Butter prices explode 7.75¢ as smart US farmers reap rewards from keeping cows others culled. Are you positioned for what’s coming next?
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The global dairy market just delivered a masterclass in contradictions, with US butter prices rocketing 7.75¢ to $2.42 per pound while Asian futures tumbled across the board. American dairy farmers are reaping massive rewards from a strategic shift in herd management – keeping 385,000 more cows in 2024 despite bird flu chaos, pushing herds to a 3-year peak of 9.425 million head. European markets paint their own picture of strength, with butter trading €1,080 (+17.4%) above last year and cheese premiums hitting 18% year-over-year. The winners in this three-speed global market aren’t those following old playbooks, but operations that maximized cow retention during tight periods, invested in component quality, and built relationships beyond traditional powder buyers. This fundamental shift toward strategic thinking over reactive management is separating the market leaders from the followers, and the positioning window is rapidly closing.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Strategic herd management pays off big: US farmers who resisted culling during tight times kept 385,000 more cows than normal in 2024, driving herds to 3-year highs and positioning themselves for explosive profitability as butter hits $2.42/lb.
- Regional markets are decoupling: European butter strength (+17% year-over-year) and US domestic resilience contrast sharply with Asian futures weakness, creating a three-speed global market that rewards geographic diversification.
- Component quality trumps volume: Cheese markets showing 18% premiums and butter commanding record prices signal that high-component milk and value-added processing are the new profit centers, not commodity powder production.
- Feed costs remain manageable: Despite slight upticks in corn and soybean meal, feed costs stay historically reasonable relative to milk prices, providing a crucial tailwind for margin expansion.
- Simple strategies won’t work anymore: The market now rewards sophisticated thinking – operations still making decisions based on 2022 conditions are leaving serious money on the table as the herd expansion window closes.
US butter prices rocketed 7.75¢ this week to hit .42 per pound – the highest since February – while American dairy herds reached a 3-year peak of 9.425 million cows. Meanwhile, global markets painted a confusing picture, with European butter soaring 17% above last year, but Asian futures are tumbling across the board.
Let’s face it – the dramatic butter surge caught many off guard after three months of sideways trading. But here’s the thing: smart money saw this coming. With US milk production jumping 1.5% in April and component levels running hot, more cream is hitting the market than expected.
What happened here? US dairy farmers pulled off something remarkable. Instead of culling aggressively during tight times, they kept cows in the barn. We’re talking 385,000 fewer culls in 2024 alone, despite bird flu wreaking havoc. This year? Another 190,000 cows were saved from the slaughterhouse compared to normal patterns.
European Markets Paint Different Story
Across the Atlantic, European traders are singing a different tune entirely. But here’s what’s really interesting – EEX futures moved just 225 tonnes last week. That’s pocket change compared to Asia’s massive volumes, right?
German butter jumped €200 in a single week to €7,300, while EU butter averages now sit €1,080 (+17.4%) above last year. That’s not seasonal strength – that’s structural demand meeting constrained supply. What’s driving this kind of premium when everyone’s talking about abundant milk?
The cheese complex tells an even more compelling story. Mozzarella gained €17 to €4,207, now trading €633 (+17.7%) above year-ago levels. When specialty cheese runs 18% premiums, you know something fundamental has shifted in European dairy markets.
French butter retreated €58, showing the regional variations that smart traders exploit. Dutch producers split the difference, gaining €50 to €7,230.
Asian Markets Tell Sobering Tale
While Europeans celebrated, Asian futures told a completely different story. SGX moved 20,842 tonnes – nearly 100 times the European volume – but prices slumped across the board. What’s going on here?
Whole milk powder dropped 2.0% to $3,854, while skim milk powder fell 0.8% to $2,826. The Global Dairy Trade index reflected this weakness, falling 0.9% to $4,589.
This isn’t random market noise. European processors prioritize domestic demand and regional exports, while Oceania suppliers face harsh reality: Chinese import patterns are shifting toward selectivity rather than volume buying. Fonterra Regular WMP managed just $4,350 at the latest GDT event, while Belgian product commanded $4,600 – a spread that speaks volumes about quality premiums in today’s market.
US Producers Rewrite Herd Management Playbook
Here’s where things get fascinating. The real story isn’t just about prices – it’s about how US producers fundamentally changed their approach to herd management. This transformation started during the heifer shortage but has become something entirely different.
Consider these numbers: US dairy farmers culled 35,000 fewer cows than average in 2023. Last year, despite bird flu chaos, they kept 385,000 cows that would normally have headed to slaughter. So far in 2025? Another 190,000 saved. Are you starting to see the pattern here?
Result? The April dairy herd hit 9.425 million head – up 89,000 from last year and the highest since March 2023. April milk production surged to 19.4 billion pounds, the strongest growth since August 2022.
States with new cheese processing capacity are seeing explosive growth. Kansas milk output jumped 11.4% year-over-year, Texas gained 10.6%, and South Dakota posted 9.2% growth. Build it, and they will come – isn’t that exactly what’s happening?
Global Trade Flows Reveal Strategic Shifts
The export picture shows fascinating regional strategies emerging. New Zealand’s dairy exports climbed 10.8% in April, with cheese exports exploding 33.7% year-over-year. This isn’t an accident – it’s strategic repositioning away from commodity powders toward value-added products.
But here’s what’s really interesting: Chinese dairy imports for April tell a complex story. Overall imports were stronger by 13.9% year-over-year, pushing cumulative imports 30% above last year. But dig deeper, and you’ll find this strength comes from strategic stockpiling during temporary tariff windows, not sustained demand growth.
EU dairy exports to the US jumped 33% in March – likely producers rushing products ahead of potential tariff increases. Meanwhile, whey exports to China surged 37%, with whey protein concentrate up 49% and whey protein isolate exploding 176%. What’s driving this sudden appetite for whey products?
Feed Markets Provide Crucial Context
Don’t ignore what’s happening in feed markets. July corn gained 16¢ to $4.59 per bushel, while soybean meal added $4 to $296 per ton. These moves reflect export demand and weather concerns, but feed costs remain historically manageable relative to milk prices.
The slight uptick in grain prices, driven by US weather concerns, creates interesting dynamics for non-US producers who rely on imported feed. They’re facing higher underlying grain prices plus a stronger dollar – a double hit that could accelerate margin erosion. Let’s face it: that’s not a position you want to be in.
What This Means for Your Operation
This market rewards three strategies: strategic herd management, value-added processing, and geographic diversification. But are you positioning your operation to take advantage of these trends?
The winners are operations that maximized cow retention during tight periods, invested in component quality, and built relationships beyond traditional powder buyers. European butter strength, US domestic demand, and selective Asian buying create opportunities for producers who can read between the lines.
Cheese output is climbing in the US, and domestic demand isn’t keeping pace. But strong exports have helped maintain normal seasonal growth. April cheese stocks totaled 1.41 billion pounds, down 2.4% from last year – though that deficit has narrowed in each of the past five months.
Whey markets stepped back, with spot powder falling 0.75¢ to 54.25¢. Chinese importers stocked up on products before temporary tariffs kicked in, boosting April imports by 13.9%. Expect fewer ships arriving this month, but US exporters rush to book sales during the 90-day pause.
The Bottom Line
Here’s the reality: this market just got incredibly complex, and the simple strategies won’t work anymore. European butter strength, US domestic resilience, and Asian selectivity create a three-speed global market that rewards sophisticated thinking.
Smart producers should immediately review culling strategies. If you’re still making decisions based on 2022 market conditions, you’re leaving serious money on the table. The herd expansion window is closing, and correctly positioning will determine who dominates the next cycle.
The global dairy game has fundamentally changed. The producers who recognize this shift – and act on it – will be the ones writing their own success stories in the months ahead. Are you ready to adapt, or will you get left behind?
Learn more:
- The Export Revolution That’s Starving America’s Butter Supply – Dive deeper into the butter market dynamics driving record prices and how export demand is reshaping domestic supply chains.
- Global Dairy Market Trends 2025: European Decline, US Expansion Reshaping Industry Landscape – Explore the broader production shifts between major dairy regions and what they mean for global competitiveness.
- Global Dairy Market in 2025: Production Shifts, Demand Fluctuations and Trade Dynamics – Get additional insights into production changes across key markets and evolving consumer demand patterns affecting trade flows.
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.
