Stop chasing daily cheese prices. Smart producers focus on the $26/cow feed cost surge that’s crushing margins while everyone watches butter.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: While dairy farmers obsess over daily CME price swings, the real profit killer is hiding in plain sight: feed cost volatility that just spiked soybean meal futures to $320.10/ton. Our latest market analysis reveals why progressive operations are shifting from reactive price-watching to proactive margin management, especially with USDA’s improved 2025 milk price forecast of $21.60/cwt (+$0.50 from previous projections) creating a narrow window for strategic hedging. The data shows March 2025 margins hit $11.55/cwt, but rising protein costs threaten to slash that by 15-20% for unprepared operations. Global production dynamics from China’s 2.6% decrease and Europe’s modest recovery are reshaping export opportunities, yet most U.S. producers remain focused on yesterday’s butter decline instead of tomorrow’s margin protection. This comprehensive CME analysis connects the dots between trading volume patterns, bid-ask spreads, and actual farm-gate profitability – revealing why the smartest operators are already locking in feed costs while others debate cheese differentials.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Feed Cost Reality Check: Soybean meal’s surge to $320.10/ton represents a potential $26/cow monthly increase in protein costs, making immediate hedging strategies critical for maintaining the current $11.55/cwt margin advantage
- Trading Intelligence Advantage: CME bid-ask patterns reveal NDM showing 5 bids vs. 2 offers while butter faced 6 offers vs. 1 bid – smart money is positioning for export demand strength that could boost powder premiums by 8-12% through summer
- Strategic Timing Window: USDA’s upgraded 2025 milk price forecast to $21.60/cwt (+$0.50) combined with projected 2026 softening creates an optimal 6-month window for selective forward contracting at current Class III levels around $19.16/cwt
- Global Market Leverage: China’s 2.6% production decline and modest European recovery position U.S. exports for significant growth, but only operations with controlled feed costs can capitalize on the margin expansion opportunity
- Margin Management Evolution: March 2025’s $11.55/cwt margin represents peak profitability that reactive management will erode – proactive feed procurement and selective milk pricing strategies can maintain 85-90% of current margins through volatile periods
Today’s CME dairy markets delivered a mixed message to producers, with Cheddar cheese prices maintaining their footing while butter took a notable 7-cent hit. Despite the weakness of butter, the overall picture suggests milk prices are finding support, particularly for Class III pools, though rising feed costs demand immediate attention from farm managers.
Today’s Price Action & Farm Impact
| Product | Price | Daily Change | Weekly Trend | Impact on Farmers |
| Butter | $2.4550/lb | -7.00¢ | +13.80¢ | Could temper Class IV gains despite strong weekly performance |
| Cheddar Blocks | $1.9475/lb | -0.25¢ | +2.92¢ | Stable pricing supports Class III milk premiums |
| Cheddar Barrels | $1.8700/lb | +0.50¢ | +1.17¢ | Continued strength reinforces the Class III outlook |
| NDM Grade A | $1.2850/lb | Unchanged | +4.75¢ | Steady export demand supporting powder markets |
| Dry Whey | $0.5750/lb | +0.50¢ | +2.97¢ | Positive movement adding to Class III component value |
Market Commentary: Today’s session revealed the resilience of the cheese complex, with barrels gaining slightly while blocks experienced only minor pressure. This stability indicates sustained demand for cheese products, the primary driver of Class III milk pricing. However, butter’s sharp 7-cent decline suggests some weakness in fat markets, potentially reflecting ample supply conditions or temporary demand softening. The unchanged NDM price reflects consistent but moderate export interest, while dry whey’s modest gain provided additional support to Class III component calculations.
Volume and Trading Activity
Today’s trading activity revealed selective buyer interest across the dairy complex:
| Product | Trades | Bids | Offers | Trading Pattern |
| Butter | 4 | 1 | 6 | Light trading with heavy offer pressure |
| Cheddar Blocks | 5 | 1 | 2 | Moderate activity, tight bid-ask spread |
| Cheddar Barrels | 6 | 1 | 2 | Most active cheese trading, steady demand |
| NDM Grade A | 4 | 5 | 2 | Strong bidding interest, limited offers |
| Dry Whey | 1 | 2 | 1 | Minimal activity but balanced interest |
The bid-ask dynamics paint a telling picture: NDM showed the strongest buyer interest with five bids against only two offers, while butter faced significant selling pressure with six offers overwhelming single bid interest. This trading pattern aligns with the price movements and suggests underlying supply-demand imbalances across products.
Feed Cost & Margin Analysis
Current Feed Futures:
- Corn (July): $4.4700/bu
- Corn (December): $4.4125/bu
- Soybeans (July): $10.5075/bu
- Soybeans (November): $10.3625/bu
- Soybean Meal (July): $320.10/ton ⚠️ Significant increase
- Soybean Meal (December): $308.50/ton
Margin Alert: The most concerning development for dairy producers is the sharp jump in July soybean meal futures, which gained substantially from previous levels. This protein cost increase directly threatens income-over-feed-cost margins, particularly as milk prices face mixed signals.
Milk-to-Feed Ratio: With June Class III futures at $19.16/cwt and current feed prices, the milk-to-feed ratio remains workable but under pressure. The escalating soybean meal component demands proactive feed procurement strategies from producers who haven’t already secured protein sources for summer feeding programs.
Global Context & Export Dynamics
International Production Trends: According to a recent Rabobank analysis, global dairy production from major exporting regions is expected to increase by 0.8% in 2025, driven by a gradual recovery in Europe and the United States. However, China faces a significant 2.6% decrease in dairy production due to reduced cow numbers and unfavorable economic policies, potentially increasing import demand.
Export Competitiveness: The U.S. dairy sector continues benefiting from sustained export demand, particularly from key destinations, including Mexico, Southeast Asia, and traditional markets. New Zealand’s focus on value-added products and EU production shifts toward cheese manufacturing may create additional opportunities for U.S. powder exports.
Currency and Trade Factors: Current exchange rates and ongoing trade policies influence U.S. competitiveness in global markets, with Chinese tariff impacts still affecting whey pricing dynamics.
USDA Forecasts & Production Outlook
Updated USDA Projections: The USDA recently raised its 2025 U.S. milk production forecast to 227.3 billion pounds, reflecting modest herd expansion and improved productivity. This represents a 0.4 billion pound increase from previous projections, supported by both increased cow numbers and milk per cow improvements.
Price Forecasts: The all-milk price forecast has been increased to $21.60/cwt for 2025, up $0.50 from previous projections. However, 2026 prices are projected to be slightly lower at $21.15/cwt, reflecting anticipated commodity price softening.
Production Fundamentals: First quarter 2025 data shows U.S. milk production at 56.7 billion pounds, down 0.3% year-over-year despite a 58,000-head increase in the national dairy herd. The March 2025 all-milk price averaged $22.00/cwt, up $1.30 year-over-year, while the Dairy Margin Coverage farm margin reached $11.55/cwt.
Market Sentiment & Industry Intelligence
Market participants expressed cautious optimism about current conditions, though concerns remain about sustainability:
“The cheese market continues to feel well-supported heading into late spring, with inventory concerns keeping buyers active despite some price volatility,” noted one industry analyst, reflecting the mixed signals in today’s session.
Another trader observed, “Butter remains the outlier in today’s complex, with domestic supplies appearing more than adequate despite some positive international cues we’ve seen recently.” This sentiment aligns with butter’s 7-cent decline despite otherwise stable market conditions.
Regarding powder markets, one market participant commented, “The bidding we’re seeing in NDM reflects export interest remaining solid, with buyers showing confidence in international demand continuing through the summer months.”
Regional Market Spotlight
Upper Midwest: Wisconsin and Minnesota continue experiencing gradual cow inventory adjustments, with some operations expanding while others optimize herd sizes. Regional processing capacity remains adequate, though transportation costs impact milk flow efficiency.
Western States: Texas, South Dakota, and Idaho lead national herd growth, offsetting reductions in traditional dairy regions. These expansion areas benefit from modern facilities and efficient production systems, though feed cost management remains critical.
Northeast: Fluid milk markets maintain Class I differentials that support regional pricing, though competition from expanding western production creates ongoing market dynamics.
Forward-Looking Analysis
Futures Positioning:
- June Class III: $19.16/cwt (down from $19.34 previous session)
- June Class IV: $18.48/cwt (unchanged)
These futures levels provide critical benchmarks for producers evaluating forward contracting opportunities. The slight Class III decline reflects today’s mixed cash market performance, while Class IV’s stability despite butter weakness suggests underlying strength in the component complex.
Seasonal Outlook: As spring flush conditions moderate and summer feeding challenges approach, typical seasonal production patterns should provide underlying price support. Global production increases remain modest, suggesting balanced supply-demand conditions ahead.
Risk Factors:
- Rising feed costs, particularly soybean meal, pose the most immediate margin threat
- Weather patterns affecting both milk production and feed crop development require monitoring
- Global trade dynamics and policy developments could impact export demand patterns
- USDA projections suggest potential price moderation in 2026, requiring strategic planning
Actionable Farmer Insights
Pricing Strategies: The relatively stable cheese market and butter weakness create mixed signals for forward contracting. Producers should evaluate partial position-taking for Class III milk if current futures align with profitability targets, particularly given USDA’s improved price forecasts.
Risk Management: Today’s soybean meal surge highlights the critical need for proactive feed cost management. Producers without adequate protein source coverage should explore hedging options immediately to protect margins against further cost escalation.
Production Planning: Current milk and feed price relationships support efficient production practices, with USDA margin data confirming favorable conditions. Review breeding and feeding programs to optimize component production while managing input costs.
Cash Flow Planning: Anticipate milk payment timing based on current market trends and cooperative payment schedules. Factor potential feed cost increases into operational cash flow projections while considering USDA’s favorable 2025 price outlook.
The Bottom Line
Today’s dairy markets demonstrated the complex dynamics facing producers as we head into summer. While cheese strength supports Class III milk pricing and provides optimism for upcoming milk checks, the butter decline and significant soybean meal cost increase demand attention. Smart producers will focus on feed cost management while capitalizing on the relative stability in cheese pricing for strategic forward contracting decisions.
The current environment rewards proactive risk management and strategic thinking over-reactive decision-making. Monitor feed markets closely and consider your exposure to rising protein costs as the most immediate operational priority. With USDA forecasts supporting improved 2025 pricing but warning of potential 2026 moderation, this may represent an optimal window for selective forward pricing strategies.
Continue following TheBullVine.com for comprehensive daily dairy market intelligence that connects global market developments directly to your farm gate profitability.
Learn More:
- Feed Cost Revolution: Why 2025-26 Could Be Your Most Profitable Year Yet—or Your Biggest Missed Opportunity – Reveals strategic feed procurement methods that could save $1,500+ monthly while navigating the protein cost challenges highlighted in today’s soybean meal surge, with actionable hedging strategies for defensive margin protection.
- Good News for Dairy in 2025: Higher Milk Prices, Lower Feed Costs Ahead – Demonstrates how USDA’s latest forecasts create specific opportunities for $1.4 billion in increased milk receipts, providing the broader economic context behind today’s market movements and forward pricing strategies.
- The Digital Dairy Revolution: How IoT and Analytics Are Transforming Farms in 2025 – Practical strategies for integrating market data with production systems to optimize component production and increase revenue by 3-5%, turning today’s price volatility into predictive advantage for strategic decision-making.
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Weekly for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.
