Skip calf nutrition hacks. New meta-analysis reveals the real lever for 10,000+ lbs more milk per heifer. Your grandpa was wrong.
If you’re like most dairy producers, you’ve probably spent countless hours fine-tuning your lactating cow TMR, meticulously balancing amino acids, and running Penn State shaker box tests to squeeze every possible pound of milk from your mature herd. Meanwhile, that group of heifers in your grower pens? They might be the most undervalued asset in your entire operation.
A groundbreaking meta-analysis published in the Journal of Dairy Science reveals a shocking truth: those first 8-10 weeks of a calf’s life set the stage for her entire productive career. Even more startling is how many farms are still following outdated feeding strategies that are literally programming their replacement heifers for mediocrity.
The numbers don’t lie: For every 100 grams of additional daily gain you achieve in a preweaning calf, you can expect an extra 301 kg (664 lbs) of milk during her first lactation alone. Think about that for a moment. Suppose your current preweaning program delivers an average daily gain (ADG) of 0.5 kg when it could be 0.8 kg. In that case, you’re potentially kissing goodbye to over 900 kg (nearly 2,000 lbs) of first lactation milk for every heifer you raise.
Still think those calves sucking down two quarts twice a day in your hutch line is just a necessary expense rather than your most strategic investment opportunity.
The Science That’s Turning Calf Nutrition Upside Down
For decades, conventional wisdom dictated that restricting milk or milk replacers to 10% of body weight would push calves to eat texturized starters earlier, promoting faster rumen development. The theory seemed sound: limit milk to 4 quarts daily, get them off milk faster, save on expensive milk replacers, and develop that rumen just like we’ve always done.
But nature has different plans for baby mammals – including calves.
This comprehensive meta-analysis – reviewing 18 studies encompassing 57 treatment groups – provides the most potent evidence that conventional thinking has been exactly backward. Limiting nutrient intake during this critical developmental window doesn’t create more productive cows – it permanently caps their potential.
“It’s like programming a computer,” says leading calf researcher Dr. Michael Van Amburgh of Cornell University in previous work on this topic. “The nutrition and management a calf receives in those first weeks of life is essentially programming her future productivity.”
The research team behind this meta-analysis meticulously examined the relationship between three key preweaning factors – average daily gain (ADG), liquid dry matter intake (LDMI), and starter dry matter intake (SDMI) – and subsequent first-lactation performance, measuring milk yield, fat yield, and protein yield.
The results weren’t just statistically significant; they were economically game-changing.
The Three Numbers That Will Change How You Raise Calves Forever
When the researchers built statistical models to understand what truly drives first-lactation performance, three critical numbers emerged that should fundamentally reshape your calf program:
1. ADG Supercharges Production: Each additional 100 g/day of preweaning growth translates to 301.65 kg more milk, 10.55 kg fatter, and 11.09 kg more protein in first lactation. This relationship was linear within the range studied (0.34-0.93 kg/day) – meaning higher growth consistently yielded greater returns with no plateauing effect.
That’s like getting an extra 75 CWT of milk from each heifer just by feeding her properly as a calf.
2. Daily, The Magic Number for Milk Feeding: 0.79-0.80 kg of dry matter from liquid feed (milk or milk replacer) created the optimal first-lactation response. This “sweet spot” balances providing enough nutrition for excellent growth while encouraging appropriate starter intake for rumen development.
Think of it like priming a pump – you need just enough initial pressure to get the system flowing. Too little liquid feed and you’re starving the calf; too much and you’re drowning her natural starter appetite.
3. The Starter Surprise: Perhaps most shocking of all – starter dry matter intake alone showed no significant direct relationship with first-lactation performance. This flies directly in the face of decades of advice emphasizing early and aggressive starter intake as the primary driver of future production.
It’s as if we’ve been telling farmers to focus on the trailer when it’s the tractor that’s pulling the load.
Why Most Farms Are Getting It Wrong
If you feed your calves twice daily with a 20/20 milk replacer (20% protein/20% fat) at 1.5-2.0% of body weight (the traditional approach), you’re likely providing only about 0.4-0.5 kg of dry matter daily. According to this meta-analysis, you’re operating at roughly HALF the optimal level.
That feeding program is like trying to fill your milk tanker with half a pipeline – you’re just not going to hit capacity.
The research revealed that preweaning liquid intake follows a quadratic relationship with first-lactation production – too little drastically limits potential, while excessive amounts may be counterproductive. The sweet spot appears to be around 0.8 kg of dry matter daily, which translates to approximately:
- 6-7 liters of whole milk (12.5% solids)
- 6 liters of a properly mixed 150 g/L milk replacer (like Land O’Lakes® Cow’s Match® or Purina® AMPLI-Calf®)
“But what about starter intake and rumen development?” I hear you asking. “My Grandpa always said to get them eating starter as soon as possible!” Here’s where things get truly interesting.
The Great Starter Feed Myth
The relationship between starter intake and first-lactation performance might be the most surprising finding in this analysis. Despite decades of industry emphasis on maximizing early starter consumption to drive rumen development, the data told a different story.
In simple and complex statistical models, preweaning starter intake showed no significant direct association with first-lactation production parameters. Let that sink in for a moment.
This doesn’t mean starter is unimportant – it’s still essential for rumen development and successful weaning. However, the analysis suggests that its primary benefit may be enabling successful weaning and supporting post-weaning growth rather than directly programming future milk production capacity.
It’s like focusing on a heifer’s free-stall training when what matters is her genetics and nutrition – the free-stall training is important for management, but it’s not what drives her milk production.
The takeaway? Prioritizing adequate liquid nutrition to drive growth shouldn’t take a back seat to push starter intake, particularly in the crucial first few weeks of life.
What’s Happening Inside That Calf?
Understanding the biological mechanisms behind these findings helps explain why early growth has such profound long-term effects. It’s not simply about bigger calves becoming bigger cows.
Mammary Development Revolution: Research cited in the meta-analysis found that calves fed higher planes of nutrition showed dramatically increased mammary parenchymal tissue growth – the actual milk-secreting tissue. At weaning, the mammary parenchymal tissue weight of calves fed increased levels of milk replacer was 6 times greater than that of calves restricted in milk intake. This indicates a direct effect of nutrient intake with parenchymal proliferation in the first months of life.
Think about that – you’re building the milk-making machinery during those early weeks. Restrict nutrition, and you’re permanently limiting the size of that machinery. It’s like building a 6-row milking parlor but only installing equipment for three rows – you’ve capped your operation’s potential forever.
Metabolic Programming: Beyond tissue development, early nutrition appears to “program” the calf’s metabolism for life, affecting how nutrients are partitioned and utilized. Calves receiving optimal nutrition during this critical window may be metabolically programmed to direct more nutrients toward milk production later in life.
It’s like how a cropping program sets field productivity – your early-season fertilizer and weed control decisions determine yield potential long before harvest.
Rumen Development Balance: Starter remains critical for rumen development but should be balanced with optimal liquid nutrition. The optimal LDMI level (around 0.79-0.80 kg/d) appears to strike the right balance – providing enough nutrients for excellent growth while encouraging adequate starter intake needed for rumen maturation.
Think of it like breaking in a first-calf heifer – you want her udder developing properly while she’s also learning the milking routine. Both matters, but udder development is the foundation of future production.
Your Three-Step Profit-Boosting Calf Program
Based on this research, here’s how to maximize your return on investment in calf rearing:
STEP 1: Target Aggressive Preweaning ADG
Aim for the upper end of the studied range – 0.8 kg/day or better. This requires:
- Excellent colostrum management (4+ quarts of high-quality colostrum with 22%+ Brix readings within 2 hours of birth)
- Optimal liquid nutrition (see step 2)
- Consistently clean, dry, deeply bedded, draft-free housing (nesting score of 3+)
- Proactive health monitoring to prevent growth setbacks (checking navels, pneumonia scoring, tracking scour days)
- Regular weight monitoring using a scale or weight tape (you can’t improve what you don’t measure)
Remember: Each additional 100 g/day of growth equals approximately 664 pounds more milk in the first lactation. A calf growing at 0.8 kg/day versus 0.5 kg/day could produce an additional 1,992 pounds of milk in her first lactation alone!
At $20/cwt, that’s about $400 in additional milk income per heifer in the first lactation.
STEP 2: Optimize Liquid Feeding
The research considers the optimal target of 0.79-0.80 kg of dry matter from liquid feed daily. This translates to:
- 6-7 liters of whole milk per day (hospital milk works too, but consistent pasteurization is essential)
- OR 6 liters of a properly mixed milk replacer (150 g/L – that’s about 1.5 lbs powder in 2 gallons)
- Divided into at least two feedings (3+ is even better)
Consider a step-down approach rather than abrupt weaning to maximize starter intake during the transition. Begin reducing milk volume gradually 10-14 days before planned weaning, which encourages starter consumption while maintaining adequate total nutrition.
This isn’t unlike transition cow management – you wouldn’t dream of abruptly changing a fresh cow’s diet, so why shock your calves with sudden weaning?
STEP 3: Provide Excellence in Starter Management
While starter intake didn’t directly correlate with first-lactation yield, it remains vital for rumen development and successful weaning. Focus on:
- Providing fresh, palatable starter from day one (texturized with minimal fines)
- Ensuring easy access to clean, fresh water (critical for starter intake)
- Maintaining consistent starter quality and availability (change daily in cold weather)
- Targeting at least 1 kg/day consumption before complete weaning
- Considering a gradual weaning approach to maximize starter intake during the transition
Like your lactating cows won’t perform with inconsistent TMR, your calves need consistent access to high-quality starter feed.
Challenging Industry Sacred Cows: Hard Questions About Current Practices
It’s time to question some industry dogma that this research calls into question:
1. Is Early Weaning Profitable?
The meta-analysis found studies with later weaning (>65 days) reported higher preweaning ADG (averaging 0.84 kg/d) and enhanced first-lactation performance. This challenges the conventional push toward early weaning (6-7 weeks), which still dominates many operations.
The Economics: Yes, feeding more milk for longer costs more upfront. However, the return on investment is compelling if later weaning facilitates significantly higher ADG and translates to hundreds of pounds more milk in the first lactation.
Think about it this way: Would you pull a milking cow out of your herd two months early to save on feed costs? Of course, not – because you understand that the milk income far outweighs the feed expense. The same principle applies to your calves.
Question to Ask: Are you making weaning decisions based on short-term feed costs or long-term production potential?
2. Should We Stop Obsessing Over Starter Intake in Young Calves?
The non-significant relationship between SDMI and first-lactation yields suggests we may overemphasize early starter consumption, particularly in the first 3-4 weeks.
Rethinking Priorities: Rather than restricting liquid feed to force starter intake in young calves focus first on providing optimal liquid nutrition to drive growth and development. Gradually encourage starters as calves age, particularly during the weaning transition period.
It’s like focusing on high-quality PMR for your fresh cows rather than pushing maximum dry matter intake in the first week – you want nutrients first, volume later.
Question: Are you limiting liquid nutrition based on outdated advice about forcing starter intake?
3. Is Your Milk Replacer Formulated for Optimal Growth?
Standard 20/20 milk replacers (20% protein/20% fat) may not provide the optimal nutrient profile for maximizing preweaning growth. Research suggests higher protein formulations (26-28% protein) may better support the development identified in this meta-analysis.
Question: Is your milk replacer selected based on price per bag or its ability to deliver optimal growth? Are you trying to save $10 per bag while potentially leaving $400 in milk production on the table?
The Economic Reality: Crunching the Numbers
Let’s use current milk and input prices to put some dollars and cents into these findings. Consider a 1,000-cow dairy raising 500 replacement heifers annually:
Scenario 1: Conventional Program
- ADG: 0.5 kg/day
- LDMI: 0.5 kg/day (2 feedings of 2-2.5L each)
- Daily milk replacer cost: $1.75/calf
- Expected first-lactation milk: Baseline
Scenario 2: Optimized Program
- ADG: 0.8 kg/day (+0.3 kg/day)
- LDMI: 0.8 kg/day (2-3 feedings totaling 6L)
- Daily milk replacer cost: $2.80/calf (+$1.05/day)
- Expected first-lactation milk increase: +900 kg per heifer (based on +301 kg per 0.1 kg ADG)
Financial Impact:
- 500 heifers × 900 kg additional milk = 450,000 kg additional milk in first lactation
- At $20/cwt milk value = $198,000 additional milk revenue from the first lactation alone
Additional Costs:
- Extra milk replacer: Approximately $60-80 per calf × 500 calves = $30,000-$40,000
- Potential labor increase: $10,000-$20,000 (depends on current systems, automation potential)
Net Benefit: $138,000-$158,000 in first lactation alone
That’s like finding an extra four tanker loads of milk every year without adding a cow to your barn!
And this doesn’t factor in potential benefits in subsequent lactations, improved reproduction, or enhanced longevity!
What the Research Doesn’t Tell Us (Yet)
While this meta-analysis provides powerful insights, several critical questions remain that could further refine our approach to calf nutrition:
- Upper Limits: What happens at ADG levels exceeding 0.93 kg/day? Do the benefits continue linearly, plateau, or potentially decline?
- Beyond First Lactation: How do preweaning nutrition effects persist through multiple lactations and overall productive life?
- Specific Nutrients: Does the composition of the liquid diet (protein percentage, fat sources, specific additives like plasma proteins or gut health enhancers) matter beyond simply the amount of dry matter provided?
- Genetic Interactions: Do calves with different genetic potential respond differently to enhanced early nutrition? Should your genomic-tested elite heifer calves be fed differently than those that will be sold or used for ET recipients?
- Health Impacts: How does optimized early nutrition affect lifetime health and reproductive performance? Do those well-fed calves also show better conception rates, fewer metabolic disorders after calving, and increased longevity?
Industry leaders should watch for emerging research in these areas to refine calf-feeding approaches.
What’s Standing in Your Way? Overcoming Common Obstacles
If the evidence for optimized calf nutrition is compelling, why haven’t more farms adopted these approaches? Let’s address the common barriers:
“It Costs Too Much”
This reflects short-term thinking. Yes, doubling liquid feed amounts increases immediate costs. But when each $1 invested potentially returns $3-4 in additional first-lactation milk alone, it’s not a cost – it’s your highest-return investment opportunity.
How many production-enhancing feed additives do you feed your lactating cows that promise a 3:1 ROI? Now look at this calf-feeding ROI.
“We Don’t Have the Labor”
Labor constraints are real. Consider:
- Automated feeding systems like the DeLaval CF1000 or Lely Calm can deliver optimal nutrition with less daily labor
- Group housing with appropriate feeding systems can reduce per-calf labor
- The long-term reduction in health issues and improved growth can reduce overall labor needs
Many dairies report that calves on higher planes of nutrition are easier to manage – fewer health treatments, more vigorous calves, and more predictable growth patterns.
“Our Facilities Won’t Allow It”
Transitioning to optimized nutrition may require the following:
- Re-evaluating housing to ensure it can support faster-growing calves
- Potentially modifying group sizes or pen moves
- Investing in better ventilation and bedding to support healthier calves
Remember: Facility limitations aren’t eliminating the cost of suboptimal nutrition – they’re just hiding it in the form of lost future production. That’s like saying your parlor can only milk cows once daily, so you accept the 40% production loss as “unavoidable.”
“We’ve Always Done It This Way”
The most dangerous phrase in farming. The evidence is clear: traditional restricted feeding approaches permanently cap your herd’s productive potential. The question isn’t whether you can afford to change – it’s whether you can afford not to.
Would you still be milking in a tie-stall barn with bucket milkers simply because “that’s how we’ve always done it”?
A Call to Action: Revolutionize Your Calf Program in 90 Days
Ready to transform your calf program based on this research? Here’s a practical 90-day implementation plan:
Days 1-30: Assessment and Planning
- Establish current baseline ADG through accurate weighing
- Analyze current LDMI and feeding protocols
- Evaluate starter quality and consumption patterns
- Calculate the economic impact of proposed changes for your operation
- Develop updated protocols for feeding, weaning, and monitoring
Days 31-60: Implementation
- Begin enhanced feeding program with rigorous monitoring
- Train staff on new protocols and the “why” behind changes
- Establish a consistent weighing schedule
- Begin collecting growth data under new program
- Address any challenges in housing, labor, or management
Days 61-90: Refinement
- Analyze initial growth data and adjust as needed
- Fine-tune weaning protocols based on starter intake
- Address any health challenges that emerge
- Calculate preliminary financial impacts
- Develop a long-term monitoring program
Beyond 90 Days: Long-term Tracking
- Continue regular growth monitoring
- Track these calves through their first lactation
- Calculate actual ROI when they enter the milking herd
- Share success stories with industry peers
The Future of Calf Nutrition is Here
The meta-analysis reviewed here represents the most comprehensive research synthesis on preweaning growth and subsequent lactation performance. Data from 18 studies encompassing 57 treatment groups provides the most substantial evidence yet that how we feed calves in those first critical weeks fundamentally shapes their lifetime productive capacity.
The progressive dairy producers who embrace these findings – targeting ADG of 0.8 kg/day or better, providing optimal liquid nutrition of around 0.8 kg DM/day, and ensuring appropriate starter intake for successful weaning – will raise a generation of dairy cows with dramatically enhanced productive potential.
Those who cling to outdated restricted feeding approaches, prioritizing short-term feed savings over long-term production potential, will increasingly find themselves at a competitive disadvantage. Their herds will simply be unable to match the production efficiency of operations embracing optimized early-life nutrition.
The science is precise. The economics are compelling. The choice is yours.
Will you continue programming your calves for mediocrity? Or will you unlock their full genetic potential through nutrition that aligns with biology and profitability?
Your next generation of 40,000-pound first-lactation cows is in your calf barn. What you feed them today will determine what they produce tomorrow.
Key Takeaways for Your Calf Feeding Revolution
- Target aggressive preweaning ADG (0.8+ kg/day) – Each 100g/day increase adds approximately 301 kg more milk in the first lactation
- Provide optimal liquid nutrition (0.79-0.80 kg DM/day) – This “sweet spot” maximizes growth while encouraging appropriate starter intake
- Balance starter intake with liquid nutrition – Starter remains essential for rumen development but shouldn’t come at the expense of adequate liquid nutrition, especially in young calves
- Consider later weaning (8+ weeks) – Studies with later weaning showed higher ADG and enhanced first-lactation performance
- Monitor growth regularly – You can’t improve what you don’t measure; implement a consistent weighing program
- Calculate your return on investment – The economic benefit of optimized calf nutrition extends far beyond the first lactation, creating a compelling business case for change
- Challenge traditional thinking – The evidence increasingly suggests that many long-held beliefs about “economical” calf raising may be programming your herd for underperformance
The bottom line? Your calf program isn’t just raising replacement heifers – it’s programming your herd’s future productive potential. Invest accordingly.
This article was developed based on the meta-analysis “Effects of preweaning calf daily gain and feed intake on first-lactation performance: A meta-analysis” published in the Journal of Dairy Science (2025). The analysis included data from 18 studies with 57 treatment groups examining the relationships between preweaning factors and subsequent lactation performance.
Key Takeaways:
- Growth is non-negotiable: 0.8kg/day preweaning ADG = 10,463kg avg first-lactation milk (+301kg/100g gain)
- Liquid feed sweet spot: 6-7L/day (0.79-0.8kg DM) maximizes milk yield – too little starves potential, too much risks starter intake
- Starter’s hidden role: No direct milk link, but critical for rumen development and avoiding post-weaning growth crashes
- Profit math: $3-4 ROI per $1 invested in optimized calf nutrition through first-lactation gains alone
- Challenge tradition: Later weaning (>65d) and aggressive feeding beat restrictive “save milk” approaches long-term
Executive Summary:
A landmark meta-analysis of 18 studies proves preweaning calf growth directly programs future milk output: Every 100g/day gain before weaning adds 664 lbs of first-lactation milk. While liquid feed shows a “Goldilocks zone” (0.8kg/day optimal), starter intake’s value lies in rumen prep – not milk yield. The data torpedoes outdated “restrict milk to boost starter” strategies, revealing linear returns on growth investments with no plateau. Producers prioritizing ADG ≥0.8kg/day could see $180K+ added milk revenue per 500 heifers.
Learn more:
- From Calf Starter to TMR: The Key to Early Heifer Development
- Revolutionizing Calf Rearing: 5 Game-Changing Nutrition Strategies That Deliver 4-20 ROI for Every Dollar Invested
- Re-evaluating Dairy Calf Nutrition for Long-Term Benefits
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.
