you prepared?
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: March 2025 saw uniform milk prices drop universally across all 11 Federal Milk Marketing Orders, driven by plummeting butterfat values (lowest since 2021) and component price collapses. Class III (cheese) and Class IV (butter/powder) milk took the hardest hits, falling $1.56/cwt and $1.69/cwt respectively, while total pooled milk volume surged despite prices—a self-defeating trend worsening oversupply. The temporary Class I pricing formula provided minor relief but expires June 1, threatening fluid milk stability. With April futures signaling deeper declines and Rabobank forecasting global dairy turbulence, producers face urgent decisions: cull low-efficiency cows, hedge prices, and rethink genetic strategies to survive the structural reset.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Universal Price Collapse: All 11 FMMO regions saw declines ($0.76–$1.49/cwt), with Upper Midwest hardest hit at $18.82/cwt.
- Component Bloodbath: Butterfat crashed 20¢/lb (3-year low), dragging Class IV down $1.69/cwt. Protein held slightly stronger at $2.46/lb.
- Pooling Paradox: Total pooled milk surged 2.16B lbs despite prices—Class III cheese milk hit 6.56B lbs, incentivizing oversupply.
- June Formula Flip: Class I’s “average-of +74¢” safety net ends June 1, risking $0.33–$0.62/cwt losses if spreads widen.
- April Forecast: Futures predict $17.22/cwt Class III and $17.91/cwt Class IV—prepare for inverted spreads and depooling incentives.
The Federal Milk Marketing Order (FMMO) system just delivered a gut punch to U.S. dairy farmers—March milk prices plummeted in all 11 regions, with some zones seeing the steepest drops since 2021. This isn’t a market correction. It’s a warning shot across your barn roof. While industry analysts mumble about “cyclical trends,” The Bullvine’s cutting through the noise to tell you why this crash matters, who’s getting hit hardest, and how to bulletproof your operation before the next shockwave hits.
THE GREAT MILK PRICE PLUNGE: WHAT JUST HAPPENED?
Let’s get raw: Every FMMO region saw prices drop in March 2025, with losses ranging from $0.76 to a brutal $1.49 per hundredweight. The Upper Midwest took the hardest hit—again—with prices cratering to $18.82/cwt. Even Florida’s “haven” fluid milk market didn’t escape, sliding 76 cents to $24.66/cwt. This is like watching your best Holstein drop from 120 to 90 pounds daily—you feel it in your bulk tank and wallet.
Why This Isn’t Just “Business as Usual”
- Butterfat values crashed to a 3-year low ($2.62/lb), dragging Class IV (butter/powder) prices down $1.69/cwt. That’s like watching your TMR mixer break down right before feeding time catastrophic.
- Cheese markets (Class III) dropped $1.56/cwt despite still up $2.28 from last year. Translation: The floor’s falling faster than a fresh heifer on a frozen freestall alley.
- Component values were slaughtered: Protein (-7¢), nonfat solids (-12¢), and other solids (-11¢). This isn’t a dip—it’s a bloodbath worse than a botched dehorning job.
Are you betting on butterfat when it’s worth less than in 2021? The industry pushed high-component genetics for a decade, and now we’re watching that strategy implode in real-time.
CLASS WARFARE: WHICH MILK CATEGORIES GOT HIT WORST?
Fluid Milk’s False Security (Class I)
“Stable” Class I prices? Don’t buy the hype. While the base price only dipped 25¢ to $21.02/cwt, thanks to a soon-to-expire pricing formula. Come June 1, when regulators ditch the “average-of plus 74¢” safety net for the old “higher-of” method, fluid milk could get rocked harder than a fresh-cut haylage pile fermenting in July heat.
Reality Check: Florida’s $26.42/cwt Class I price looks sweet until you realize it’s propped up by zone differentials—artificial life support that’ll vanish faster than silage inoculant in summer heat if processing plants relocate or consumer habits shift.
Manufacturing Milk’s Meltdown (Classes III & IV)
Cheese and butter/powder markets are where the real carnage happened:
- Class IV (butter/powder): Down $1.69/cwt month-over-month and $1.88/cwt year-over-year. That’s like watching your SCC spike from 150,000 to 400,000 overnight.
- Class III (cheese): Despite being up $2.28 from 2024, March’s $1.56/cwt drop exposed its vulnerability faster than a high-producing cow with subclinical ketosis.
The Killer Detail: The Class III-IV spread shrank to just 41¢, removing incentives to depool (removing milk from FMMO revenue sharing). Translation? More milk is stuck in low-value pools, dragging everyone down like mastitis in your best string.
When was the last time your milk check formula got a hard look? Most farmers couldn’t explain their payment structure if their farm depended on it—and it does.
THE DIRTY SECRET NO ONE’S TALKING ABOUT: POOLING PARADOX
Here’s where it gets wild: Milk pooled through FMMOs surged by 2.16 billion pounds in March.
More milk, lower prices—this isn’t supply and demand, it’s a suicide pact-like breeding your entire herd to non-genomic tested young bulls.
Why Farmers Keep Digging the Hole Deeper
- Class III pooling hit 6.56 billion pounds—the highest since August 2024, like watching your neighbors expand their herds during a milk price crash.
- Class IV jumped 685 million pounds despite prices tanking faster than a cow’s calcium levels at freshening.
The Bullvine Take: This isn’t resilience—it’s desperation. Farmers are flooding the system with milk to meet loan payments; unaware they’re collectively suppressing prices. It’s the dairy equivalent of running toward a burning commodity shed because everyone else is. We’ve seen this movie before—2009, 2015, 2020—and the ending always stinks worse than a neglected manure lagoon in August.
Are you part of the problem? If you’re pushing production while prices plummet, you’re helping dig the industry grave. When will we learn that sometimes less milk means more money?
BUTTERFAT’S BLOODBATH: THE SILENT KILLER
March’s butterfat price ($2.62/lb) hasn’t been this low since December 2021. For herds averaging 4% butterfat:
- Loss per cow: ~$0.52/cwt monthly, like watching your feed efficiency drop 0.1 points across the herd
- Annualized hit: Over $6/cwt if trends continue—that’s a full-blown displaced abomasum requiring surgery, not just a mild case of milk fever
Genetic Wake-Up Call: The industry’s decade-long push for higher butterfat is backfiring like a poorly timed CIDR protocol. With component values crashing, that 5% BF superstar might be costing you more feed than she’s earning at the market. Your +1000 GTPI heifer with +0.50% fat PTA isn’t impressive when the market won’t pay for her expensive output.
Has your genetic strategy adapted to the reality of the new market? Or are you still selecting bulls like it’s 2020?
JUNE’S LOOMING DISASTER: THE FORMULA CHANGE NO ONE’S READY FOR
Mark June 1, 2025, in red on your calendar like a problem cow’s hoof wrap. That’s when the Class I pricing formula reverts to the “higher-of” method. Here’s why it matters:
- March Example: The current formula gave farmers an extra 62¢/cwt vs. the old method—the difference between profitable and breakeven for many operations.
- April Forecast: 33¢/cwt cushion—disappearing in June faster than quality hay in a drought year.
Doomsday Scenario: If Class III and IV diverge sharply (like April’s projected 79¢ spread), fluid milk prices could nosedive overnight. Your 2023-24 risk management plans? It is obsolete, like a tie-stall barn in the age of rotary parlors.
How many farmers even know this formula change is coming? The industry’s asleep at the wheel while regulators prepare to pull the rug out from under us. Wake up!
BULLVINE’S SURVIVAL BLUEPRINT
1. Ditch the “More Milk” Mentality
The data’s clear: Producing more milk into a falling market is financial suicide, like feeding a high-cost ration to your lowest-producing string. Cull low-component cows now. If your herd’s butterfat is under 3.8%, ask if she’s worth keeping like you would a chronic mastitis case. Remember: Sometimes, your best cull decision is your most profitable one.
2. Renegotiate Feed Contracts—Yesterday
With corn and soy futures fluctuating, lock in prices now. Every 10¢ saved per bushel puts $0.15/cwt back in your pocket—that’s like finding free bypass protein. Talk to your nutritionist about substituting ingredients without sacrificing rumen health or component production. Consider alternative fiber sources like soyhulls or beet pulp if your forage quality took a hit last season.
3. Hedge Like Your Farm Depends on It (Because It Does)
April’s Class III futures at $17.22/cwt signal more pain ahead. Sell 25% of Q3 production forward, even at these prices. It’s like treating for metritis early painful but necessary to prevent bigger problems. Work with your co-op or milk handler to understand your basis adjustments and ensure you’re not leaving mailbox price premiums on the table.
4. Prep for the June Formula Flip
- Shift milk to Class I buyers before June 1 if your location and quality parameters allow it.
- Diversify: Explore direct fluid sales to bypass pooling—think of it crossbreeding your marketing strategy like you might use beef genetics on your bottom-end heifers.
5. Genetic Pivot
Start selecting for protein, not just butterfat. March’s protein value ($2.46/lb) held stronger than fat, and cheese demand isn’t disappearing like last year’s silage. Review your genetic plan with your AI rep and consider bulls with positive milk and protein that might have been overlooked in the fat-focused era. Remember: Today’s genetic decision impacts your component checks for the next decade—choose wisely.
Is your operation prepared to survive on $17/cwt milk? If not, you need to start making changes today, not tomorrow.
THE ELEPHANT IN THE MILK PARLOR: WHEN WILL IT END?
Rabobank’s global optimism doesn’t match U.S. realities. Here’s our forecast:
- 2025 Q2: Prices keep sliding, hitting $17/cwt by June—like watching your reproduction rate drop 5 points in one month.
- 2026: Margin protection claims surge as feed costs rise faster than a somatic cell counts in a poorly maintained parlor.
- Long Game: 10% of U.S. dairies fold or consolidate by 2026—that’s not a prediction; it’s a mathematical certainty like pregnancy rates after skipping heat detection.
Final Warning: This isn’t 2020’s “COVID crash” or 2009’s recession. It’s a structural reset, like transitioning from conventional to robotic milking. Adapt or become another statistic in the USDA’s declining dairy farm count.
WHEN EXPANSION MIGHT MAKE SENSE
While most operations should be battening down the hatches, there are specific scenarios where strategic growth deserves consideration. For farms with exceptional component efficiency (producing 3.8%+ butterfat at lower-than-average feed costs) or those with direct marketing channels that bypass FMMO pricing entirely, the current environment could present acquisition opportunities as struggling operations exit.
If you’re in a strong equity position with locked-in feed costs and processing contracts, expanding while land and cattle prices soften might position you for the eventual market recovery. However, this strategy requires ironclad risk management and substantial financial reserves—not for the faint of heart or highly leveraged.
Remember, even during downturns, the most efficient producers can remain profitable. The question isn’t just whether to expand but whether your operation has the efficiency metrics to justify growth when others are retreating.
THE BOTTOM LINE
The milk price crash of March 2025 isn’t just another dip in the cycle—it’s exposing fundamental weaknesses in how we produce and market milk in America. The industry’s addiction to volume over value has created a self-destructive pattern crushing margins across all regions.
Your Move: Stop following the herd mentality driving us off a cliff. Reassess your component strategy, cull aggressively, lock in feed costs, and prepare for the June formula change like your farm depends on it—because it does.
Will you be the one who saw it coming or left wondering what hit you? The Bullvine’s betting on the former. Let’s prove us right.
Learn more:
- USDA’s 2025 Dairy Outlook: Market Shifts and Strategic Opportunities for Producers
Explore the USDA’s latest dairy market forecast, including production trends, price projections, and actionable strategies to help producers thrive in a volatile 2025. - USDA’s New Dairy Pricing Rules: The Financial Impact No One Saw Coming
Get the inside scoop on upcoming FMMO reforms, how new pricing rules could shake up your milk check, and what every dairy operator needs to know to stay profitable. - Risk Management
Dive deep into practical risk management tools—like Dairy Margin Coverage and Dairy Revenue Protection—to safeguard your operation from milk price volatility and market shocks.
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Daily for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.
