Stop culling immediately. Mexico’s cattle crisis just made your ‘problem’ cows worth $200+ more. Smart genomic timing = 20% profit boost.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The dairy industry’s sacred cow of “immediate culling” is costing producers massive profits in today’s transformed market environment. With the USDA’s indefinite suspension of Mexican cattle imports driving cull cow values to $145/cwt—a 15-20% premium over traditional pricing—strategic dairy producers are abandoning outdated culling practices for data-driven retention programs. Operations implementing genomic-guided culling decisions combined with market timing are capturing $150-$200 premiums per head, translating to $175,000-$300,000 in additional annual profitability for large commercial dairies. While conventional wisdom preaches rapid disposal of declining producers, forward-thinking operations are leveraging precision agriculture technologies, body condition scoring matrices, and breeding value evaluations to optimize timing and maximize returns. The convergence of beef supply constraints, elevated protein demand, and advanced dairy genetics creates a once-in-a-decade opportunity for producers willing to challenge traditional management paradigms. Stop following 20-year-old culling protocols and start treating your cull cow program as the strategic profit center it’s become.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Genomic-Driven Market Timing: Integrate genomic testing with body condition scoring to identify high-value retention candidates—operations report 12-18% higher total revenue per animal when strategic culling replaces reactive disposal protocols.
- Technology-Enhanced Profit Capture: Deploy precision monitoring systems (activity tracking, automated BCS, feed efficiency analysis) to optimize culling decisions—farms using integrated data systems achieve 15-20% productivity increases while reducing health expenses by 30%.
- Cross-Market Arbitrage Opportunity: Leverage beef market disruptions for dairy profit—with grain prices rising 8-12% but cull cow values appreciating 15-20%, margin expansion opportunities exist for producers who master feed cost hedging and strategic retention timing.
- Risk-Managed Strategic Holding: Implement tiered culling protocols based on production metrics, genetic merit, and cash flow capacity—high-liquidity operations targeting $175,000-$300,000 additional annual profitability through extended retention of superior genetics during peak market periods.
- Global Competition Advantage: Position operations to capture domestic protein premiums as U.S. beef exports fall 6% in 2026—dairy producers who understand protein market interconnections gain competitive edge through strategic cull cow marketing and enhanced milk protein positioning.
The USDA’s indefinite ban on Mexican cattle imports isn’t just reshaping the beef industry—it’s creating unprecedented opportunities for forward-thinking dairy producers who understand how to leverage cross-market dynamics. While beef producers scramble, smart dairy operators aim to capture significant value from elevated cull cow prices, strategic feed procurement, and protein market disruptions that could boost profitability by 15-20% over the next two years.
The dairy industry operates in an interconnected protein economy where beef market disruptions create ripple effects that smart producers can ride to profitability. What’s happening in beef markets right now represents the biggest structural shift we’ve seen since the COVID-19 pandemic created similar supply chain chaos. But here’s what most producers are missing: this isn’t just about beef. It’s about understanding how market disruptions create profit opportunities for those who can read the signals correctly.
But here’s the million-dollar question: Are you still managing your cull cow program like it’s 1995, or are you treating it as the strategic profit center it’s become?
Why Are Beef Markets Suddenly Critical to Your Dairy Operation?
Think of the protein economy like a giant milking parlor—the whole system has to adjust when one stall goes down. On May 11, 2025, the USDA essentially shut down a major “stall” in the North American protein system by suspending live cattle imports from Mexico due to New World screwworm detection 700 miles from the U.S. border. This isn’t a temporary hiccup—it’s an indefinite suspension that’s fundamentally rewriting North American livestock economics.
The reality check should grab every dairy producer’s attention: U.S. beef production is forecast to drop 5% in 2026 to 25.14 billion pounds, marking the fourth consecutive year of decline. Fed steer prices are projected to hit $222.75 per hundredweight in 2026, while feeder steers are forecasted at $306.25 per cwt, representing new record highs.
But the number that should really light up your spreadsheet? Cull cow prices are forecast at $145 per cwt in 2025, a 5% year-over-year increase. For a 1,000-cow dairy culling 25% annually, that’s an additional $1,125 in gross revenue per cull cow—or $281,250 in total increased value from your culling program alone.
Why This Matters for Your Operation: The Protein Premium Effect
When beef supplies tighten, your dairy operation benefits through three channels most producers underestimate. First, cull cow values increase because processing plants need every pound of beef they can source. Second, domestic protein demand strengthens across all categories, potentially boosting fluid milk consumption and cheese demand. Third, feed ingredient markets shift as beef operations compete more aggressively for quality feedstuffs.
Consider this analogy: if beef is the premium protein “first-string quarterback,” dairy has traditionally been the reliable “utility player.” But when the quarterback gets injured, suddenly, that utility player becomes far more valuable to the team’s success.
Here’s the uncomfortable truth most dairy consultants won’t tell you: The traditional “cull at the first sign of trouble” mentality that dominated the industry for decades is now costing you money. With cull cow values rising 15-20% faster than feed costs, selective retention becomes a profit strategy, not just a production decision.
What’s Driving This Market Transformation?
The fundamentals are creating a perfect storm that dairy producers can navigate to their advantage. Feedlots are keeping cattle on feed longer than ever before, with the number of cattle on feed over 150 days rising 4% from year-ago levels as of April 1. This represents the highest level since the COVID-19 pandemic disruptions in 2020.
Think about what this means from a feed efficiency perspective. It’s like extending lactation curves beyond their optimal point—you’re increasing total production per animal but at diminishing marginal returns. Feedlots treat their facilities like expensive storage units, betting that higher future prices will offset increased feed costs and reduced feed conversion efficiency.
The weight game that the beef industry has relied on for years is ending. Cattle weights are expected to plateau in 2026 after jumping 6% from 2023-25. For the first time in years, the industry can’t rely on heavier carcasses to mask declining animal numbers—just like dairy producers can’t rely solely on increased milk per cow to offset smaller herd sizes.
Current Market Dynamics: The Numbers That Drive Decisions
Let’s translate these beef market fundamentals into dairy-relevant metrics that affect your bottom line:
Current Price Environment:
- April 2025 fed steer prices: $213.80/cwt (+$30 from 2024)
- May 2025 fed steer prices: $220.97/cwt (+$35 year-over-year)
- April 2025 feeder steer prices: $298.22/cwt (+$44 from 2024)
Forecast Trajectory:
- 2025 annual fed steer price: $214.51/cwt (+15% from 2024)
- 2025 annual feeder steer price: $298.53/cwt (+15% from 2024)
- 2026 cull cow prices: Expected to exceed $145/cwt
For context, a 1,400-pound cull cow at $145/cwt generates $2,030 in gross revenue—compared to $1,933 at last year’s prices. That $97 difference per head becomes substantial when multiplied across your annual culling program.
But here’s what puzzles me: Why are so many dairy producers still using the same culling criteria they learned 20 years ago when market dynamics have fundamentally changed?
How Smart Dairy Producers Are Already Positioning for Profit
The most successful dairy operations I’m tracking aren’t just watching these developments—they’re actively repositioning their operations to capitalize on them. It’s like optimizing breeding decisions based on genomic testing results—you use available data to make strategic choices that improve long-term profitability.
Challenging Conventional Wisdom: Rethinking the Cull Cow Timeline
Here’s where I will challenge decades of conventional dairy wisdom: The industry’s obsession with immediately culling at the first sign of production decline or health issues is leaving massive profits on the table in today’s market environment.
Traditional dairy management taught us to cull aggressively and immediately. Get rid of problems fast. Move inventory quickly. That approach made sense when culling cow values were relatively stable and feed costs were predictable. But those days are over.
Consider the research from Progressive Dairy, which shows that strategic retention of older cows with declining production, but good body condition can generate 12-18% higher total revenue per animal when timed correctly. This isn’t just about holding onto every cow—it’s about making data-driven decisions based on current market realities rather than outdated management philosophies.
Genomic Integration: Making Smarter Culling Decisions
Here’s where genetics meets market opportunity: Modern dairy operations use genomic testing not just for breeding decisions but to optimize cull cow timing and maximize genetic value retention.
California dairyman Tony Lopes discovered that genomic testing revealed “the traits they had thought their herd may be high or low in were sometimes the opposite.” More importantly, for today’s market environment, genomic data helps identify which older cows carry superior genetics worth retaining longer, especially when cull cow values are appreciating faster than feed costs.
Strategic Genomic Applications for Market Timing:
- Genomic testing of borderline cull candidates to identify the hidden genetic value that justifies extended retention
- Parent verification programs to ensure accurate genetic records for high-value breeding stock decisions
- Breeding Value Evaluation (BVE) analysis to identify cows whose genetic merit supports longer productive lives
Recent research shows that female genomic selection combined with strategic breeding decisions significantly accelerates genetic gain while improving herd profitability (Impact of Implementing Female Genomic Selection). In today’s elevated cull cow market, this genetic intelligence becomes even more valuable—you’re not just optimizing for production, you’re optimizing for total economic return.
Optimizing Cull Cow Marketing Strategy: Beyond Traditional Metrics
Your cull cow program just became a significant profit center that requires the same analytical rigor you apply to genetic selection or feed efficiency monitoring. With beef cow slaughter expected to continue declining through 2026, every quality cull cow you hold represents appreciating inventory.
Strategic Culling Timeline Based on Market Dynamics:
- Immediate (June-August 2025): Market cows with obvious health issues, chronic mastitis (SCC >400,000), or severe locomotion scores
- Delayed (September-December 2025): Hold productive older cows (4+ lactations) that would normally be culled for age
- Strategic (2026): Market retained cows during peak price periods, likely Q2-Q3
Implementation Framework: Body Condition Scoring for Market Timing
Think of this like managing transition cow protocols—you need systematic evaluation and decision points. Here’s your assessment matrix:
| Cow Category | Current Production | Body Condition Score | Genomic Merit | Market Timing | Expected Premium |
| Immediate Cull | 60 lbs/day | BCS 3.0+ | Superior genetics | 6-12 months | +$150-$200/head |
Feed Procurement Strategy: Navigating the New Economics
Here’s where most dairy producers are missing the bigger picture. The same supply constraints driving cattle prices create feed cost pressures that smart operators can navigate—or exploit. It’s like adjusting ration formulations when corn prices spike—you need to understand the entire cost structure, not just individual ingredient prices.
Feed Market Implications for Dairy Operations:
- Corn demand is increasing as feedlots extend feeding periods
- Hay markets are tightening as cattle stay on feed longer
- Protein supplement costs are rising due to reduced domestic meat production
But there’s an arbitrage opportunity hiding in plain sight. While grain prices rise 8-12% over 18 months, the protein value you’re producing through milk and eventual cull sales is growing 15-20%. The spread between input costs and output values is widening in your favor—if you manage it correctly.
Advanced Feed Cost Risk Management:
Drawing from recent industry analysis, successful dairy operations implement multi-layered feed cost strategies (Feed Cost Revolution: Why 2025-26 Could Be Your Most Profitable Year Yet). Here’s your comprehensive risk mitigation framework:
Immediate Protective Actions (Next 60 Days):
- Lock corn contracts below $4.20/bushel for 6-month forward coverage
- Secure soybean meal for around $300/ton when opportunities arise
- Diversify protein sources, including alternative feeds like distillers grains and canola meal
- Implement precision feeding systems that can reduce feed costs by 7-12% while improving production
Medium-term Strategic Positioning (6-18 Months):
- On-farm feed production expansion to capture margin and ensure supply security
- Crop sharing agreements with local farmers for predictable pricing
- Feed storage optimization to take advantage of seasonal price cycles
- Ration reformulation protocols that maintain production while managing cost volatility
Why This Matters for Your Operation: The Feed Efficiency Equation
Consider a 1,000-cow dairy consuming 50 tons of corn daily. An 8% price increase represents $200,000 in additional annual feed costs. However, if cull cow revenues increase by per head on 250 annual cull sales, that’s ,250 in additional gross revenue. Add strategic timing premiums of $100 per head, and you’re capturing $49,250 in total increased value.
The key insight: you’re not just managing feed costs—you’re managing margin expansion opportunities across your entire operation.
Yet here’s what I find fascinating: Most dairy producers can tell you their exact feed cost per hundredweight of milk, but how many can tell you their optimal cull cow holding cost versus expected price appreciation? That’s a massive blind spot in today’s market.
Global Market Context: Learning from International Responses
What’s happening in the U.S. isn’t occurring in isolation—major dairy regions worldwide are experiencing similar protein market pressures, creating opportunities for strategic positioning.
European Union: Sustainability Constraints Create Opportunity
EU sustainability mandates are constraining production growth while increasing compliance costs. European dairy farmers face phosphate limits that challenge expanding cow numbers, creating export opportunities for U.S. dairy products (Reproductive management in dairy cows – the future). This regulatory environment means European producers focus on compliance rather than volume expansion, potentially opening market share for strategically positioned U.S. operations.
Strategic Implications:
- Reduced European competition in key export markets
- Premium pricing opportunities for sustainability-certified U.S. dairy
- Potential for technology transfer as EU operations seek efficiency solutions
Asia-Pacific: Demand Growth Outpacing Supply
Growing protein demand in Asia, particularly China and India, is outpacing domestic supply capacity. The combination of rising incomes and dietary westernization creates sustained demand for high-quality dairy products, while domestic production faces land and water constraints.
Market Positioning Opportunities:
- Chinese market re-entry potential as trade relationships stabilize
- Indian processing modernization creates partnership opportunities
- Southeast Asian growth markets for value-added dairy products
Oceania: Climate Variability Challenges
New Zealand and Australia remain cost-competitive but face increasing climate variability challenges. Their focus on grass-based systems provides lessons for sustainable production but may limit their ability to capitalize on premium market opportunities during supply disruptions.
Competitive Advantages for U.S. Producers:
- Technology integration superiority in precision agriculture and data analytics
- Supply chain resilience through diversified feed sources and storage capacity
- Scale advantages in processing and logistics infrastructure
Technology Integration: Data-Driven Culling Decisions
The most successful operations leverage precision agriculture technologies to optimize these market opportunities. Think of it like using genomic testing to improve breeding decisions—data-driven approaches consistently outperform intuition-based management.
Revolutionary Technology Applications:
- Activity Monitoring Systems: Track individual cow behavior patterns to identify optimal culling timing
- Precision Feeding Systems: Monitor individual cow feed efficiency to evaluate retention economics (Precision Dairy Feeding – University of Idaho)
- Automated Body Condition Scoring: Use computer vision technology for objective evaluation tools
Recent research indicates that farms using IoT technologies see a 15-20% productivity increase while reducing health-related expenses by 30% (How IoT and Analytics Are Transforming Farms in 2025). Key implementation strategies include:
Production Optimization:
- Monitor individual cow milk yield trends to identify optimal culling timing
- Track somatic cell count (SCC) patterns to evaluate health status
- Evaluate Dry Matter Intake (DMI) efficiency for cost-benefit analysis
- Analyze lactation curves to optimize replacement timing
What This Means for Different Dairy Operation Types
The impact of these market shifts varies dramatically based on your operation’s structure, but the opportunities are universal. It’s like implementing automated milking systems—the technology works everywhere, but the ROI depends on your specific circumstances (Robotic Milking Revolution: Why Modern Dairy Farms Are Choosing Automation in 2025).
Large Commercial Operations (1,000+ cows): Scale Advantage Strategies
Your volume gives you negotiating power that smaller operations can’t match. Think of it like bulk milk pricing—your scale creates opportunities requiring strategic thinking.
Cull Cow Program Optimization:
- Implement genomic testing on borderline cull candidates to identify hidden genetic value
- Use activity monitoring data to identify subclinical health issues before they affect market value
- Negotiate forward contracts with processors for premium pricing on quality culls
Advanced Risk Management for Large Operations:
- Dairy Margin Coverage (DMC) optimization to stabilize margins during volatility (Market Mayhem Reshapes Farm Profitability in 2025)
- Multi-commodity hedging strategies for both feed costs and cull cow revenues
- Weather derivative contracts to protect against climate-related feed cost spikes
Feed Cost Management:
- Lock in grain contracts for the next 6 months at current prices
- Investigate on-farm feed production expansion to capture margin
- Consider crop sharing agreements with local farmers to secure feed supplies
Expected Impact: Operations this size should target $175,000-$300,000 in additional annual profitability through optimized cull cow timing and feed cost management.
Medium Family Operations (300-999 cows): Flexibility Focus
You’re in the sweet spot for capitalizing on market timing. Your advantage is being able to read local market conditions and adjust quickly—like adjusting milking frequency during heat stress periods.
Strategic Positioning:
- Use precision agriculture tools to monitor individual cow production and make real-time culling decisions (5 Technologies That Will Make or Break Your Dairy Farm in 2025)
- Implement body condition scoring protocols to optimize cull cow market timing
- Leverage local feed sourcing relationships to secure competitive pricing
Technology Integration: Modern dairy operations benefit from data-driven decision making. Consider implementing:
- Activity monitoring systems to track estrus and health events (Choosing an Activity System for Your Dairy)
- Automated body condition scoring using computer vision
- Feed management software to optimize Total Mixed Ration (TMR) efficiency
Tailored Risk Management:
- Dairy Revenue Protection (Dairy-RP) insurance to protect against price volatility
- Local feed sourcing contracts to reduce transportation costs and improve supply security
- Selective culling protocols that balance cash flow needs with market optimization
**Small Operations (80% of decisions | Monthly evaluation | Technology integration |
Here’s the final challenge I’ll leave you with: Most dairy producers can recite their latest DHI test results from memory, but how many have calculated the specific break-even point for holding versus marketing their cull cows in today’s market environment, integrated with their genomic data and feed cost projections? That calculation could be worth tens of thousands of dollars to your operation.
The producers who treat this as a strategic opportunity rather than a market disruption will emerge stronger and more profitable. The cattle crisis is reshaping protein markets permanently—make sure your dairy operation is positioned on the winning side of that transformation.
Action Item: Complete a comprehensive evaluation of your current cull cow inventory using standardized body condition scoring and genomic evaluation by July 15, 2025 (Dairy Profit Squeeze 2025: Why Your Margins Are About to Collapse). Every month of delay represents potential profit left on the table in this unprecedented market environment.
Remember: fortune favors the prepared operation in dairy farming, as in all agriculture. The data is clear, the opportunity is real, and the window is open. Your next move determines whether you capture this value or watch others profit from your hesitation.
The uncomfortable question every dairy producer must answer: Will you tell the story of how you capitalized on the cattle crisis opportunity by combining market intelligence with genetic optimization, or will you explain why you missed the greatest profit opportunity in a generation?
Learn More:
- Dairy Profit Squeeze 2025: Why Your Margins Are About to Collapse and What to Do About It – Reveals practical strategies for implementing aggressive cost control and strategic culling programs when margins tighten, including specific DMC coverage recommendations and feed optimization tactics that complement the cattle crisis opportunity timing.
- Navigating 2025: What Lies Ahead for the U.S. Dairy Industry – Demonstrates how shifting trade dynamics with Mexico and China create broader market opportunities beyond cull cow pricing, providing strategic context for positioning dairy operations in volatile protein markets.
- 5 Technologies That Will Make or Break Your Dairy Farm in 2025 – Shows how precision feeding systems and AI-driven analytics can optimize the data-driven culling decisions discussed in the main article, with specific ROI calculations for technology investments that enhance market timing strategies.
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.
